Skip to main content

Between 1346 and 1353 a disease swept from the grasslands north of the Black Sea across the Middle East, North Africa and Europe, killing a larger share of the people it reached than any war in recorded history. Those who lived through it rarely called it the Black Death. Contemporaries usually spoke of the great mortality or the great pestilence, in Latin mortalitas magna. The name we use spread centuries later, in Scandinavian and German writing of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries and in English mainly in the nineteenth. The word "black" probably meant dreadful, as in a black day, rather than describing a symptom.

One germ, three forms

The disease was plague, an infection caused by a bacterium now called Yersinia pestis. It takes three main forms, depending on how the germ enters the body and where it settles. In bubonic plague, the most common form, bacteria injected by a flea bite travel to the nearest lymph nodes. The nodes swell into hard, painful lumps called buboes: buboes are painfully swollen lymph nodes, usually in the groin, armpit or neck. Fever, chills, headache and exhaustion follow within a few days to a week. Untreated, bubonic plague killed perhaps half of its victims, though many recovered.

If the bacteria multiply in the blood itself, the result is septicemic plague, which can kill before any bubo appears and may cause bleeding under the skin and blackened fingers and toes. If the infection reaches the lungs, it becomes pneumonic plague. Pneumonic plague can pass from person to person through droplets coughed into the air, with no flea involved. Without treatment it is almost always fatal, often within two or three days.

Rodents, fleas and people

Plague is at root a disease of animals. The germ survives between epidemics in colonies of wild rodents, such as marmots and gerbils in the grasslands and mountains of Central Asia, where it circulates among burrows and their fleas. Humans are accidental victims. An outbreak among people usually begins when infected fleas leave dying rodents and bite whatever warm body is nearby.

The classic account of the medieval epidemic gives the leading role to the black rat, which lived close to people in houses, barns and ships, and to its fleas. Some researchers doubt that rats can explain how fast the disease moved through crowded towns. In 2018 a team that modeled deaths in nine European cities argued that human fleas and body lice, passing the infection directly between people, fit the recorded patterns better than rats alone. Others reply that rats, human parasites and pneumonic spread could all have worked together, in proportions that changed with place and season. The question is still open.

How the culprit was found

For more than five centuries no one knew what caused plague. The answer came during a later pandemic. Alexandre Yersin, a Swiss-born French physician, identified the bacterium in Hong Kong in 1894, and it now bears his name. The Japanese researcher Kitasato Shibasaburo, working in the same city, reported a germ at almost the same moment. Four years later, Paul-Louis Simond showed in Karachi that fleas carried the germ from rats to people.

Some historians still doubted that the medieval catastrophe was the same disease, since it seemed to spread faster than plague did in modern India or China. Ancient DNA settled the question of identity. Teeth hold traces of the blood that once flowed through them, and in 2011 scientists published a genome of the bacterium rebuilt from teeth found in the East Smithfield cemetery in London, an emergency burial ground opened in 1348 and 1349. The study rebuilt the genome of the plague germ from medieval teeth. Later work found the same germ in graves across Europe and Asia.

Not the first pandemic

Historians count three great plague pandemics. The first began with the Plague of Justinian in 541, named for the Roman emperor who then reigned from Constantinople, and it returned in waves for about two centuries. The Black Death opened the second, which recurred for some four hundred years. The third began in southwestern China in the nineteenth century and spread around the world by steamship.

Worked example: reading a chronicler's symptoms

A chronicler in an Italian town writes that some victims developed swellings the size of an egg under the arm and lingered for several days, while others coughed blood and died within three days, and that people who nursed the second group often fell ill themselves. How should we read this?

The swellings are buboes, the mark of the bubonic form. The coughing of blood and the speed of death point to the pneumonic form, and the sickness among nurses fits its direct spread through the air. A careful reader then asks two more questions. Did the writer witness these cases or repeat what others said? And does the account follow a model, since many medieval chroniclers borrowed phrases from ancient descriptions of epidemics? Here the details fit what modern medicine and the DNA from graves tell us, which makes the report more believable. A description that matched no known disease would call for more doubt, not less.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did people who lived through the epidemic usually call it?
2. What are buboes?
3. How can pneumonic plague spread?
4. Where does the plague germ survive between epidemics?
5. Who identified the plague bacterium in Hong Kong in 1894?
6. What did Paul-Louis Simond show in Karachi?
7. What did the 2011 study of teeth from East Smithfield achieve?
8. How did the first plague pandemic begin?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia