In 1928 Chiang Kai-shek's Nationalists took Beijing and declared China unified under a new capital at Nanjing. Twenty-one years later Chiang was fleeing to Taiwan and Mao Zedong was proclaiming a new state from the gate of the old palace. How a hunted rural movement beat a recognized government with a far larger army is one of the great questions of the century.
The Nanjing decade
The years from 1928 to 1937 are often called the Nanjing decade. The Nationalist government built roads and railways, reformed the currency, expanded schools and won back control of tariffs from the foreign powers. It was also a one-party state that ruled through the army, arrested critics and depended on deals with surviving warlords. Its hold on the countryside was weak, and it did little about rents and debts that crushed tenant farmers.
The Communists go to the countryside
After the 1927 massacres, Communist survivors fled to the hills. Mao had already argued that the peasants, not only urban workers, would make the revolution. In a 1927 report on the peasant movement in his home province of Hunan he wrote: "A revolution is not a dinner party." In the mountains of Jiangxi province the Communists set up a Soviet Republic, redistributed land and built a Red Army. Chiang launched a series of encirclement campaigns against them, and in 1934 the fifth one succeeded.
In October 1934 about 86,000 Communists broke out and began the Long March, a fighting retreat of thousands of miles through the mountains and grasslands of the southwest and west. In January 1935, at a meeting in the town of Zunyi, Mao won a leading voice in military affairs at the Zunyi conference, the first step in his rise to command of the party. Fewer than 10,000 of those who left Jiangxi reached the north in October 1935, according to most estimates, settling in a poor region of Shaanxi province around the town of Yan'an. Later party histories turned the march into a founding legend, and some episodes, such as the crossing of the Luding Bridge, may have been exaggerated.
Japan's war
Japan seized Manchuria in 1931, and Chiang chose to finish the Communists before fighting Japan, a policy many Chinese resented. In December 1936 Chiang flew to the city of Xi'an to push his commanders there into a new campaign. Instead the commander Zhang Xueliang, whose own homeland of Manchuria had been lost to Japan, had Chiang arrested. The Xi'an Incident forced Chiang to agree to a united front against Japan. Chiang was released on Christmas Day, and Zhang spent most of the rest of his long life under house arrest.
Full war with Japan began in 1937 and lasted eight years. The Nationalists bore the brunt of the big battles, lost the coast and its cities, and retreated to Chongqing in the southwest. Their armies were drained, and wartime printing of money set off inflation. The Communists, meanwhile, fought mainly a guerrilla war behind Japanese lines in the north and grew from tens of thousands of members to more than a million. In Yan'an, the Rectification Movement of 1942 to 1944 made Mao's thought party orthodoxy, through study sessions, forced self-criticism and the persecution of suspected spies. Its methods would be used again on a vast scale.
Civil war
Japan surrendered in August 1945. American envoys, above all General George Marshall, tried to arrange a coalition government, but full civil war broke out in 1946. On paper the Nationalists had more troops, American weapons and international recognition. Yet the Communists took over most of Manchuria, where Soviet forces had handed them captured Japanese arms, and in the great campaigns of late 1948 and early 1949 they destroyed Nationalist armies by the hundreds of thousands. In the cities, runaway inflation wrecked the Nationalist government's support: a new currency issued in August 1948 collapsed within months, wiping out the savings of the middle class.
On 1 October 1949 Mao proclaimed the People's Republic of China from Tiananmen, the gate of the old palace. Chiang moved his government to Taiwan, along with gold reserves and about a million soldiers and civilians, and the Republic of China continues there. Its rule there had begun harshly: in the February 1947 uprising and crackdown, troops killed thousands of Taiwanese, and martial law lasted from 1949 to 1987.
Worked example: Why did the Communists win?
Historians have offered several explanations, and each fits some evidence. In 1962 the political scientist Chalmers Johnson argued peasant nationalism, roused by the Japanese invasion, explained the result: villagers joined the Communists because they led resistance to brutal occupation, not because they believed in Marxism. Mark Selden and others replied that the party's social program mattered more: rent reduction, land reform and cooperative work gave peasants a stake in Communist rule. A third school stresses Nationalist failure: corruption, inflation and an army exhausted by eight years of war against Japan. A fourth points to organization: the Communists built a disciplined party that reached into villages in a way the Nationalists never did. Test each against a case. In Manchuria the Japanese had already left by 1946, so peasant nationalism explains little there, while Soviet help and land reform explain a great deal. A good answer combines causes and asks which mattered where.
