In the autumn of 1478 a pope signed a short document that let two monarchs appoint their own judges of heresy. Within a few years those judges were burning people in Seville, and the tribunal they founded lasted, with interruptions, until 1834. To see why Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile wanted such a court, one has to go back nearly a century, to a wave of violence and conversion that changed who counted as a Christian in Spain.
Inquisitions before the Spanish one
The word inquisition comes from the Latin for an inquiry. In the 1230s popes began sending friars, mostly Dominicans, to hunt heresy in southern France and northern Italy, and their courts are usually called the medieval inquisition. The Crown of Aragon had papal inquisitors from the thirteenth century, and one of them, the Catalan Dominican Nicolau Eymerich, wrote the Directorium Inquisitorum of 1376, a handbook on how to try heretics. Later inquisitors in Spain still consulted it, and a new edition was printed in Rome in 1578. Castile, the larger kingdom, had never had such a court. What made the tribunal of 1478 different was not the idea of inquiring into faith but who controlled it: its judges were chosen by the crown, not sent by Rome.
The conversos
In 1391 riots swept through the Jewish quarters of Castile and Aragon. Thousands of Jews were killed and many more accepted baptism to save their lives. Further conversions followed in the early fifteenth century, driven by fiery preaching, by a long public disputation held at Tortosa in 1413 and 1414, and by laws that squeezed Jewish life. The converts and their descendants were called conversos, or New Christians. How many there were is unknown; estimates run to many tens of thousands, and none is reliable.
Freed from the legal limits placed on Jews, many conversos rose fast. They became royal tax officials, town councillors, physicians, merchants and even bishops. Some married into old noble families. Others kept certain Jewish customs, such as lighting candles on Friday evening or avoiding pork, sometimes out of belief and sometimes out of habit. Families were often divided, with Jewish and Christian relatives living side by side. Old Christians, whose families had never been Jewish, increasingly asked whether the converts were really Christians at all.
Toledo, 1449
The resentment broke into the open at Toledo in 1449. A revolt against a royal tax, led by the nobleman Pero Sarmiento, turned on the conversos, who were blamed because some collected the king's revenue. The rebels issued a decree known as the Sentencia-Estatuto, which barred people of converso descent from holding public office in the city. It is often treated as the ancestor of the purity of blood rules that later spread across Spain.
The decree was challenged at once. Pope Nicholas V condemned it in 1449, declaring that all baptized Christians formed one people. Inside Spain the strongest defense came from Alonso de Cartagena, bishop of Burgos. His father, Pablo de Santa María, had been a rabbi in Burgos before his baptism around 1390 and later became bishop of the same city. In his Defensorium unitatis christianae, Cartagena argued that the Church could not divide its members by ancestry, since baptism made a convert fully a Christian.
The case for a new court
Others drew the opposite conclusion. Around 1460 the Franciscan friar Alonso de Espina wrote the Fortalitium fidei, or Fortress of the Faith, which attacked Jews, Muslims and false converts and called for an inquisition to root out secret Judaism. King Henry IV of Castile asked for one in the 1460s, and a plan drawn up with the Hieronymite friar Alonso de Oropesa came to nothing. When Isabella won the throne after a civil war in 1474 to 1479, the demand was waiting for her.
Historians still weigh the motives. Some stress sincere fear for the faith; others stress money, since the property of condemned heretics went to the crown; others point to the monarchs' wish to tighten control over towns and nobles. A further question shapes everything else: how many conversos were actually practicing Judaism in secret? The evidence for an answer comes largely from the tribunal's own trial records, which is itself a problem, since people on trial do not always tell the truth, and neither do their accusers.
Worked example: one family across three generations
Follow a single family. Solomon ha-Levi was chief rabbi of Burgos in the 1380s. Around 1390 he was baptized, took the name Pablo de Santa María, studied theology in Paris, served as tutor to a royal prince and in 1415 became bishop of Burgos. His son Alonso de Cartagena succeeded him in the same see in 1435 and represented Castile at the Council of Basel. Within two generations a rabbi's family held one of the great bishoprics of Castile.
Now apply the Toledo decree of 1449 to them. Had it been the law of the whole kingdom, Alonso de Cartagena, a bishop and royal diplomat baptized as a small child, could have been shut out of city office for his father's past. That is why he wrote: the decree did not ask what a person believed or did, only where his family came from. The tension between those two tests, belief and ancestry, runs through the whole history of the Spanish Inquisition. The tribunal was founded to judge belief, yet the society around it kept sliding toward judging blood.
