For about a century and a half, al-Andalus was ruled from Marrakesh by two Berber empires in turn. Both arrived as movements of religious reform, and both were seen by many Andalusis as rough outsiders. Yet under the second of them, the Almohads, al-Andalus produced some of the most daring philosophy of the Middle Ages. The relation between strict rulers and free thinkers turns out to be more tangled than either side of it suggests.
The Almoravid order
The Almoravids governed with the support of jurists of the Maliki school of law, who gained great influence. Their suspicion of new religious ideas showed when, around 1109, the Revival of the Religious Sciences by the eastern scholar al-Ghazali was publicly burned in Córdoba on the orders of the ruler and with the approval of local judges, who thought its mystical teaching undermined the law. Ironically, al-Ghazali had earlier supported the Almoravids' right to depose the taifa kings.
The Christian frontier kept moving. Alfonso I of Aragon took Zaragoza in 1118, and in 1125 to 1126 he led a long raid deep into Andalusi territory. Some Mozarabs joined him. In response, the Almoravid authorities deported many Mozarabs to North Africa in 1126, a turning point in the decline of the old Arabic-speaking Christian communities of the south.
The Almohad revolution
The Almohads began in the Atlas Mountains with Ibn Tumart, a scholar who claimed to be the Mahdi, a divinely guided leader. His followers called themselves al-muwahhidun, "those who affirm the unity of God," which Europeans turned into Almohads. They accused the Almoravids of crude ideas about God and of lax rule. After Ibn Tumart's death his successor Abd al-Mumin took Marrakesh in 1147 and soon crossed into al-Andalus. He took the title of caliph. The Almohads pressed Jews and Christians to convert or leave, and many Jewish families fled north to Christian lands or east to Egypt.
The Almohads made Seville their Andalusi capital and gave it a great mosque. Its minaret, built from 1184 to 1198, survives as the Giralda, the bell tower of Seville's cathedral, with a Renaissance top added in 1568.
A boy on an island
The Almohad court valued reason as a path to faith, and it gathered philosophers. One of them, Ibn Tufayl, was physician and adviser to the caliph Abu Yaqub Yusuf. He wrote a philosophical tale, Hayy ibn Yaqzan, about a boy raised by a gazelle on an empty island who reasons his way to the truth about the world and God without any teacher. When Hayy finally meets other people, he finds that most of them prefer simple rules and stories to philosophy, and he goes back to his island. A Latin translation published in Oxford in 1671 drew interest from European thinkers concerned with what reason alone can know.
Ibn Rushd and the caliph
Ibn Rushd, born in Córdoba in 1126, came from a family of judges and became a judge and physician himself. Ibn Tufayl introduced him to the caliph, who complained that Aristotle's works were hard to follow. At the caliph's request, Ibn Rushd wrote commentaries explaining Aristotle. He produced short, middle and long versions, and his long commentaries became the most careful reading of Aristotle in the Middle Ages, studied in Latin and Hebrew long after they were forgotten in Arabic.
Then came a reversal. In 1195, during the caliph Abu Yusuf Yaqub's war with Castile, when he needed the support of religious scholars, Ibn Rushd was disgraced and exiled to the nearby town of Lucena, and some of his books were ordered burned. Within about two years he was restored to favor. He died in Marrakesh in 1198. That same summer of 1195 the Almohads won a great victory over Castile at Alarcos, but in 1212 a Christian alliance broke their power, and their empire soon fell apart.
Worked example: why disgrace a philosopher you protected?
The Almohad rulers had paid Ibn Rushd for years and shared his interests. Why turn on him? Weigh the evidence. The timing points to politics: the caliph was gathering soldiers and needed the jurists and preachers who rallied them, many of whom distrusted philosophy. Sources from the period also mention charges about passages in his writings that seemed to slight religion, perhaps taken out of context by rivals. And the quick pardon suggests that the caliph's own views had not changed. Notice too what the episode did not do: it did not end philosophy's influence, because Ibn Rushd's books had already been copied and were soon carried north, where Jewish and Christian scholars read them for centuries. The likeliest reading is that a ruler sacrificed a thinker to buy support in a crisis, then quietly undid the damage. It is an old pattern. Freedom of thought that depends on one patron's favor is a privilege, not a right, and privileges can be withdrawn whenever power needs allies more than it needs ideas.
