Skip to main content

The Nazis did not invent hostility toward Jews. They inherited a long tradition, gave it a new and more lethal form, and then gained the power of a modern state to act on it. Historians usually distinguish two strands that fed into Nazi thinking: an older religious hostility and a newer racial one.

Religious anti-Judaism

For many centuries Christian preaching taught that the Jews as a people bore guilt for the death of Jesus and had been rejected by God. Medieval Europe added the blood libel, the false charge that Jews murdered Christian children for ritual purposes, and accusations that Jews poisoned wells. Jews were expelled from England in 1290 and from Spain in 1492, and in many cities they were confined to separate quarters. The word "ghetto" comes from Venice, where Jews were made to live in a walled district from 1516, an area named after a foundry. Religious hostility was cruel, but it held out one way out, at least in principle: a Jew who converted to Christianity was supposed to be accepted.

Racial antisemitism

In the nineteenth century, pseudo-scientific race theories claimed that humanity was divided into biological races with fixed traits, ranked from higher to lower. Some writers recast the Jews as a race whose supposed faults were carried in the blood. The word "antisemitism" was popularized around 1879 by the German journalist Wilhelm Marr, who wanted a term that sounded modern and scientific. The shift mattered enormously. Racial antisemitism left no escape through conversion, since baptism could not change a person's ancestry. It also fed a conspiracy myth of great flexibility. Jews were cast as secret masters of the world who pulled the strings of both banks and revolutions, so that the myth blamed Jews for both capitalism and communism, whatever a listener happened to fear.

The Dreyfus affair

Antisemitism was not only a German problem. In 1894 a French army captain, Alfred Dreyfus, who was Jewish, was convicted of spying for Germany on forged evidence and sent to Devil's Island. When the real culprit was identified, the army protected him. France split in two. In January 1898 the novelist Emile Zola published an open letter, "J'accuse," charging the army with a cover-up, and he wrote, "Truth is on the march, and nothing will stop it." Zola was convicted of libel and fled to England, but Dreyfus was fully cleared in 1906.

A forgery that would not die

The most influential antisemitic text of the century was a fake. The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, which claimed to record a secret Jewish plan for world domination, first appeared in a Russian newspaper in 1903. In 1921 The Times of London showed that the Protocols were copied from a French satire of 1864, Maurice Joly's attack on the emperor Napoleon III, which had nothing to do with Jews. Exposure did not stop it. Henry Ford's newspaper in Michigan promoted it in the early 1920s, and the Nazis later made it required reading in schools.

The Nazi worldview

Adolf Hitler and his movement saw history as an endless struggle between races for land and survival. They placed so-called Aryans, and Germans above all, at the top, and they cast Jews not as one race among others but as a parasite that undermined every healthy nation from within. The goal was a "people's community," a nation bound by blood, from which Jews, and later the disabled, Roma and others judged unfit, were to be removed. Many Germans believed the stab-in-the-back myth, which claimed Germany lost the First World War because of traitors at home, socialists and Jews above all, rather than defeat in the field.

The party won only 2.6 percent of the vote in 1928. As the Depression deepened it surged, and in July 1932 it became the largest party in the Reichstag, yet its best showing in a fully free national election was about 37 percent. Many voters backed it for jobs, order or anticommunism, and accepted its antisemitism rather than voting for it. How central hatred of Jews was to ordinary Germans remains disputed. In 1996 Daniel Goldhagen argued that a long German tradition of "eliminationist" antisemitism made ordinary Germans willing killers. His critics, including many historians of the period, replied that the thesis ignored the many non-German perpetrators, the variety of German opinion before 1933 and the role of war, careerism and conformity.

Worked example: unmasking a forgery

Philip Graves, the Times correspondent in Constantinople, was handed an old French book by a Russian emigre. Graves set passages side by side. Joly's Machiavelli explains how a ruler can manipulate the press, the courts and public credit; the Protocols put almost the same sentences in the mouths of Jewish elders.

Notice the method. Graves did not argue about whether Jews were trustworthy. He asked where the document came from and whether its text could be traced to something older. That is still the strongest test of a conspiracy text: find its source, look for borrowed passages and anachronisms, and ask who first circulated it and why. Notice also the limit. Proof of forgery reached readers of one newspaper; the forgery kept selling for decades because people who wanted it to be true did not care where it came from.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the conspiracy myth blame Jews for?
2. Why was racial antisemitism more dangerous than the older religious kind?
3. What did Daniel Goldhagen argue in 1996?
4. Who popularized the word "antisemitism" around 1879?
5. What share of the vote did the Nazi party win in 1928?
6. Where does the word "ghetto" come from?
7. What did Emile Zola publish in 1898?
8. What did The Times of London show about the Protocols in 1921?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia