Skip to main content

Many measures of well-being rely in the end on what people want or report. The capabilities approach was built partly in reaction to a stubborn fact: people who have long lived with hardship often come to accept it. They may say they are satisfied, or never ask for what they lack. Philosophers call such adjusted wants adaptive preferences. The worry for capability theorists is practical: if policy follows only what people say they want, the worst off may seem to need the least.

Sen's evidence from Bengal

Sen drew on a public health survey carried out in Bengal in 1944, just after the great famine there. Asked about their own health, widowers reported ill health far more often than widows did, although widows were among the most deprived people in the province. Nearly half the widowers described their health as ill or indifferent. Almost none of the widows did. Sen did not conclude that the widows were healthy. He concluded that their expectations had been worn down until they no longer counted their condition as illness.

Sen's broader point was that mental metrics such as happiness or desire can be bent by deprivation itself. A person who has learned to take small mercies with pleasure may score well on a happiness survey while lacking food, safety or schooling.

Nussbaum's brick carrier

Nussbaum gave the problem faces. In Women and Human Development she describes Jayamma, a woman in Trivandrum, in Kerala, who for decades carried heavy loads of bricks on her head at a brick kiln. Women at the kiln were paid less than men and were never promoted to the better-paid jobs that men held. Jayamma did not complain of this arrangement. She seemed to regard it as simply the way things were. Nussbaum argued that her lack of protest showed not that the arrangement was fair, but how thoroughly it had shaped what she thought possible.

Nussbaum's second case, Vasanti, in Ahmedabad, in Gujarat, shows the other side. Vasanti left an abusive husband and, with help from her brothers and later a loan from the Self-Employed Women's Association, a trade union of poor working women, built up a small sewing business. As her options grew, so did her sense of what she was owed. Preferences, Nussbaum stressed, shift as people gain options and allies: information, income and the company of others in the same position.

What follows, and what does not

Adaptive preferences are an argument against relying on preferences alone. They are not a license to ignore what people say. Nussbaum argues that a list of capabilities gives an independent check: whatever Jayamma reports, she lacks equal treatment at work, which falls under affiliation and under control over her material environment. But the list does not tell anyone to force Jayamma to want something different. Its aim is to secure the options and let her choose.

The paternalism worry

Critics press hard here. Who decides that someone's contentment is adaptive and not wise? A woman who stays in a traditional role may have weighed the alternatives and chosen what she values. Calling her preferences adaptive can become a way for outsiders, whether development workers, governments or philosophers, to dismiss views they dislike. Feminist critics in particular have warned against treating poor women in the global South as victims who cannot know their own minds.

The philosopher Serene Khader, in Adaptive Preferences and Women's Empowerment (2011), proposed a narrower test. On her account, a preference counts as adaptive in the troubling sense only when it harms flourishing and arose from injustice: it must be inconsistent with a person's basic flourishing and have been formed under unjust conditions. She also argued that outsiders should respond through deliberation with the people concerned, not by overriding them.

Not only a problem of the poor

Adaptation is not limited to poor countries. People in wealthy societies adapt to long commutes, unsafe workplaces or exclusion from public life, and come to say they do not mind. People with disabilities often report higher life satisfaction than others predict for them, which some read as adaptation and others read as evidence that outsiders misjudge disabled lives. The approach must handle both readings honestly: a person's report is evidence to weigh, not a final verdict that ends the inquiry.

Worked example: the kiln survey

Suppose a labor ministry surveys brickworkers like Jayamma and finds that most women say they are satisfied with their pay. A preference-based report would conclude there is no problem. A capability review asks further questions. Can women legally take the better jobs, and are they trained for them? If the answers show that women could not take better work even if they wanted it, the satisfaction figures reveal narrow options, not fair treatment. The ministry's task is then to open the doors, through anti-discrimination rules and training, and to ask the women again once they can choose. If many still prefer their current work, that preference now carries real weight, because it is a choice among options rather than acceptance of the only one on offer.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why are adaptive preferences a practical worry for policy?
2. In the 1944 Bengal survey Sen cited, who reported ill health more often?
3. What did Sen conclude from such health reports?
4. How did Jayamma's kiln treat women compared with men?
5. What did Nussbaum stress about preferences?
6. What does a capability list aim to do in a case like Jayamma's?
7. Under Khader's test, when is a preference troublingly adaptive?
8. How should a person's report about their own life be treated?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia