Skip to main content

Paper that failed

Hongwu inherited a tradition of paper money from earlier dynasties, and from 1375 he issued notes called the Great Ming Treasure Notes. But the government printed them freely, held no reserves to redeem them, and would not accept them for many payments. Printed without backing, the notes steadily lost value until, by the middle of the fifteenth century, they were nearly worthless in the market. People turned to copper coins for small purchases and to uncoined silver, weighed by the tael, an ounce of about 37 grams, for larger ones. Silver became the money of the Ming economy almost against the state's will.

A tangle of obligations

Early Ming taxes were paid mainly in grain and cloth, and every household also owed labor service: carrying goods, guarding granaries, running post stations or serving as local runners. Labor duties were assigned through the lijia system and fell very unevenly. Rich families with connections slipped out of them, and the burden landed on those least able to bear it. Many households fled their land to escape.

From the early sixteenth century local officials in many regions began converting these obligations into silver payments. The reforms took many local forms, but they shared a goal and came to be called the Single Whip, from a pun on the words for "combine into one item." The reform combined the land tax and labor service into a single payment in silver, assessed mainly on land. Officials then hired workers with the money. The changes were tried province by province for decades.

Zhang Juzheng

The man who drove the reform across the whole empire was Zhang Juzheng, senior Grand Secretary from 1572 to 1582. He served as tutor to the boy Wanli emperor and dominated the government in his name. Zhang ordered a new survey of farmland to find hidden fields and pressed the silver tax system nationwide around 1581. He also introduced a system that tracked officials' tasks and deadlines in ledgers checked month by month, so that the capital could see who was doing his job. Revenues rose and the treasury filled.

Zhang made many enemies. He broke the rules of mourning when his father died so that he could keep his post, and his grip on the young emperor bred resentment. Soon after his death in 1582, Wanli turned on his memory. Zhang was stripped of his honors, and in 1584 his family's property was seized and his eldest son killed himself under interrogation. Many of his reforms survived him, but the lesson for later ministers was that even success could not protect them.

Merchants and markets

The Ming economy grew more commercial with each generation. To supply the northern garrisons, the state used a scheme called kaizhong, in which merchants delivered grain to frontier armies in return for licenses to sell salt, a state monopoly. Merchant families from Shanxi and Huizhou grew rich in the salt trade and branched into pawnshops, timber and moneylending, spreading guild halls across the empire.

Whole regions specialized. Songjiang, near modern Shanghai, became the great center of cotton cloth weaving, with farm women spinning and weaving at home for merchants who shipped the cloth across China. Jingdezhen, in Jiangxi, was home to the imperial porcelain kilns, where thousands of workers each handled a single step, from shaping to painting to firing. Its blue and white wares filled palaces from Istanbul to Lisbon.

Worked example: a farmer and the price of silver

Imagine a farmer near Suzhou around 1590. He sells his rice and cotton cloth in the local market for copper coins, the only money most villagers handle day to day. His tax under the Single Whip is set at 2 taels of silver.

To pay, he must change copper for silver at a moneychanger's shop. Suppose the rate is 700 copper coins to one tael. His tax then costs him 1,400 coins. Now suppose silver becomes scarce and the rate climbs to 1,000 coins per tael. His tax, still 2 taels on paper, now costs 2,000 coins, an increase of 600 coins, or nearly 43 percent, though no official raised it.

This simple arithmetic explains why the silver economy brought both freedom and danger. The Single Whip ended many hated labor duties, and paying in money let families decide how to spend their time. But it tied every farmer's burden to the price of a metal whose supply depended on mines in distant lands and on ships he would never see. When silver was abundant, the system worked. When the flow faltered, as it did in the seventeenth century, the poorest felt it first, which is one reason fair taxation remains a question of human dignity and not only of accounting.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did Ming paper money lose its value?
2. What did the Single Whip reform do?
3. Who pressed the Single Whip system across the whole empire?
4. What happened to Zhang Juzheng's family after his death?
5. What did Zhang Juzheng's ledger system track?
6. How did the kaizhong scheme work?
7. What was Songjiang best known for in the Ming?
8. What was located at Jingdezhen?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia