Skip to main content

Trouble in the north

After Tumu the Ming gave up hope of defeating the Mongols on the steppe. The question became how to keep them out. Mongol leaders, for their part, mostly did not want to conquer China. They wanted access to Chinese goods, such as grain, cloth, tea and iron pots, which the dry grasslands could not produce. When the Ming refused trade, they raided.

In the sixteenth century the most powerful Mongol leader was Altan Khan. Again and again he asked for markets on the border, and again and again the court refused, partly out of pride and partly from fear that trade would feed the enemy. Altan's raids were meant to force the Ming to open frontier markets. In 1550 his horsemen rode right up to the suburbs of Beijing, burning and plundering, before withdrawing.

The deadlock broke in 1571. After a family quarrel sent Altan's grandson over to the Ming side, officials on the frontier negotiated a settlement. Altan received a Ming title as a loyal prince, and licensed horse markets opened along the border. Raids fell sharply in the years that followed, and the frontier was quieter than it had been for a century.

Building the wall

While trade was refused, the Ming built walls. Earlier dynasties had built long earthen ramparts, but much of the Ming wall was new, and its builders chose stone and fired brick for the most important stretches. One of the great builders was the general Qi Jiguang, who was sent north in 1568 to guard the approaches to Beijing. There he added hundreds of hollow brick watchtowers, where soldiers could live, store weapons and shelter from arrows, along the mountain ridges. The famous sections that visitors see today near Beijing owe much to work of this period.

The historian Arthur Waldron argued in 1990 that the idea of a single Great Wall standing for two thousand years is a myth. The Ming walls, he showed, were the product of particular policy debates, built when the court rejected the alternatives of attack or trade. Walls were a choice, and an expensive one.

The sea ban

On the coast the Ming took a similar line. Hongwu had issued a sea ban, which forbade private Chinese trade overseas and allowed foreign trade only as part of official tribute missions. The ban was meant to cut off pirates and rebels at sea, and it was renewed many times.

But coastal people lived by the sea, and demand for Chinese silk and porcelain abroad was immense. Smuggling flourished, often from offshore islands. The raiders and smugglers who plagued the coast in the 1550s were called wokou, Japanese pirates. In fact, most of them were Chinese traders and coastal people, working with Japanese and Portuguese partners. A later official history of the dynasty claimed that only about three in ten were truly Japanese.

The best known leader was Wang Zhi, a merchant from Anhui who ran a smuggling empire from bases in Japan. In 1557 he was persuaded to come ashore with promises of pardon and the hope that trade would be legalized. Instead he was arrested and later executed.

Soldiers from the hills

Qi Jiguang made his name fighting the coastal raiders before he went north. He found regular garrison troops useless and recruited his own army from tough farmers and miners of Yiwu, in Zhejiang. He drilled them hard and taught them the mandarin duck formation, a squad of about a dozen men combining long and short weapons, in which shield bearers, spearmen and men carrying bamboo poles with branches left on protected each other. His manuals on training were read for centuries.

The door opens

In 1567, under the new Longqing emperor, the court took a different path. It allowed licensed merchants to sail from Moon Harbor in Fujian to Southeast Asia, though trade with Japan stayed banned. Piracy declined, the treasury collected duties, and Chinese junks soon carried silk to Manila to be exchanged for American silver.

Worked example: walls or markets?

Put yourself in a court debate in the 1560s. A hard-line official argues that trading with the Mongols rewards raiders, feeds a dangerous enemy and shames the Son of Heaven. Build more wall, he says, and train better soldiers. His argument is not foolish. Mongol leaders were not bound by a central authority, and a market opened to one chief could not stop another from raiding.

A frontier official replies that the raids happen because the Mongols need things only China can supply. Every year of refusal costs lives and silver, while a market would let both sides gain. Walls on their own leave the cause untouched.

The evidence after 1571 favored the frontier official, at least for a time: raids fell, and market duties helped pay the garrisons. The same reasoning applied on the coast, where opening trade in 1567 weakened piracy more than decades of bans had. The lesson Ming officials drew was that people treated as enemies because of a ban may behave as partners once they are allowed to trade, but they drew it only after a very long and costly delay.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What were Altan Khan's raids mainly meant to achieve?
2. What did the settlement of 1571 give Altan Khan?
3. What did Qi Jiguang add to the wall near Beijing?
4. What did the Ming sea ban forbid?
5. Who made up most of the so-called wokou raiders of the 1550s?
6. Who was Wang Zhi?
7. What was the mandarin duck formation?
8. What changed at Moon Harbor in 1567?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia