Huerta's fall did not bring peace. The armies that had beaten him disagreed about almost everything except their hatred of him, and within months they turned on one another. The fighting of 1914 to 1917 was the bloodiest of the whole revolution, and its outcome decided which version of the revolution would shape the Mexican state.
Why the coalition broke
The split was personal, but it also had social roots. Villa's and Zapata's armies were made up largely of peasants, cowboys and rural workers, and they wanted land and local self-rule. Carranza's movement drew on provincial middle classes, northern ranchers and ambitious officers who wanted a strong, modern national state.
In October 1914 the revolutionary factions tried to settle their differences at the Convention of Aguascalientes, a meeting of delegates chosen by the revolutionary armies. Zapatista representatives joined, and the Convention accepted the principles of the Plan of Ayala. It chose a provisional president, Eulalio Gutiérrez, and asked both Carranza and Villa to step aside. Carranza refused and withdrew with his government to Veracruz, which the Americans had just left. Obregón, after much hesitation, stayed loyal to Carranza.
Villa and Zapata in the capital
In December 1914 Villa and Zapata met for the first time at Xochimilco, on the edge of Mexico City, and agreed to fight together. Days later their armies paraded through the capital. A famous photograph shows Villa lounging in the presidential chair, grinning, with Zapata seated beside him looking wary. It was the high point of the popular revolution.
It did not last. Neither leader wanted to govern the nation from the capital. Zapata returned to Morelos. Villa turned north. Their alliance never produced a joint national program or a unified military plan.
Carranza's countermove
Carranza, by contrast, learned. In December 1914 he added promises of social reform to his Plan of Guadalupe. His decree of 6 January 1915 promised to restore and grant land to villages, borrowing the language of his peasant enemies; it was drafted largely by the lawyer Luis Cabrera. In February 1915 his movement signed a pact with the Casa del Obrero Mundial, a labor federation in Mexico City. In exchange for support for unions, urban workers formed "Red Battalions" to fight for Carranza, against peasant armies whose religious banners and rural ways many city workers distrusted.
The battles of Celaya
The decisive clashes came in the Bajío, the farming region north of the capital. In April 1915, at Celaya, Obregón dug in to receive Villa's attacks. Obregón used trenches, barbed wire and machine guns against Villa's cavalry charges, tactics he had studied from reports of the war then raging in Europe. Wave after wave of Villa's horsemen was cut down. In June a shell tore off Obregón's right arm, but he fought on. By the summer Villa's army was retreating north, broken.
In October 1915 the United States granted Carranza's government de facto recognition. It also allowed Carranza's troops to travel by American railways to defend the border town of Agua Prieta, where Villa was beaten again in November. Villa felt betrayed. On 9 March 1916 his men raided the town of Columbus, New Mexico, killing American soldiers and civilians. Wilson sent General John J. Pershing into Mexico with a Punitive Expedition of some ten thousand troops. It chased Villa for eleven months through the deserts of Chihuahua, never caught him, clashed with Carranza's forces, and withdrew in early 1917.
The cost
For ordinary people, 1915 was remembered as the year of hunger. Armies seized crops and livestock, railways were wrecked, and each faction printed its own paper money, which the others refused to accept. Typhus and later the influenza of 1918 swept through weakened towns. Mexico's census counted about 15.2 million people in 1910 and about 14.3 million in 1921. Deaths, emigration to the United States and lost births together account for the gap, and many historians estimate that around a million people died.
The doctor Mariano Azuela, who served with Villa's forces, captured this mood in his novel The Underdogs, first published in 1915 in El Paso. Its peasant fighters keep fighting long after they have forgotten why, and its most famous image compares them to a stone that, once pushed off a cliff, cannot stop rolling.
Worked example: why Carranza and Obregón won
The popular armies of Villa and Zapata had more fighters in 1914, and they controlled the capital. Why did they lose?
Begin with resources. Carranza held Veracruz and the oil port of Tampico, whose customs duties and oil taxes paid for weapons, while Villa's cattle and cotton sales dried up as his territory shrank. Next, strategy and leadership: Obregón adapted to modern firepower; Villa kept charging. Then alliances: Carranza won workers and the recognition of the United States. Finally, program: by promising land and labor rights, Carranza stole much of his enemies' appeal.
None of this made the result inevitable. But the case shows a pattern seen in many revolutions: the movement that wins is often not the one with the most popular fighters, but the one that builds a state, secures revenue and borrows its rivals' ideas. The revolution would be carried out from above, by a national government, in the name of the peasants and workers who had fought it from below.
