Skip to main content
↑ Back to the start
7 months 1 week ago
Suppose we encounter an advanced civilization that has engineered a happy biosphere. Population sizes are controlled by cross-species immunocontraception. Free-living herbivores lead idyllic lives in their wildlife parks. Should we urge the reintroduction of starvation, asphyxiation, disemboweling and being eaten alive by predators? Is their regime of compassionate stewardship of the biosphere best abandoned in favour of "re-wilding"? I suspect the advanced civilization would regard human pleas to restore the old Darwinian regime of "Nature, red in tooth and claw" as callous if not borderline sociopathic.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
Reply to "[https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2015/09/10/i-am-horrified-at-what-goes-on-in-philosophy-departments-personally/#comment-971596 I am horrified at what goes on in philosophy departments, personally]", Freethought Blogs, 10 Sept. 2015
7 months 1 week ago
More controversially, technology can accelerate the transition from harming to helping free-living sentient beings: mankind's fitfully expanding "circle of compassion". The civilising process needn't be species-specific but instead extend to free-living dwellers in tomorrow's wildlife parks. Every cubic metre of the biosphere will soon be computationally accessible to surveillance, micro-management and control. Fertility regulation via immunocontraception can replace Darwinian ecosystems governed by starvation and predation. Any species of obligate carnivore we choose to preserve can be genetically and behaviourally tweaked into harmlessness. Asphyxiation, disembowelling, and agonies of being eaten alive can pass into the dustbin of history.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.hedweb.com/transhumanism/neojainism.html High-tech Jainism]", The World Transformed, Jul. 2014
7 months 1 week ago
In the long run, there is nothing to stop intelligent agents from identifying the molecular signature of experience below hedonic zero and eliminating it altogether — even in insects. Nociception is vital; pain is optional. I tentatively predict that the world's last unpleasant experience in our forward light-cone will be a precisely datable event — perhaps some micro-pain in an obscure marine invertebrate a few centuries hence.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-radical-plan-to-eliminate-earths-predatory-species-1613342963 The Radical Plan to Phase out Earth's Predatory Species]", io9, 30 Jul. 2014
7 months 1 week ago
Getting rid of predation isn't a matter of moralising. A python who kills a small human child isn't morally blameworthy. Nor is a lion who hunts and kills a terrified zebra. In both cases, the victim suffers horribly. But the predator lacks the empathetic and mind-reading skills needed to understand the implications of what s/he is doing. Some humans still display a similar deficit. From the perspective of the victim, the moral status or (lack of) guilty intent of a human or nonhuman predator is irrelevant. Either way, to stand by and watch the snake asphyxiate a child would be almost as morally abhorrent as to kill the child yourself. So why turn this principle on its head with beings of comparable sentience to human infants and toddlers? With power comes complicity.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-radical-plan-to-eliminate-earths-predatory-species-1613342963 The Radical Plan to Phase out Earth's Predatory Species]", io9, 30 Jul. 2014
7 months 1 week ago
What right have humans to impose our values on members of another race or species? The charge is seductive but misplaced. There is no anthropomorphism here, no imposition of human values on alien minds. Human and nonhuman animals are alike in an ethically critical respect. The pleasure-pain axis is universal to sentient life. No sentient being wants to be harmed – to be asphyxiated, dismembered, or eaten alive. The wishes of a terrified toddler or a fleeing zebra to flourish unmolested are not open to doubt even in the absence of the verbal capacity to say so.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-radical-plan-to-eliminate-earths-predatory-species-1613342963 The Radical Plan to Phase out Earth's Predatory Species]", io9, 30 Jul. 2014
7 months 1 week ago
A few centuries from now, if involuntary suffering still exists in the world, the explanation for its persistence won't be that we've run out of computational resources to phase out its biological signature, but rather that rational agents – for reasons unknown – will have chosen to preserve it.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-radical-plan-to-eliminate-earths-predatory-species-1613342963 The Radical Plan to Phase out Earth's Predatory Species]", io9, 30 Jul. 2014
7 months 1 week ago
The biology of suffering in intelligent agents is a deep underlying source of existential risk – and one that can potentially be overcome.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.hedweb.com/social-media/pre2014.html Unsorted Postings]", pre-2014
7 months 1 week ago

One might naively suppose that a negative utilitarian would welcome human extinction. But only (trans)humans - or our potential superintelligent successors - are technically capable of phasing out the cruelties of the rest of the living world on Earth. And only (trans)humans - or rather our potential superintelligent successors - are technically capable of assuming stewardship of our entire Hubble volume.

0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://www.hedweb.com/social-media/pre2014.html Unsorted Postings]", Facebook, pre-2014
7 months 1 week ago

Both natural selection and the historical record offer powerful reasons for doubting the trustworthiness of our naive moral intuitions. So the possibility that human civilisation might be founded upon some monstrous evil should be taken seriously - even if the possibility seems transparently absurd at the time.

0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://ieet.org/index.php/IEET2/more/pearce20130726 The Antispeciesist Revolution]", Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, 26 Jul. 2013
7 months 1 week ago
Humans already massively intervene in Nature, whether through habitat destruction, captive breeding programs for big cats, "rewilding", etc. So the question is not whether humans should "interfere", but rather what ethical principles should govern our interventions.
0
⚖0
▼ Source
source
"[https://ieet.org/index.php/IEET2/more/pearce20130726 The Antispeciesist Revolution]", Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, 26 Jul. 2013

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia