Skip to main content

Martha Nussbaum came to development through ancient philosophy. A scholar of Aristotle and the Hellenistic schools, she worked in the late 1980s with Sen at the World Institute for Development Economics Research in Helsinki, and together they edited The Quality of Life (1993). Where Sen kept the approach open, Nussbaum gave it content. In Women and Human Development (2000) and Creating Capabilities (2011) she defended a list of ten central human capabilities that every government owes its citizens, at least up to a minimum level.

The list

In brief, and in paraphrase, the ten are these:

  • Life: living to the end of a human life of normal length, not dying early.
  • Bodily health: good health, including reproductive health, adequate nourishment and shelter.
  • Bodily integrity: moving freely, being secure against assault, including sexual and domestic violence, and having choice in matters of reproduction.
  • Senses, imagination and thought: using the mind in a fully human way, informed by education and protected by freedom of expression and religion.
  • Emotions: having attachments to people and things, loving, grieving and longing, without being crushed by fear and anxiety.
  • Practical reason: forming a conception of the good and reflecting critically on how to plan one's life.
  • Affiliation: living with and toward others, and having the social bases of self-respect, with protection against humiliation and discrimination.
  • Other species: living with concern for animals, plants and the natural world.
  • Play: laughing, playing and enjoying recreation.
  • Control over one's environment: politically, taking part in political choices with free speech and association; materially, holding property and seeking work on an equal basis with others.

A threshold of dignity

Nussbaum's theory is a theory of minimum justice, not of complete justice. Her question is what a life worthy of human dignity requires. Justice requires bringing every citizen above a minimum in each one of the ten. What happens above the threshold, and whether further equality is required, she leaves largely open, though she argues that some capabilities, such as political rights and religious freedom, must be held equally if they are to be held with dignity at all.

No trading one for another

A central feature is that the capabilities are separate. The capabilities cannot be traded off: a government cannot make up for a shortfall in one by giving more of another. Extra income does not compensate for denying women the vote, and good schools do not excuse torture. This sets the approach apart from measures that add everything into one total. When capabilities conflict, so that no available policy can secure them all, Nussbaum calls this a tragic choice.

Two that organize the rest

Among the ten, Nussbaum gives special place to two. Practical reason and affiliation organize and pervade all the others. To be fed in a fully human way is to plan one's meals and share them with others, not simply to be handed rations.

Three kinds of capability

Nussbaum also distinguishes three kinds. Basic capabilities are innate powers, such as the potential to learn language. Internal capabilities are developed traits and skills, such as literacy or confidence, trained in a supportive setting. Combined capabilities are skills plus the outside conditions to use them. A trained journalist under censorship has the internal capability to report but not the combined one. Politics, Nussbaum argues, should aim at combined capabilities.

Universal but liberal

A universal list invites the charge of cultural imperialism: who is a philosopher in Chicago to tell villagers in India what a good life needs? Nussbaum's answer has several parts. The list is meant to be open-ended and revisable. It names capabilities, not functionings, so people stay free not to use them: a person may choose celibacy, fasting or a quiet life away from politics. And it is offered, borrowing an idea from Rawls's later work, as an object of overlapping consensus: people of different faiths and philosophies can endorse the list as a political basis without agreeing on a full account of the good life.

Critics are not all persuaded. Some say any list carries the values of its author: the place of play, or of concern for other species, reflects one picture of human nature. Others say the list is too thin to guide hard choices, since it does not say how much of each capability is enough. Nussbaum accepts that thresholds must be set nation by nation.

Worked example: a resettlement plan

A city council is preparing to resettle a few hundred refugee families and asks what it must provide. A resource view would set a cash allowance. Nussbaum's list prompts a fuller check. Life and bodily health call for housing and clinics. Bodily integrity calls for safety from violence, including inside families. Senses, imagination and thought call for schooling and language classes. Affiliation calls for protection against discrimination and places where families can meet neighbors. Control over one's environment, in its material form, means the right to seek work on equal terms, and in its political form, a voice in local decisions. Because the capabilities cannot be traded, the council cannot argue that a generous allowance makes up for a ban on working. The list does not fix the size of any budget, but it tells the council exactly what it would be failing at if it left something out.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which of these appears on Nussbaum's list of central capabilities?
2. What does Nussbaum's threshold require?
3. Can a government offset a shortfall in one capability with more of another?
4. Which two capabilities does Nussbaum say organize the others?
5. What are combined capabilities?
6. Why does Nussbaum list capabilities rather than functionings?
7. What role does overlapping consensus play in Nussbaum's view?
8. What does Nussbaum call a situation where no policy can secure all capabilities?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia