In the winter of 1916 to 1917, while Pershing's troops were still in Chihuahua and Zapata still held Morelos, about two hundred delegates gathered in the colonial city of Querétaro to write a new constitution. The document they produced, promulgated on 5 February 1917, is still Mexico's constitution today, amended many hundreds of times. It turned the demands of the battlefield into law, at least on paper.
Who wrote it
The convention was not a meeting of all revolutionaries. Supporters of Villa and Zapata were excluded, so every delegate belonged to Carranza's side. Carranza sent a moderate draft that largely updated the liberal constitution of 1857. But a large group of younger delegates, often called the jacobins after the radicals of the French Revolution, wanted much more. Many were close to Obregón. Their leading figure was Francisco Múgica, a general from Michoacán who led the radical delegates. On the articles that mattered most, the radicals won.
Article 3: schools
Article 3 required that education be secular, not only in public schools but in private primary schools as well. Religious bodies and clergy were forbidden to run primary schools, and primary education in public schools was to be free. The radicals saw the Church as the old regime's ally and wanted the next generation formed by the nation rather than the clergy.
Article 27: land and subsoil
Article 27 overturned the liberal idea of property as an absolute right. It declared that ownership of lands and waters belonged originally to the nation, which could transfer them to private owners but could also impose limits on property in the public interest. Villages that had lost lands could have them restored, and those without enough could receive grants. Above all, minerals and oil beneath the ground were declared the direct property of the nation. Foreigners could own land only if they agreed to be treated as Mexicans in any dispute and not to seek the protection of their own governments.
Article 123: labor
Article 123 was a whole labor code written into the constitution. It promised an eight hour day, a weekly day of rest, a minimum wage, equal pay for equal work regardless of sex or nationality, compensation for workplace accidents and the right of workers to organize and to strike. Children under twelve could not be employed. Workers were even promised a share of company profits. For Mexicans who remembered Cananea, the equal pay clause had a special meaning.
Article 130: the churches
The constitution went further against the Church than any before it. Article 130 denied churches legal personality, so they could not own property in their own name. Clergy had to be Mexican by birth, could not vote, and were forbidden to criticize the laws or the government. State legislatures could limit the number of priests. These clauses would one day provoke a war.
Who was left out
The constitution did not give women the vote. The feminist Hermila Galindo, a close aide of Carranza, petitioned the convention for women's suffrage and was refused. In Yucatán, the revolutionary governor Salvador Alvarado had already sponsored two feminist congresses in Mérida in 1916, where women debated education, work and political rights. Mexican women won the national vote only in 1953.
Paper and practice
Carranza became constitutional president in May 1917, but he enforced the new articles slowly. He returned many confiscated haciendas to their owners and distributed little land. In Morelos, his army waged a brutal campaign against the Zapatistas. On 10 April 1919 Zapata was lured to the hacienda of Chinameca by a colonel, Jesús Guajardo, who pretended to defect to him, and was shot dead on arrival.
In 1920 Carranza tried to choose his own successor, a little known diplomat, Ignacio Bonillas, in order to block Obregón. Obregón and his Sonoran allies rebelled under the Plan of Agua Prieta. Carranza fled the capital by train with the treasury's gold, and in May 1920 he was killed at the village of Tlaxcalantongo, in the mountains of Puebla. Of the revolution's great leaders, Madero, Zapata and now Carranza had all died violently, and Villa and Obregón would follow.
Worked example: three readers of Article 27
Imagine three people reading Article 27 in 1917. A villager from Morelos reads it as a promise that the nation stands behind the community's ancient claim to its fields. An American oil executive at Tampico reads it as a threat: if oil underground belongs to the nation, perhaps the wells his company bought under Díaz are no longer his. A liberal lawyer reads it as a troubling expansion of state power over every citizen's property.
Each reading is reasonable. The article rests on a real idea, that property exists within a society and can be shaped by the needs of that society. It also concentrates great discretion in the hands of the state, which may use it for the poor or for its own allies. The test of such rights lies less in their wording than in who enforces them, how fairly, and whether the people they protect can hold the enforcers to account. In 1917 that test still lay ahead.
