Skip to main content

On Sunday 21 May 1871, while a concert for the wounded was being held in the Tuileries gardens, Versailles troops entered Paris. Over the next eight days the city was reconquered street by street. The French called it la Semaine sanglante, Bloody Week. It remains one of the deadliest episodes in the history of any European capital in the nineteenth century.

The army enters

The breach came in the southwest. Versailles troops entered through the undefended Porte de Saint-Cloud, after a civilian signaled to them that the gate was unguarded. By the next day tens of thousands of soldiers were inside the walls and moving through the wealthy western districts, where they met little resistance.

The Commune had no central plan of defense. Delescluze called on Parisians to abandon military discipline and fight in their own neighborhoods. Defenders built barricades district by district, often fighting bravely but separately, which allowed the army to take one area after another. In the Latin Quarter the Panthéon fell on 24 May, and on the Butte-aux-Cailles in the south Wróblewski's battalions held out until the next day before retreating east across the river. Dąbrowski was killed on 23 May. Delescluze, sixty-one, walked deliberately onto a barricade at the Château-d'Eau on 25 May and was shot dead.

The fires

As they retreated, Communards set fire to public buildings, partly to slow the army and partly as acts of defiance. The Tuileries Palace and the Hôtel de Ville were burned, along with the Ministry of Finance, parts of the Palais de Justice and other buildings. The Louvre museum survived, though its library was destroyed. Versailles shells also started fires. Rumors spread of women called pétroleuses throwing petrol into cellars. Historians have found little evidence that organized bands of women fire-raisers existed, but the rumor led soldiers to shoot women on sight in some districts.

Killing on both sides

The army fought without mercy. Prisoners taken with weapons, or with powder-blackened hands, or simply denounced by neighbors, were often shot on the spot or after summary hearings at improvised courts. Mass executions took place in the Luxembourg Gardens, at the Lobau barracks and in other sites across the city. At the Châtelet theater an improvised court sorted prisoners in minutes, and those sent to one side were led away and shot. Long columns of captives were marched out to Versailles, where crowds jeered and some well-dressed spectators struck them. Foreign journalists described scenes that shocked readers abroad, and even some supporters of the government were disturbed by the scale of the killing.

The Communards killed too. On 24 May Archbishop Darboy and five other hostages were shot in La Roquette prison on the order of Commune officials. On 26 May a crowd on the rue Haxo in Belleville killed about fifty hostages, mostly priests and gendarmes, despite the protests of Varlin and others. Each act was used by the other side to justify its own.

The last stand

The final fighting took place in the working-class east. On 27 May Communards fought among the tombs of Père Lachaise cemetery. The next morning 147 captured defenders were shot against a wall in the cemetery, now called the Mur des Fédérés, the Wall of the Federals. That day Varlin was recognized, beaten by a crowd and shot on Montmartre. The last barricades fell on 28 May, ending the Commune seventy-two days after 18 March, counting both days.

How many died?

Nobody kept a full count. For more than a century the usual figure was about 17,000 to 20,000 Communards killed, drawn from claims by contemporaries and from payments by the city for burials. Some writers gave far higher totals. In 2012 the British historian Robert Tombs published a detailed reassessment of cemetery records and other sources. Tombs estimated that between about 5,700 and 7,400 people were killed, still a terrible toll. The Versailles army lost fewer than a thousand dead in the whole campaign of April and May.

Worked example: counting the dead

Suppose you are trying to settle the death toll. Start with your sources. The city's payments for burials suggest a large figure, but did they cover only Communards, or soldiers and civilians too, and were some bodies counted twice when moved between sites? Contemporary claims by both sides served a purpose: Communard exiles wanted to show the scale of the massacre, while the government wanted to minimize it.

Next look at records of individual cemeteries, hospitals and mass graves, where they survive. Tombs added these up and found a smaller total than the traditional one. His critics answer that many bodies were buried in unmarked pits, burned or never recorded at all, so any count from surviving records must be a minimum.

Finally, ask what the number is used for. A lower figure does not excuse the killings: thousands of people, many of them prisoners, were shot without trial. A higher figure does not prove a plan of extermination. The debate shows how historians separate what the evidence can establish from the moral judgment of what happened, which does not depend on the exact total.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Through which gate did Versailles troops enter Paris on 21 May?
2. How did the Commune's defenders fight during Bloody Week?
3. Which buildings did retreating Communards burn?
4. What have historians found about the women called pétroleuses?
5. Who were shot in La Roquette prison on 24 May 1871?
6. Where did Communards fight on 27 May 1871?
7. How many captured defenders were shot at the wall in Père Lachaise on 28 May?
8. What death toll did Robert Tombs estimate for Bloody Week in 2012?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia