The men who ruled the Mamluk state were a few thousand foreign-born soldiers, most of whom spoke Turkish as their first language. The people they ruled were millions of Arabic-speaking Muslims, Christians and Jews in Egypt and Syria. How did such a small, foreign elite govern so many, for so long? Part of the answer is force. The larger part is a partnership with the civilian world of scholars, clerks and merchants, who needed the soldiers' protection and supplied what the soldiers lacked.
Two worlds in one city
Cairo under the Mamluks was among the largest cities west of China, with perhaps a quarter of a million people or more by the early fourteenth century; estimates vary widely. The Mamluk military elite mainly spoke Turkish, and some sultans barely spoke Arabic. Below them lay a dense Arabic-speaking city of craftsmen, shopkeepers, porters, water carriers, students and beggars.
Between the two stood the ulama, the scholars of religion and law. They staffed the courts, taught in the colleges, wrote the chancery's letters and kept the accounts. The soldiers needed them for two things: the skills to run a state, and the religious approval that made Mamluk rule look lawful rather than merely strong.
Four judges
Sunni Islam recognizes four schools of law: the Shafi'i, the Hanafi, the Maliki and the Hanbali. They agree on most matters but differ on many details of contracts, marriage, inheritance and endowments. Earlier Egyptian rulers had generally appointed a single Shafi'i chief judge. In 1265 Baybars appointed four chief judges, one for each Sunni school, a reform later copied in Damascus. Litigants could now bring certain cases before the judge whose school best served them, and the sultan gained more control over a judiciary no longer led by one man.
Endowments and Sufi lodges
The streets of Mamluk Cairo filled with religious buildings: mosques, madrasas for teaching law, public fountains, schools for orphans, and Sufi lodges. A khanqah was a lodge that housed Sufis, Muslim mystics, who lived there on stipends, prayed together and followed a master. Most of these institutions were supported by endowments of shops, baths, farmland or villages, whose income paid salaries and upkeep.
Endowments had a worldly attraction for mamluks. A founder could name his descendants as paid administrators of an endowment, so a family could keep income and status that an iqta could never pass on. Piety and family planning went together.
A scholar in prison
The ulama were not simply servants of power. Ibn Taymiyya, born in 1263 near Harran and raised in Damascus, was a Hanbali scholar of enormous learning and fierce independence. When the Ilkhan Ghazan invaded Syria, Ibn Taymiyya issued rulings on the Mongols. Ibn Taymiyya argued that the Mongol rulers, though they had converted, could be fought because they did not govern by Islamic law. His opponents had him jailed several times, and Ibn Taymiyya died in prison in the citadel of Damascus in 1328. His writings, little followed in his own day, became deeply influential centuries later.
Christians and Jews
Egypt still had a large Coptic Christian population, and Copts were prominent as clerks in the financial offices, which made them resented. Christians and Jews were dhimmis, protected non-Muslims who paid a special tax and lived under legal limits. Those limits were enforced unevenly. A decree of 1301 required Christians and Jews to wear turbans of distinctive colors, blue for Christians and yellow for Jews according to the chroniclers. Riots in 1321 and a wave of pressure in 1354 led to church burnings, dismissals and many conversions. Historians see these years as a turning point in Egypt becoming a society with a Muslim majority not only in power but in numbers.
A visitor from the West
The historian Ibn Khaldun, born in Tunis, arrived in Cairo in 1382 and stayed for the rest of his life. He lectured, wrote and was appointed several times to high office. In Cairo Ibn Khaldun served as the Maliki chief judge, and he was dismissed and restored repeatedly as factions changed.
Worked example: choosing a court
Imagine a Cairo widow who wants to lease out a shop belonging to an endowment for many years at a fixed rent, a deal one school of law might restrict and another permit. Under a single chief judge she would have one answer. Under the four-judge system she, or more likely her lawyer, could look for the court whose school allowed what she needed. Judges of different schools sometimes even confirmed one another's rulings, so a deal made under one school's rules could then be protected by another.
This was not simple fraud. It was a recognized way of using a plural legal order. It had costs as well as benefits: wealthy people with good advice could use the system more skillfully than the poor. But it also gave ordinary subjects, including women, who appear often in surviving court records as buyers, sellers and plaintiffs, real choices. It reminds us that law under a military regime was not just what the sultan wanted. It was a field where scholars, officials and ordinary people bargained over rules.
