The Tokugawa order was designed by warriors who distrusted commerce. Yet peace, roads and the endless travel of lords and their retinues turned Japan into one of the most commercialized societies of its time. Merchants, ranked last in official theory, ended up holding much of the samurai class in debt.
Growth on the land
The first century of peace saw a burst of land clearing, irrigation and river control. By some estimates the area under cultivation nearly doubled between 1600 and 1720. Population grew with it. From perhaps 12 to 18 million in 1600, the population roughly doubled to about 30 million by the early eighteenth century, then leveled off for more than a hundred years. Historians debate why growth stalled: limits of land and technology, famines, late marriage and deliberate family limitation, including infanticide, all played a part.
Farming also changed in character. The historian Hayami Akira described an "industrious revolution": growth that came from families working longer and harder, not from machines or more animals. In some regions the number of draft animals actually fell as farmers replaced them with their own labor and careful hand cultivation. Farmers grew cotton, tobacco, indigo and mulberry for silkworms to sell, and they bought fertilizer such as dried sardines and herring meal to push yields higher. A farm household was increasingly a small business, watching prices and keeping accounts.
Three metals and two capitals of trade
Money was complicated. The shogunate minted gold, silver and copper coins, and different regions preferred different metals. Osaka and the west did business in silver, weighed out by the unit, while Edo and the east counted in gold, and copper coins served for everyday purchases. Money changers who converted between them became the country's bankers.
Osaka was the commercial heart. Domains needed cash to pay for life in Edo, so they shipped their tax rice to Osaka for sale. The kurayashiki were domain warehouses in Osaka where tax rice was stored and sold, and around them grew a world of brokers, lenders and shippers. Osaka was called the kitchen of the realm, because the goods of the whole country passed through it. Edo, by contrast, was the great consumer, a city of samurai households, servants and craftsmen with perhaps a million people.
Roads and travelers
Five main highways radiated from Edo, the most famous being the Tokaido along the Pacific coast to Kyoto. Post towns along them offered inns, porters and horses, at first for officials and lords' processions, but more and more for commoners. Travel required permits, and checkpoints watched closely for guns going into Edo and for women leaving it, since a lord's wife slipping home could signal a plot. Even so, millions of ordinary people traveled on pilgrimages, above all to the great shrines at Ise, and guidebooks, maps and travel diaries sold briskly. The roads carried goods, news and fashions as well as people.
New ways of doing business
Some merchant houses grew enormous. In 1673 Mitsui Takatoshi opened a cloth shop called Echigoya in Edo. Most shops then sold on credit to wealthy customers after visiting them at home and haggling over prices. Echigoya sold over the counter for cash at fixed, posted prices, and would cut cloth to any length. Sales soared, and the house went on to run money exchanges for the shogunate. Merchant families wrote house codes that stressed thrift, honesty, careful bookkeeping and loyalty to the firm across generations.
The debts of the warriors
Samurai were paid stipends in rice, but they needed cash. In Edo, the fudasashi were brokers who collected the stipend rice of the shogun's retainers, sold it and lent money against future stipends. As prices of goods rose faster than the price of rice, many samurai fell deeper into debt to the merchants they were supposed to outrank, and some quietly adopted merchant sons as heirs in return for cash.
Worked example: following a bale of rice
Imagine a bale of rice harvested in a village in Kaga in the 1750s. The headman collects it as part of the village's tax, and the domain ships it by sea around the western tip of Honshu to Osaka. There it goes into the domain's warehouse, and a merchant buys it with a paper certificate that he may sell on to another trader before the rice ever moves. The domain uses the silver it earns to pay its huge expenses in Edo, where the lord lives every other year with hundreds of retainers. Those retainers spend their own stipends on food, clothing, books and theater tickets.
Along the route the bale has fed shippers, warehouse workers, brokers, lenders and craftsmen. It has also created debts: the domain may have borrowed against next year's harvest, and the retainers against next year's stipend. A political system meant to keep warriors on top and merchants at the bottom created, through its own rules, a national market in which merchants held much of the power. The rulers could punish individual merchants, cancel debts or ban luxuries, but they could not do without the people who made the system run.
