Skip to main content

What a home price really buys

Every home is two things sold together: a structure and a piece of ground. The structure is made of timber, concrete, pipes, wiring and labor, and those cost roughly the same from one region to the next. A builder's cost per square foot in the priciest American metro areas is perhaps one and a half to two times the cost in the cheapest, yet finished homes in those places can sell for five or more times as much. The difference is the ground. In expensive cities, most of a home's price is the value of its location and land. People are paying less for bricks than for what the bricks are near: jobs, schools, friends, the sea, a subway stop.

This explains a pattern that puzzles many newcomers to housing debates. A small, old flat in central Paris or San Francisco can cost more than a large new house in a declining town, even though the house took more material and work to build. What sells is access.

The bid-rent idea

In 1826 the German landowner and economist Johann Heinrich von Thünen imagined a single market town in a flat plain and asked how farmers would use the land around it. Crops that were heavy or spoiled quickly had to be grown close in; cattle could walk to market from farther away. In 1964 the economist William Alonso applied the same reasoning to modern cities. Every household and firm, he argued, weighs the cost of travel against the price of space. Bid-rent theory predicts that what people will pay for land falls with distance from the center.

Out of that one rule comes much of a city's shape. Near the middle, land is so costly that it pays to stack floors on top of each other, so buildings rise and flats shrink. Farther out, land is cheap and lots grow larger. In bid-rent terms, households trade living space against access to the center. A family that wants a garden gives up time on the train; a single worker who wants a short walk to the office accepts a tiny kitchen.

Who earns the value of land?

If land is valuable because of what surrounds it, an awkward question follows. An owner who does nothing at all may grow rich as a city grows around the plot. The philosopher John Stuart Mill made the point sharply in 1848, writing that landlords "grow richer, as it were in their sleep, without working, risking, or economizing." Mill's complaint was that landlords gained wealth without work or risk of their own.

The American writer Henry George built a movement on this idea in his 1879 book Progress and Poverty. Since the community, not the owner, creates most of a location's value, George proposed a tax on the value of land alone, with buildings left untaxed. Many economists across the political spectrum have admired the idea. Defenders say a land value tax does not discourage building, because it falls on land and not on what is built on it: an owner pays the same whether the lot holds a parking lot or an apartment block, so leaving it idle stops paying.

Critics raise fair objections. It is hard to value land separately from the buildings on it. A pure land tax can hit owners who are land rich and cash poor, such as retirees in a neighborhood that has boomed around them. And a large new tax on land would cut the value of what millions of families already own, which makes it politically very difficult.

Measuring affordability

The most common yardstick is simple. Households that spend more than 30 percent of their income on housing are called cost-burdened. The number has an unglamorous origin: it comes from US public housing rent rules, which capped tenants' rent at 25 percent of income in 1969 and raised the cap to 30 percent in 1981. Another common measure is the ratio of the median home price to median household income; some analysts treat a ratio around three as affordable and above five as severely unaffordable.

Both measures have limits. Thirty percent of a large income leaves plenty for everything else, while 25 percent of a very small one may not. For that reason some researchers prefer a residual income approach, which asks how much money is left after paying for housing, and whether it covers food, transport and other basics.

Worked example: two identical flats

Imagine two flats with the same floor plan. One is in a busy city near a household's jobs and rents for 2,200 dollars a month. The other is in a town ninety minutes away and rents for 1,100. The household earns 60,000 dollars a year.

The city flat costs 26,400 dollars a year, 44 percent of income, so the household is cost-burdened. The town flat costs 13,200, just 22 percent, so it looks affordable. But the bid-rent idea says to count the trade. Two adults commuting three hours a day by car could spend several thousand dollars a year on fuel, insurance and wear, and lose around 1,500 hours of their lives. On the residual income test the gap narrows, and on time it may reverse. Neither number alone tells this family which home is cheaper. What the example does show is why the price of a home cannot be separated from where it is, and why the question of who captures the value of a good location matters so much.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. In expensive cities, what makes up most of a home's price?
2. What does bid-rent theory predict?
3. In bid-rent terms, what do households trade against each other?
4. What was John Stuart Mill's complaint about landlords?
5. What did Henry George propose in Progress and Poverty?
6. Why do defenders say a land value tax does not discourage building?
7. What are households that spend over 30 percent of income on housing called?
8. Where did the 30 percent affordability figure come from?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia