Skip to main content
↑ Back to the start
7 months 1 week ago
Our present-day neurochemical cocktail, we are asked to believe, is the medium through which alien realms of consciousness can be grasped and neutrally appraised from a third-person perspective. Empirical research suggests this optimism is at best naïve.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.hedweb.com/bokowfil.htm Storming Heaven: LSD and the American Dream]", BLTC Research (2009)
7 months 1 week ago
It is hard to imagine an experience more horrific than being eaten alive. Most of us would prefer not to imagine what it must feel like. Note that the photographer here had to persuade the park ranger to violate the park rules and put the baby elephant out of his misery.By analogy, suppose it were lawful to visit Third World countries for photoshoots but illegal to "interfere" and help a stricken human baby. Is there a fundamental difference between "ethical" intervention to help humans and "sentimental" pleas to "interfere" and help non-humans? Should we encourage the preservation of life-forms such as the hyena in their current guise? Or do the value judgements underlying the "science" of conservation biology need to be re-examined?
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.abolitionist.com/reprogramming/elephant-hyenas.html Hyenas Eat Baby Elephant Alive: The Case for Intervention]"
7 months 1 week ago
Given our anthropocentric bias, thinking of non-human vertebrates not just as equivalent in moral status to toddlers or infants, but as though they were toddlers or infants, is a useful exercise. Such reconceptualisation helps correct our lack of empathy for sentient beings whose physical appearance is different from "us". Ethically, the practice of intelligent "anthropomorphism" shouldn't be shunned as unscientific, but embraced insofar as it augments our stunted capacity for empathy. Such anthropomorphism can be a valuable corrective to our cognitive and moral limitations. This is not a plea to be sentimental, simply for impartial benevolence.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.hedweb.com/abolitionist-project/reprogramming-predators.html Reprogramming Predators]", BLTC Research, 2009
7 months 1 week ago

Here we come to the nub of the issue: the alleged moral force of the term "natural". If any creature, by its very nature, causes terrible suffering, albeit unwittingly, is it morally wrong to change that nature? If a civilised human were to come to believe s/he had been committing acts that caused grievous pain for no good reason, then s/he would stop - and want other moral agents to prevent the recurrence of such behaviour. May we assume that the same would be true of a lion, if the lion were morally and cognitively "uplifted" so as to understand the ramifications of what (s)he was doing? Or a house cat tormenting a mouse? Or indeed a human sociopath?

0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.hedweb.com/abolitionist-project/reprogramming-predators.html Reprogramming Predators]", BLTC Research, 2009
7 months 1 week ago
If we already lived in a cruelty-free world, the notion of re-introducing suffering, exploitation and creatures eating each other would seem not so much frightful as unimaginable – no more seriously conceivable than reverting to surgery without anaesthesia today.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.hedweb.com/abolitionist-project/reprogramming-predators.html Reprogramming Predators]", BLTC Research, 2009
7 months 1 week ago
Here the question comes down to an analysis of risk-reward ratios - and our basic ethical values, themselves shaped by our evolutionary past. Lest extension of the new reproductive medicine seem too rashly experimental even to contemplate, it's worth recalling that each act of old-fashioned sexual reproduction is itself an untested genetic experiment, the outcome of random mutations and meiotic shuffling of the genetic deck, and with no happy ending to date. So just who are we to accuse of reckless gambling? As it stands, all of us are genetically predestined to grow old and die; and in the course of a lifetime, the great majority of humans will experience periods of intense psychological distress, for instance loneliness and heartache after an unhappy love affair. Our social primate biology ensures that most of us sometimes experience, to a greater or lesser degree, all manner of nasty states that were genetically adaptive in the ancestral environment e.g. jealousy, resentment, anger, and so forth. Hundreds of millions of people in the world today suffer bouts of depression; others live with chronic anxiety. One might say these phenotypes are part of what it means to be human. Worse, we pass a heritable predisposition to these horrible states on to our children.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.reproductive-revolution.com/ The Reproductive Revolution: Selection Pressure in a Post-Darwinian World]", Talk delivered at the Touch Me Festival, Zagreb, Dec. 2008
7 months 1 week ago
My own view of the risks and uncertainties is that there is a critical distinction between trying to abolish suffering exclusively via social reform and abolishing suffering directly via biotechnology. As we know, utopian social experiments typically go wrong, sometimes hideously wrong, and end up causing a lot of suffering instead. The abolitionist project of eradicating the biological substrates of suffering sounds like just another utopian scheme, whether it's touted as a grandiose species-project or simply as a byproduct of the Reproductive Revolution explored here. Although the abolition of psychological pain is arguably no more utopian in principle than pain-free surgery, it could presumably go wrong in unanticipated ways too. Perhaps we'll unwittingly create a fool's paradise. But if and when we ever abolish the molecular underpinning of unpleasant experience, and it becomes physiologically impossible for any sentient being to suffer, we thereby change the very meaning of what it is for anything to "go wrong". Unwelcome surprises where no one gets hurt are very different from unwelcome surprises where they do. For what it's worth, I think the abolition of involuntary suffering is the precondition of any civilised posthuman society; and therefore a risk worth taking.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.reproductive-revolution.com/ The Reproductive Revolution: Selection Pressure in a Post-Darwinian World]", Talk delivered at the Touch Me Festival, Zagreb, Dec. 2008
7 months 1 week ago
Assume, provisionally at any rate, a utilitarian ethic. The abolitionist project follows naturally, in "our" parochial corner of Hilbert space at least. On its completion, if not before, we should aim to develop superintelligence to maximise the well-being of the fragment of the cosmos accessible to beneficent intervention. And when we are sure – absolutely sure – that we have done literally everything we can do to eradicate suffering elsewhere, perhaps we should forget about its very existence.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.abolitionist.com/multiverse.html Quantum Ethics? Suffering in the Multiverse]", BLTC Research, 2008
7 months 1 week ago
My own sense of how to behave in a simulation has more traditional roots in the theory of perception. I've long believed that each of us lives in an egocentric simulation of the world run by the mind/brain. Since the zombies of each (waking) simulation have sentient real world counterparts, one should treat them as though they were real. Nonetheless as an angst-ridden teenager, my dawning acceptance of an inferential realist theory of perception made me feel as if I'd been condemned to solitary confinement for life. The sense of loneliness was indescribable. Naïve realism is better for one's mental health.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://ieet.org/index.php/IEET2/more/bostrom20071226 Origins and Theory of the World Transhumanist Association]", Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, 26 Dec. 2007
7 months 1 week ago
If we want eternal life, then we’ll need to rewrite our bug-ridden genetic code and become god-like. “May all that have life be delivered from suffering”, said Gautama Buddha. It’s a wonderful sentiment. Sadly, only hi-tech solutions can ever eradicate suffering from the living world. Compassion alone is not enough.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
[https://www.hedweb.com/transhumanism/ "Interview with Nick Bostrom and David Pearce"], Dec. 2007

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia