The Holocaust was the deliberate, state-organized murder of about six million Jews by Nazi Germany, its allies and its collaborators. Most of the killing took place between 1941 and 1945, but it grew out of years of persecution that began in 1933. Any honest study of it starts with the people who were killed, because the Nazis set out to destroy not only lives but a whole civilization. In 1933 about nine and a half million Jews lived in Europe, well over half of all the Jews in the world. They were not a single community. They differed in language, religious practice, politics, wealth and how they saw their neighbors.
Citizens in the west
In Germany, France, Britain, Italy and the Netherlands, most Jews spoke the national language at home, worked in trade, the professions, science or the arts, and saw themselves as citizens who happened to follow a particular faith. German Jews had gained full legal equality by 1871, when the new German Empire was founded. They were a small minority: under 1 percent of Germany's people were Jewish in 1933, a little more than 500,000 people, and many married non-Jews or drifted from religious observance. About 100,000 German Jews served in the First World War and some 12,000 died. In 1916, as rumors spread that Jews were dodging the front, the War Ministry ordered a count of Jewish soldiers. Many Jewish veterans felt insulted by the country they had bled for.
The heartland in the east
Most of Europe's Jews lived farther east. Poland had Europe's largest Jewish community, about 3.3 million people, close to a tenth of the country. Millions more lived in the Soviet Union, Romania, Hungary, Lithuania, Latvia and Czechoslovakia. Many lived in small market towns that Yiddish speakers called a shtetl, where Jews could be half or more of the population, and many more in big cities such as Warsaw, Lodz, Vilna and Odessa. Their everyday language was Yiddish, a Germanic language written in Hebrew letters, enriched with words from Hebrew, Aramaic and Slavic tongues. Yiddish had daily newspapers, theaters, novels and poetry, and from 1925 it had its own research institute, YIVO, founded in Vilna to study Jewish language, folklore and history.
Many ways of being Jewish
Religious life was varied. Hasidic Jews, followers of an eighteenth century movement that prized joyful prayer and devotion to charismatic rebbes, lived beside traditionalists who put the study of the Talmud in academies called yeshivas at the center of life. Others followed the Jewish Enlightenment and mixed religious learning with modern schooling. Politics was just as lively. The Bund, a Jewish socialist party founded in 1897, wanted Jews to win equal rights where they already lived, an idea it called "doikayt," or hereness. Zionists wanted a Jewish homeland in the ancient Land of Israel. Theodor Herzl, a Viennese journalist, had laid out that program in The Jewish State in 1896, and in a novel of 1902 he wrote, "If you will it, it is no dream."
Many chose to leave. Between 1880 and 1924 more than two million Jews moved from Eastern Europe to the United States, fleeing poverty and violence. That road largely closed when an American law of 1924 sharply cut immigration from Eastern and Southern Europe, a fact that would matter terribly in the 1930s.
Neighbors and pressures
Jewish life in Europe was rich, but it was not secure. Waves of pogroms, mob attacks on Jews, struck the Russian Empire in the 1880s and in 1903 to 1906, and during the civil wars in Ukraine from 1918 to 1921 tens of thousands of Jews were killed. Between the wars, several new states treated Jews as outsiders. In 1920 Hungary passed a numerus clausus law that capped the number of Jews admitted to universities. In Poland, nationalists organized boycotts of Jewish shops, and by the late 1930s some universities forced Jewish students to sit on separate benches. Yet in 1933 nobody, Jewish or not, imagined what was coming. Most Jews expected hardship and discrimination, which they had survived before, not a plan to kill every Jewish man, woman and child.
Worked example: a town in photographs
Eishyshok, a small town now in Lithuania and then in Poland, had a Jewish community that local tradition traced back many centuries. In late September 1941 about 3,500 Jews from the town and nearby villages were shot over two days by a German unit and local auxiliaries. Yaffa Eliach survived as a small child. Decades later she tracked down survivors and relatives across the world and collected their family pictures: weddings, school classes, a girl on a bicycle, young men posing in new suits, a family around a holiday table. Hundreds of those photographs now line a three-story tower at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, known as the Tower of Faces.
Ask what the tower does that a statistic cannot. A figure of six million is too large to picture; the tower shows individual faces. It also corrects a quiet distortion. If we meet Jews of this period only as victims in striped uniforms, we see them only through their killers' eyes. The photographs show people with plans, quarrels, jobs and jokes, many of them with no idea how short their future would be. That is the right place to begin: with a world that was lived in, not with its ending.
