Skip to main content

By the 1830s silver was leaving China in large amounts, and many officials linked the outflow to opium. Because ordinary people used copper coins but paid taxes reckoned in silver, a rising price of silver squeezed farmers and alarmed the court. The Daoguang emperor, who reigned from 1820 to 1850, faced a real policy choice, and his officials argued it openly.

Legalize or suppress?

In 1836 the official Xu Naiji sent the emperor a memorial, a formal written proposal, arguing that prohibition had failed. Xu proposed legalizing and taxing opium, to be paid for in goods rather than silver, so that the drain would stop. He also suggested letting Chinese farmers grow their own poppies to undercut imports, while keeping the ban for officials, scholars and soldiers. To his supporters this was realism: a law that could not be enforced only bred corruption.

Critics replied that the state could not profit from poisoning its own people, and that legalization would be a surrender to foreigners. In 1838 Huang Juezi went further. Huang urged death for smokers who had not quit within a year of a grace period. Attack demand, he argued, and the trade would wither. Most provincial officials consulted thought this too harsh, but the emperor chose suppression. Arrests and executions of Chinese dealers increased, and the court looked for a man who could finish the job.

The commissioner

Lin Zexu, born in Fujian in 1785, had a reputation for honesty and energy. He had been governor-general of Hubei and Hunan, where he had run a strict anti-opium campaign. The emperor named him imperial commissioner with full powers, and he reached Canton in March 1839.

Lin moved quickly. He arrested Chinese dealers, collected large numbers of pipes and ordered the foreign merchants to hand over all their opium and sign bonds promising never to bring more, on pain of death. When they stalled, he blockaded the factories and took away their Chinese servants, trapping about 350 foreigners in their buildings for six weeks. They were not harmed, but they were cut off.

The British Superintendent of Trade, Captain Charles Elliot, had little love for the opium dealers. Yet he now made a decision of great consequence. Elliot promised the merchants that their government would compensate them if they surrendered their opium to him. The dealers, who faced a collapsing market, gladly agreed. In this way private contraband became, in British eyes, crown property seized by a foreign government. More than 20,000 chests were handed over, and in June Lin had them destroyed.

A letter and a library

Lin also wrote to Queen Victoria. Believing, wrongly, that Britain banned opium at home, he asked how a ruler could allow her subjects to sell to others a drug she would not let her own people use. It was a moral appeal from one sovereign's servant to another. It was printed in the British press, though there is no evidence the queen ever saw it.

Lin was more curious about the West than his enemies assumed. He hired translators to render foreign newspapers and books into Chinese, and gathered material for a geography of the world. He had passages from Vattel's book on the law of nations translated, apparently to check how European law treated a state's right to ban imports and punish smugglers. He was trying to meet the foreigners on their own legal ground.

The killing at Kowloon

Tension rose through the summer. In July 1839 drunken sailors killed a villager, Lin Weixi, at Kowloon, across the water from Hong Kong Island. Lin Zexu demanded that the killer be handed over to Chinese justice. Elliot refused, held his own trial on a ship and sentenced several sailors to fines and prison, but they were freed once they reached England. Lin cut off food to the British, who left Macau and lived on their ships off Hong Kong. In September and November small naval clashes broke out. The refusal to hand over the sailors raised a question that would last for a century: whose law governed foreigners on Chinese soil?

Worked example: whose property?

Consider the puzzle Elliot created. Before his promise, the opium belonged to merchants who had broken Chinese law, and most governments would accept that a state may seize contraband. After his promise, the British government could tell itself that a Chinese official had confiscated property owed to the crown and humiliated its representative. Lin saw a lawful confiscation of illegal goods. The merchants saw a safe sale at a good price in a falling market. In London, the foreign secretary Lord Palmerston saw an insult and a debt. The same chests now carried three different meanings. Notice how one administrative decision changed the moral framing of a dispute. A quarrel about drugs and smuggling could now be argued as a quarrel about property, honor and the equality of states, and that is how much of the British debate would be conducted.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Xu Naiji propose in 1836?
2. What did Huang Juezi urge in 1838?
3. Which post had Lin Zexu held before going to Canton?
4. How did Lin force the foreign merchants to give up their opium?
5. What did Charles Elliot promise the British merchants?
6. Roughly how many chests of opium were handed over in 1839?
7. Which European work did Lin have passages of translated?
8. What happened at Kowloon in July 1839?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia