Skip to main content

The Tokugawa system was built for a world of rice and warriors, and every few decades the shogunate tried to pull reality back toward that design. Historians speak of cycles of reform: bursts of austerity, moral campaigns and new regulations, followed by drift. The shoguns and ministers involved are some of the most vivid figures of the age.

The dog shogun

Tsunayoshi, the fifth shogun, ruled from 1680 to 1709. From the mid 1680s he issued a stream of edicts known as the Laws of Compassion for Living Things. They protected animals, above all dogs, and also forbade abandoning sick travelers and unwanted children. People were punished for harming dogs, and the shogunate built huge kennels on the edge of Edo that reportedly housed tens of thousands of strays. Townspeople mocked Tsunayoshi as the dog shogun, and his successor repealed the laws almost as soon as he died. For centuries he was remembered as a crank. Some historians now argue that he was trying, through Buddhist and Confucian ideals, to teach a society still shaped by warrior violence to value life. Both views can be partly true.

Tsunayoshi's reign was also an age of spending. To pay for it, the Genroku recoinage of 1695 lowered the gold and silver content of the coins, letting the shogunate mint more money from the same metal. Prices rose. The Confucian adviser Arai Hakuseki later persuaded the shogunate to restore the coins' quality.

The rice shogun

Yoshimune, the eighth shogun, came from the Kii branch house in 1716 and set out to restore the finances and spirit of Ieyasu's day. His Kyoho reforms cut spending, encouraged new fields and promoted sweet potatoes as a famine crop. In 1721 he placed a petition box outside his offices where commoners could submit proposals. One suggestion, from a town doctor, led to a free clinic for the poor of Edo, opened at Koishikawa in 1722. Short of revenue, Yoshimune let daimyo spend less time in Edo in return for contributions of rice, a concession he dropped once finances improved. He also relaxed the ban on Western books, so long as they had nothing to do with Christianity, opening the way for Dutch learning.

Famine and the merchant minister

In the 1770s and 1780s power rested with Tanuma Okitsugu, a minister who looked to commerce for revenue. He licensed merchant guilds in return for fees, studied plans to develop Ezo in the north and backed land reclamation. Critics accused him of bribery, and his reputation collapsed with a disaster. Cold summers ruined harvests from 1782, and in 1783 Mount Asama erupted, covering fields with ash. The Tenmei famine killed hundreds of thousands, mostly in the northeast. In 1787 crowds in Edo and other cities carried out uchikowashi, the smashing of rice dealers' shops and houses, targeting merchants accused of hoarding. They usually destroyed goods rather than stealing them, to show they acted from justice and not greed.

The Kansei reforms

Tanuma fell, and Matsudaira Sadanobu, a grandson of Yoshimune, took charge from 1787 to 1793. He ordered daimyo to store rice against famine, created a savings fund for poor relief in Edo and cancelled many old debts that the shogun's retainers owed to rice brokers. He also tried to discipline ideas. His ban of 1790 limited teaching at the shogunate's official academy to the Neo-Confucianism of Zhu Xi, and he punished writers whose books seemed frivolous or alarming, including one who warned that Japan's coasts were defenseless. His reforms eased the crisis but could not change the underlying gap between fixed rice revenues and a growing money economy.

Worked example: Uesugi Yozan of Yonezawa

Reform also happened in the domains. In 1767 a teenage adopted heir, Uesugi Harunori, later known as Yozan, inherited Yonezawa in northern Japan, a domain so deep in debt that its leaders had considered handing it back to the shogunate. He cut his own household's spending sharply, wore cotton instead of silk and ate simple meals. He promoted lacquer trees, mulberry and silk weaving, reopened the domain academy and organized relief stores of grain. Yonezawa reportedly suffered far fewer deaths in the Tenmei famine than its neighbors, though such claims are hard to verify.

When Yozan handed the domain to his heir in 1785, he left three short precepts. In paraphrase: the domain is inherited from the ancestors and passed to descendants, not the lord's private property; the people belong to the domain, not to the lord; and the lord exists for the sake of the domain and its people, not the people for the lord. In a society that gave commoners no political rights, this was not democracy. It was a statement that power is a trust held for the governed, a principle that Confucian scholars had long taught and that rulers often ignored. Yozan's reputation rests on the attempt to live by it, and it remains a useful measure for judging any government's claims about whom it serves.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Tsunayoshi's Laws of Compassion mainly protect?
2. What happened to the Laws of Compassion after Tsunayoshi died?
3. What did the Genroku recoinage of 1695 do?
4. What came of one suggestion in Yoshimune's petition box?
5. What did Yoshimune offer daimyo for contributions of rice?
6. Which volcano's eruption in 1783 worsened the Tenmei famine?
7. What was uchikowashi?
8. What did Matsudaira Sadanobu's ban of 1790 do?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia