Why governments build
Markets build homes for people who can pay what new construction costs. For everyone else, governments have tried three broad approaches: building and owning housing themselves, paying nonprofits to do it, or handing tenants money to rent privately. Each has spectacular successes and well-known failures, and the differences come down less to the idea than to how it was done.
Red Vienna
After the First World War, Vienna was hungry, crowded and newly governed by Social Democrats. From 1919 to 1934, the years later called Red Vienna, the city funded a building program partly through a new tax on housing that fell most heavily on luxury flats. It built more than 60,000 flats in large courtyard blocks with laundries, kindergartens and libraries. The most famous, the Karl-Marx-Hof, completed in 1930, stretches for more than a kilometer.
The program continued after 1945 in other forms. Today roughly half of Vienna's residents live in municipal or subsidized limited-profit housing. The key design choice is that income limits are generous, so teachers, nurses and office workers live in these buildings alongside poorer neighbors. Vienna's generous income limits mean social housing carries little stigma, and the large public stock helps steady rents across the whole city. Critics note real problems. Long-time tenants can keep cheap flats for life even after their incomes rise, newcomers and migrants often wait longer, and the city's land was bought cheaply in an era that cannot be repeated.
Singapore
Singapore took a different path. Its Housing and Development Board, created in 1960 when much of the population lived in crowded shophouses and squatter settlements, built new towns at enormous speed. Today about four in five Singapore residents live in public flats, most of which they own on 99-year leases. Buyers can use their compulsory retirement savings toward the purchase. Since 1989 an Ethnic Integration Policy has set limits on the share of each block and neighborhood that may be owned by Chinese, Malay, Indian and other residents, to prevent ethnic enclaves.
The model's critics point to its foundations. The state owns most of the land, much of it acquired compulsorily at low prices, which few democracies could repeat. Because the leases expire after 99 years, flats lose value as they age, and the government has had to explain what happens when leases run out. The large population of foreign workers is excluded and largely housed in dormitories.
Pruitt-Igoe and its lessons
In the United States public housing became a byword for failure, and one project became its symbol. The Pruitt-Igoe complex in St. Louis, thirty-three eleven-story towers, opened in the mid-1950s and began to be demolished in 1972, less than twenty years later. Architecture critics took it as proof that tower blocks did not work. Later historians disagreed. Historians now blame Pruitt-Igoe's failure more on funding, segregation and job loss than on its design. Federal rules expected rents to pay for maintenance, the city was losing jobs and population, the project was racially segregated in practice, and repairs stopped. Similar towers in other countries, properly maintained and mixed by income, have lasted for generations.
Vouchers
Since 1974 the main American approach has shifted toward vouchers, which pay part of a private rent while the tenant pays around 30 percent of income. Vouchers let families choose where to live and avoid concentrating poverty in one place. But housing vouchers in the United States are not an entitlement, and funding covers only about one in four eligible households; many wait years. Some landlords refuse voucher holders, and in tight markets a voucher may find nothing to rent.
The value of location showed up in a famous experiment. In the 1990s the Moving to Opportunity program offered randomly chosen families in public housing in five cities vouchers to move to low-poverty neighborhoods. Early results for adults' earnings were disappointing. Two decades later, Raj Chetty, Nathaniel Hendren and Lawrence Katz found that children who moved before age 13 earned about 31 percent more as young adults, while those who moved as teenagers did not gain. The earlier a child moved, the more the neighborhood mattered.
Worked example: one budget, three choices
A mid-sized city has 100 million dollars for housing over ten years. One option is to build public flats on city-owned land. It would produce perhaps 300 homes, last a century and help steady rents, but tenants would be chosen from a long list and the city must budget for repairs forever, the lesson of Pruitt-Igoe.
A second option is to fund nonprofits that mix tenants by income, as Vienna does. Fewer of the poorest would be helped at first, but the buildings would carry less stigma and more political support.
A third option is vouchers, helping more families right away and letting them move to neighborhoods with better schools, as Moving to Opportunity suggests. But in a tight market the vouchers might only push up rents unless supply grows too. Many cities end up combining all three, and the deciding question is often which they can sustain after the first ribbon is cut.
