The Commune was crushed in a week, but arguing about it has never stopped. Its defeat shaped the French Third Republic, its memory divided France for generations, and socialists, anarchists and conservatives around the world each claimed to know what it meant. This final level follows the aftermath and the competing interpretations.
Trials and deportation
Repression continued long after the fighting. Tens of thousands of Parisians were arrested, some held for months in camps and in the hulks of ships. Military courts heard the cases for years. About ten thousand people were convicted. Death sentences were passed on dozens, and a smaller number were carried out, including that of Rossel, shot at Satory in November 1871 at the age of twenty-seven.
The most common heavy penalty was transportation. Several thousand Communards were deported to New Caledonia, a French colony in the South Pacific, among them Louise Michel and Nathalie Le Mel. Michel taught there and sympathized with the Kanak people when they rose against colonial rule in 1878. Others escaped into exile in London, Brussels and Switzerland. Courbet, held responsible for the Vendôme Column, was ordered to pay for its rebuilding and died in exile in Switzerland in 1877.
Pressure for forgiveness grew as republicans gained power. A partial amnesty came in 1879, and a full amnesty for Communards followed in 1880. Survivors returned, and many resumed political life.
A conservative republic
One paradox stands out. The Commune was defeated by a government led by a conservative, yet the regime that emerged was a republic. Thiers became president in 1871 and argued that a conservative republic could keep order. Monarchists forced him out in 1873, but they could not agree on a king, and in 1875 a series of constitutional laws established the Third Republic, which lasted until 1940. For some, the bloody suppression proved that a republic could be trusted with order. For others it remained the republic's founding crime.
On Montmartre, the hill where the rising began, the Catholic church built the basilica of Sacré-Cœur, approved by the Assembly in 1873 as a vow of national penance after defeat. Many on the left saw it as a monument against the Commune, raised over the place where it started. Its defenders said it expressed repentance for the war as a whole.
The great interpretations
Karl Marx wrote an address for the International, published in 1871 as The Civil War in France, which praised the Commune as the first government of the working class. In 1891 Friedrich Engels pointed to it as an example of what he called the dictatorship of the proletariat, and in 1917 Lenin drew on both men to argue that workers must not take over the old state but replace it. In this tradition the Commune was a dawn: the first attempt at a workers' state.
Anarchists such as Mikhail Bakunin and Peter Kropotkin read it differently. They praised the Commune's federalism, its rejection of a central state, and blamed its failures on the Jacobin wish to concentrate power. The song "The Internationale," written by the Communard Eugène Pottier in June 1871 and later set to music by Pierre De Geyter, carried its memory into labor movements everywhere.
Many historians since the 1960s have stressed other motives. Research by Jacques Rougerie on those arrested found that most were artisans and workers from small trades, not factory hands. He suggested the Commune was less the dawn of a new kind of revolution than the last of the nineteenth century's Paris revolutions, driven by patriotism, republicanism and the demand for municipal liberty. Tombs has likewise emphasized its ordinary, local character.
Worked example: the wall
Visit the Mur des Fédérés in Père Lachaise. A plain stone plaque reads, in French, "To the dead of the Commune, 21 to 28 May 1871." Since 1880, when the amnesty allowed exiles to return, the left has marched to this wall every May.
Read the site as a historian. The plaque chooses its dates: it remembers the Communards killed, not the hostages of the rue Haxo, who have their own memorials elsewhere. The marches reflect each generation's politics: socialists, communists and trade unions have competed to lead them. In 2016 the French National Assembly passed a resolution calling for the rehabilitation of those punished after the Commune, which showed the argument still alive in the twenty-first century. Far from Paris, the Commune's name lived on too: in 1967, during the Cultural Revolution, radicals in Shanghai briefly proclaimed a Shanghai People's Commune in its honor, before Mao Zedong told them to choose another form.
The wall raises the question this course has followed. The Commune was a democratic experiment in self-government, cut short by a war it could not win. It also took hostages, and the state that defeated it killed thousands without trial. Judging it fairly means holding both truths at once: the worth of every person killed in that week did not depend on which side of the barricade they stood.
