Skip to main content

Ending the war took almost as much ingenuity as fighting it. There were dozens of parties, several overlapping wars and no agreed rules on who could even sit at the table. That the negotiators succeeded at all is one of the great achievements of European diplomacy.

Two towns, one congress

After preliminary agreements in 1641, delegations gathered from 1643 onward in two towns in the northwest of the empire. Catholic powers, including France and Spain, negotiated at Münster, while Sweden and the Protestant estates negotiated at Osnabrück, about 50 kilometers away. Couriers rode between them constantly. Two mediators, the papal envoy Fabio Chigi and the Venetian diplomat Alvise Contarini, carried proposals at Münster, since the French and imperial delegations would not deal face to face.

Each major delegation brought secretaries, lawyers, servants and guards, and the two small towns became crowded diplomatic capitals for about five years. Much time went on ceremony. Who entered a room first, who sat on the right, and whose title came first in a document were not trivial matters: they signaled rank, and rank shaped claims. Meanwhile the fighting continued, and each victory or defeat shifted the talks. Crucially, the emperor accepted that the princes and cities of the empire could send their own delegations, which made the congress an assembly of the empire as well as of Europe.

The Dutch settlement

One war ended first. In the Peace of Münster of January 1648, Spain recognized the independence of the Dutch Republic, ending eighty years of conflict. The ceremony of ratification in May was painted by the Dutch artist Gerard ter Borch, who placed himself among the onlookers. Spain made this peace partly to free its strength for the war with France, which did not end with Westphalia at all but continued until 1659.

The treaties of October 1648

On 24 October 1648 the emperor signed two treaties, one with Sweden at Osnabrück and one with France at Münster. Their main terms can be grouped in three parts.

First, rewards for the victors. Sweden gained western Pomerania, the port of Wismar and the bishoprics of Bremen and Verden, held as fiefs of the empire, which gave it seats in the imperial diet. It also received five million thalers to pay off its army. France gained full sovereignty over the bishoprics of Metz, Toul and Verdun, which it had occupied since 1552, and Habsburg rights in Alsace whose exact meaning was left vague, a source of later disputes.

Second, German territorial changes. Brandenburg received eastern Pomerania and several former bishoprics. Bavaria kept its electoral title, and a new eighth electorate was created for Frederick V's son, Charles Louis, who recovered the Rhine Palatinate. The Swiss Confederation's independence from imperial jurisdiction was also confirmed.

Third, religion and the constitution. Calvinists were finally admitted to the religious peace. Subjects whose faith differed from their ruler's were allowed to worship privately and to emigrate without losing their property. In the diet, religious questions could no longer be settled by majority vote: Catholic and Protestant members met separately and had to reach agreement, a procedure called itio in partes, "going into parts". The princes' right to make alliances with foreign powers was confirmed, provided they were not directed against the emperor or the empire. France and Sweden became guarantors of the settlement.

The peace had limits. The emperor's own hereditary lands, including Bohemia and Austria, were largely exempted from the guarantees for religious minorities, so Protestants there gained little. And Pope Innocent X issued a formal protest, dated November 1648, declaring the religious clauses null and void. The signatories had anticipated this and written into the treaties that no such protest would have force.

Worked example: the problem of paying armies off

Signing a peace did not make armies disappear. Tens of thousands of soldiers, many with families, were still quartered across the empire and would not leave until paid. The Swedish five million thalers had to be raised from the German territories themselves, district by district.

So a second conference met at Nuremberg in 1649 and 1650 to work out the details of demobilization: which troops would leave which towns, in what order, and on what payment. In September 1649 the Swedish commander Carl Gustav, the future King Charles X, hosted a great peace banquet in Nuremberg's town hall, recorded in a large painting by Joachim von Sandrart, while the hard bargaining continued around it. The last garrisons did not leave some places until the early 1650s.

Apply this to any peace process. A treaty is a promise; disarmament is logistics. Fighters must be paid, fed and sent home, or they become bandits. Victims, meanwhile, often fund the settlement, as German towns funded Swedish withdrawal. The negotiators of 1648 understood this, which is why the treaties included detailed payment schedules, guarantees and a general amnesty, and why many towns celebrated peace festivals only after the soldiers had actually gone.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How were the Westphalian talks divided between two towns?
2. What did Spain recognize in the Peace of Münster of January 1648?
3. When did the emperor sign the treaties with Sweden and France?
4. What territories did Sweden gain at Westphalia?
5. How was the Palatine question resolved in 1648?
6. How were religious questions handled in the diet after 1648?
7. Which lands were largely exempted from protections for religious minorities?
8. What did Carl Gustav host in Nuremberg in September 1649?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia