Skip to main content

The republic born in 1902 had a flag, a president, elections and a constitution. It also had a powerful neighbor with the legal right to land troops, and an economy that rose and fell with a single crop. The three decades that followed taught Cubans a hard lesson in disappointment, and the anger it produced fed every movement that came after.

Interventions

The first president, Tomás Estrada Palma, was an honest administrator who nonetheless secured re-election in 1906 through fraud. When the Liberals rose against him, he asked Washington to intervene and then resigned. American forces occupied Cuba a second time, from 1906 to 1909, after the disputed election, under the governor Charles Magoon, whose rule many Cubans remembered for easy public jobs and new debt. Marines landed again in 1912 and 1917 to protect American property during uprisings. Cuban politicians learned to appeal to Washington instead of to voters. The word "Plattism" came to mean a habit of political dependence.

The massacre of 1912

Afro-Cubans had made up a large share of the liberation army, and many expected the republic to reward their sacrifice. Instead they found themselves kept from good jobs and official posts. In 1908 veterans led by Evaristo Estenoz and Pedro Ivonet founded the Independent Party of Color, which sought equal treatment and public jobs for Black Cubans. Congress responded with the Morúa Law of 1910, named after a Black senator, Martín Morúa Delgado, which banned parties organized by race. When the party staged an armed protest in May 1912 to demand legal status, the government answered with overwhelming force. Troops and volunteer militias killed thousands of Black Cubans, many of them uninvolved in the protest. Estimates of the dead run from about 2,000 to 6,000.

Sugar's boom and bust

American investment poured into sugar, railways, utilities and banks. During the First World War, European beet sugar fields were ruined and prices soared. In 1920 the price peaked and then fell by more than three quarters within months. Cubans called the 1920 sugar boom and crash the "Dance of the Millions." Cuban banks failed, and American banks and companies bought up mills cheaply. Depending on one export sold mainly to one buyer left the country exposed to decisions made in Washington, such as changes to the American sugar tariff.

Machado and the revolution of 1933

Gerardo Machado, elected in 1924, began with ambitious public works. Then in 1928 he had the constitution changed to extend his term and was re-elected unopposed. When the Great Depression struck, sugar prices sank again and opposition spread. Students, a secret society called the ABC, labor unions and the young Communist Party, cofounded in 1925 by the student leader Julio Antonio Mella, fought the regime with bombs and strikes, and its police answered with murder.

In 1933 the American envoy Sumner Welles tried to arrange a managed exit. A general strike finished the job, and Machado fled in August. Weeks later, on 4 September, sergeants and enlisted men led by Sergeant Fulgencio Batista took over the army in the Sergeants' Revolt and joined students in installing a government under the physician Ramón Grau San Martín. In about a hundred days it decreed an eight hour workday, autonomy for the university, and a rule that half the workers in any business must be Cuban born. It also declared the Platt Amendment void. Washington withheld recognition, and in January 1934 Batista, now army chief, pushed Grau out. His successor was recognized within days.

The new government then gained what Grau had demanded. In May 1934 a treaty with the United States ended the Platt Amendment but kept Guantánamo as an American base. That year a provisional constitution also gave Cuban women the vote. For the next quarter century Batista would be the central figure in Cuban politics, whether in the presidency or behind it.

Worked example: a nation above race?

The massacre of 1912 raises a question that reaches beyond Cuba: when does an ideal of a nation without races protect equality, and when does it hide inequality? Martí had taught that Cubans were more than white or Black, and many Afro-Cuban veterans shared that hope. The supporters of the Morúa Law used the same language. A party organized by color, they argued, was itself a kind of racism that would divide the nation and invite another American intervention.

The founders of the Independent Party of Color replied that the ideal was being used against them. Black Cubans faced real exclusion from jobs, clubs and offices, and a rule against naming the problem left it untouched. Seen this way, the law turned a hope into a gag.

Weighing the two positions, a student can grant that the unifying ideal had real moral force and helped make Cuba's independence army one of the most racially mixed of its time. A student can also see that ideals are tested by who enforces them and against whom. Neither argument justifies what followed, since no reading of national unity excuses the killing of thousands of citizens. The lasting point concerns equal dignity: a promise of equality is measured by whether those left out may speak and organize to claim it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. When did American forces occupy Cuba for a second time?
2. What did the Independent Party of Color seek?
3. What did the Morúa Law of 1910 do?
4. What was the "Dance of the Millions"?
5. How did Gerardo Machado extend his rule in 1928?
6. Who led the Sergeants' Revolt of September 1933?
7. What did the 1934 treaty with the United States do?
8. Which reform did Grau's hundred day government decree?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia