Skip to main content

Bricks or permission?

If land near people is valuable, one would expect builders to use it intensively, adding homes until prices fell toward the cost of construction. In many cities that does not happen. The economists Edward Glaeser and Joseph Gyourko compared home prices with what it cost to build them and found that in much of the United States the two were close. In a handful of coastal metro areas, though, prices ran far above construction costs. Their conclusion was that where prices far exceed building costs, rules limiting construction are usually the main reason. They described the gap as working like a tax, created not by any legislature's vote but by regulation.

The rules in question are many: limits on height and density, minimum lot sizes, setbacks from the street, design reviews, environmental reviews and requirements for parking. Each can have a good reason. Together they can make it impossible to build anything but detached houses on most residential land.

By right or by permission

A crucial difference lies in how permission is given. "By right" approval means a project that meets the written rules gets permission without a hearing. The builder checks the code, submits plans and starts work. Under discretionary review, by contrast, a board or council can say yes or no case by case, often after public hearings, appeals and negotiations. The main cost of discretionary review is uncertainty and delay, which falls hardest on smaller builders who cannot wait years for an answer.

Tokyo and Houston

Two cities show what looser rules can do. Japan sets its zoning categories nationally, with about a dozen zones that mostly allow building by right, and local residents have limited power to stop a project that follows them. In some years in the 2010s, Tokyo approved more new homes than the whole of California. Rents and prices in Tokyo stayed far steadier than in London or Sydney while its population grew. Other forces helped: Japan's population as a whole is shrinking, and Japanese houses lose value as they age and are often rebuilt.

Houston is the only large American city without zoning, after voters rejected it in 1948, 1962 and 1993. It still has rules, including private deed restrictions that cover many neighborhoods. In 1998 Houston cut its minimum lot size inside its inner highway loop from 5,000 to 1,400 square feet, extending the change to the rest of the city in 2013. Builders responded with tens of thousands of townhouses on land that once held single homes. Critics point out that Houston's growth has also meant sprawl, paved floodplains and severe flooding, and that its private covenants can be as rigid as zoning.

Auckland's experiment

In 2016 Auckland, New Zealand's largest city, adopted a Unitary Plan that rezoned about three quarters of its residential land to allow more homes per lot. Researchers at the University of Auckland compared areas that were upzoned with those that were not and found that permits for new homes in upzoned areas roughly doubled within about five years, mostly townhouses. Rents in Auckland rose more slowly afterward than in other New Zealand cities. Skeptics note that other factors were at work, including interest rates and migration, and that the full effect on prices will take decades to judge.

Parking

One rule has drawn special attention. Parking minimums require new buildings to supply a set number of parking spaces. The planner Donald Shoup spent decades arguing that these rules hide large costs: a space in a garage can cost tens of thousands of dollars to build, the cost is folded into rents paid by people with and without cars, and the space required can make small buildings unworkable on small lots. In 2017 Buffalo, New York, became one of the first American cities to drop parking minimums citywide. Defenders of the rules worry about crowded streets and spillover parking in nearby neighborhoods.

The case for rules

Planning rules exist for real reasons. Before zoning, factories could rise beside homes, and tenements could block light and air entirely. Neighbors have a legitimate interest in shade, noise, traffic and safety. Environmental review protects wetlands and wildlife. Historic districts keep places people love. Sewers, schools and roads have limits. The fair question is not whether to have rules, but which rules, made by whom, and whether their total cost is visible to the people who bear it, including those who would like to live in a place but cannot yet afford to.

Worked example: the corner lot

A small builder buys a corner lot near a bus line and proposes a four-story building with twelve flats. In City A the zoning allows it by right. Plans are checked against the code, the permit comes in four months and construction begins.

In City B the lot is zoned for one house. The builder must apply for rezoning. Neighbors raise concerns about parking and shadows at two hearings; the council asks for a smaller building and eight parking spaces; an appeal follows. Two and a half years later the builder wins permission for eight flats with a garage. Interest on the land loan, design changes and lawyers have added several hundred thousand dollars, which must now be recovered across fewer homes. Each step had a reason, yet the result is fewer and more expensive flats, and a builder less likely to try again.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Glaeser and Gyourko conclude about places where prices far exceed building costs?
2. What does "by right" approval mean?
3. According to the level, what is the main cost of discretionary review?
4. What does the level say about Tokyo in some years of the 2010s?
5. What did Houston do in 1998?
6. What did researchers find after Auckland's 2016 upzoning?
7. What do parking minimums require?
8. What did Buffalo, New York, do in 2017?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia