It is tempting to tell the Cuban story as a straight road from the troubles of the early republic to Fidel Castro. The 1940s complicate that story. For about a dozen years Cuba had competitive elections, a progressive constitution and peaceful transfers of power. How that order lost the public's trust is one of the most instructive parts of the whole history.
The Constitution of 1940
After ruling through a series of puppet presidents, Batista agreed to a constitutional assembly, elected in 1939. Its members ranged from conservatives to Communists. The Constitution of 1940 promised social rights such as a minimum wage, social security and limits on large landholdings, alongside free elections and civil liberties. Many of its promises depended on laws that were never passed, but it became a reference point. For the next two decades nearly every opponent of the government, including the young Fidel Castro, claimed to be fighting to restore it.
Batista himself won the presidential election of 1940 and governed until 1944, with the Communists among his allies; they held cabinet posts and led the main labor federation. In 1944 his chosen successor lost to Grau San Martín, and Batista handed over power and left for Florida.
The Auténtico years
Grau, and after him Carlos Prío Socarrás, led the Auténtico party, heir to the hopes of 1933. They governed in good years for sugar and largely respected civil liberties. But their administrations became notorious for embezzling public funds on a vast scale. Politics was scarred as well by gangsterismo: armed "action groups," many born in the student movement, that fought one another in the streets and around the University of Havana, often protected by officials who paid them with government jobs.
Chibás and the politics of honesty
The loudest critic of the corruption was Senator Eduardo Chibás, who broke away in 1947 to found the Orthodox Party. Its symbol was a broom, and its central cause was honest government. Chibás's Sunday radio talks drew enormous audiences. In August 1951, having failed to produce proof for a corruption charge against a minister, he shot himself just after a radio broadcast, apparently believing he was still on the air, and died eleven days later. The Orthodox Party was expected to do well in the elections of 1952.
The coup of 10 March 1952
Batista, back from Florida and running for president, was trailing third in the polls. In March 1952, less than three months before the election, he seized power in a nearly bloodless coup. Washington recognized the new government within weeks. Many Cubans met the coup with a shrug, which says a good deal about how little faith the elected politicians had left them.
A prosperous country?
By Latin American standards Cuba in the 1950s was well off. Its income per head was among the highest in the region, it had many doctors, radios and televisions, and Havana was a glittering destination. But the averages hid deep divides. Sugar supplied some four fifths of exports, and cane workers faced the "dead time," months without work between harvests. Rural Cubans had far less schooling, health care and electricity than city dwellers, and Black Cubans faced discrimination at clubs, beaches and workplaces.
The Moncada attack
Fidel Castro, a 26 year old lawyer and Orthodox activist, chose armed revolt. On 26 July 1953 Castro led an attack on the Moncada barracks in Santiago with more than a hundred young men and two women, Haydée Santamaría and Melba Hernández. The attack failed within hours, and soldiers tortured and killed many of the captured rebels. At his trial Castro delivered a long defense, later published under a title declaring that history would absolve him, which promised to restore the 1940 Constitution, give land to small farmers and punish corruption. Sentenced to fifteen years, he was freed by an amnesty in May 1955 and went to Mexico to train an expedition. There he met an Argentine doctor, Ernesto "Che" Guevara.
Worked example: was Cuba poor?
Supporters of the revolution often describe prerevolutionary Cuba as a land of misery; its critics describe a prosperous country ruined by revolution. Both draw on real numbers. Income per head was high for the region, and the 1953 census found that roughly three quarters of Cubans over ten could read. Yet the same census showed literacy and housing far worse in the countryside, and seasonal unemployment left many families without income for much of the year.
The way to handle such a dispute is to ask what each number measures. An average describes a whole country, but it says nothing about how income is spread. Prosperity also does not settle the political question. Many historians note that the rebellion's early leaders were mostly middle class and that its first cause was the restoration of constitutional government after a coup, not hunger. Others answer that rural poverty and dependence on sugar explain why the revolution, once in power, turned so quickly to land reform and found such strong support. A careful student can hold both facts: Cuba was neither a ruin nor a paradise, and a dictatorship that blocked peaceful change gave many kinds of grievance a single target.
