Skip to main content

Two ways to have a home

An owner holds an asset; a renter buys the use of one. The difference shapes wealth, mobility, politics and even how secure a family feels. In the English-speaking world ownership is often treated as the normal goal of adult life, but the pattern varies enormously. In Romania and several other former communist countries, over nine in ten households own their homes, largely because state flats were sold cheaply to their occupants after 1989. In Germany only about half of households own. And Switzerland, one of the richest countries on earth, has one of the lowest homeownership rates in Europe, with most households renting. High ownership, in other words, is not the same thing as prosperity.

The case for owning

Supporters of ownership make serious arguments. Owners cannot be told to leave when a lease ends. Paying down a loan works as a form of forced saving, and in many countries home equity is the main wealth that ordinary families hold. Owners have a stake in their neighborhood and tend to stay longer, join local groups and vote in local elections. Many people also simply value the freedom to paint a wall or plant a tree without asking anyone.

The case for caution

Critics point to the other side of the ledger. A house is a single, heavy, undiversified investment, and its value can fall just when its owner's job is lost. Owning also makes moving costly. The economist Andrew Oswald argued that high homeownership can raise unemployment by making it harder to move for work, an idea that remains debated but has some support in later studies. Renting, by contrast, lets a worker follow opportunity and puts the risks of repair and price swings on someone else.

The homevoter

Ownership also shapes local politics. The economist William Fischel, in a 2001 book, proposed what he called the homevoter hypothesis: homeowners, whose largest asset is their house, vote to protect its value. They cannot insure against a nearby change that might lower prices, so they tend to oppose anything that seems risky, from apartments to shelters to new roads. Fischel did not treat this as selfishness; it is a rational response to putting most of one's savings in one place. But since owners vote in local elections at higher rates than renters, their caution often decides what gets built.

Protecting renters

Countries with many renters usually give them strong protections. In Germany, leases are normally open-ended, and a landlord needs a recognized reason, such as wanting the flat for a family member, to end one. Such security of tenure lets renting function as a lifelong option rather than a waiting room.

Rent regulation is more contested. Early versions, like the wartime controls of the 1940s, froze rents outright. Most modern versions are different: rent stabilization usually limits how fast rents can rise rather than freezing them, often tying increases to inflation. Defenders say this keeps families in their communities and prevents sudden shocks. Critics, including most economists, warn that it discourages new building and maintenance and rewards whoever happens to hold a lease, not those most in need.

Berlin offered a sharp test. In 2020 the city froze most rents and ordered some cut. In 2021 Germany's Federal Constitutional Court struck the law down, ruling that in Germany, rent law is a matter for the federal government, not individual states such as Berlin. Studies of the short experiment found that rents in covered flats fell, but the number of flats advertised for rent dropped sharply, as landlords sold or waited.

Eviction

For renters with low incomes the most frightening event is eviction. The sociologist Matthew Desmond followed families in Milwaukee for his 2016 book Evicted and argued that eviction is a cause of poverty, not only a symptom of it: losing a home often means losing a job, changing schools and moving into worse housing. Most tenants in eviction court have no lawyer, while most landlords do. In 2017 New York City became the first American city to guarantee lawyers to low-income tenants facing eviction. Supporters say the program kept many families housed; critics worry it slows the removal of tenants who truly do not pay and raises costs that landlords pass on.

Worked example: the rent increase

Marta has rented the same flat for nine years. Her landlord, a retired teacher who owns two buildings, announces a 25 percent increase after his property taxes and repair bills rose. Marta's children are settled in the local school and her job is a short walk away.

Look at the choices through the level. In a place with open-ended leases and rent stabilization, the increase would be capped, perhaps near inflation, and Marta could stay. The landlord would bear more of his rising costs, and might sell to an owner-occupier or skimp on repairs. In a place with no limits, Marta might move to a cheaper flat farther away, losing time and ties, or stretch her budget. If she owned instead, the increase would not exist, but a rise in interest or tax bills could squeeze her just as hard, and selling would take months. If the dispute reached court, a lawyer could make the difference. Each system shifts risk between people; none makes it disappear.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does the level say about Switzerland?
2. What did Andrew Oswald argue about high homeownership?
3. What is the homevoter hypothesis?
4. How do most modern rent stabilization rules work?
5. Why did Germany's Federal Constitutional Court strike down Berlin's rent freeze?
6. What did studies of Berlin's rent freeze find?
7. What did Matthew Desmond argue about eviction?
8. What did New York City do in 2017?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia