In the 1790s the most radical people in Ireland were Presbyterian merchants in Belfast, and the most cautious were often Catholic bishops. That surprises anyone who reads the present back into the past. In a single generation Ireland saw an attempt at a nonsectarian republican revolution, its bloody defeat, the abolition of the Irish parliament, and then one of the first great peaceful mass movements in modern European politics.
The United Irishmen
The Society of United Irishmen was founded in Belfast in October 1791. Its best known figure was Theobald Wolfe Tone, a Dublin lawyer from the established Anglican church, but most of its first members were Presbyterian merchants and professionals in Belfast. Inspired by the American and French Revolutions and by Thomas Paine, they demanded reform of a parliament dominated by landlords, and equal rights for Catholics. Tone set out the aim in words later published in his journals: "to substitute the common name of Irishman in place of the denominations of Protestant, Catholic, and Dissenter." In other words, he wanted to replace the labels Protestant, Catholic and Dissenter with a shared Irish citizenship.
The government made concessions. A Relief Act in 1793 gave Catholics who met the property qualification the vote, though they still could not sit in parliament. But when Britain went to war with revolutionary France in 1793, it suppressed the Society, which went underground as a secret revolutionary organization seeking a French invasion.
The rebellion of 1798
Meanwhile sectarian conflict grew in the countryside. In County Armagh, Protestant and Catholic bands fought over land and leases, and after a clash in 1795 Protestants founded the Orange Order. In 1797 and 1798 the army disarmed suspect districts with floggings, house burnings and torture, which drove many into rebellion. When the rising came in May 1798 it was badly coordinated. Its most serious fighting was in County Wexford, where rebels, some led by Catholic priests, held much of the county until their defeat at Vinegar Hill in June. In Antrim and Down, Presbyterian United Irishmen rose and were defeated within days.
The rebellion's ideals did not stop atrocities. At Scullabogue in Wexford rebels burned a barn holding loyalist prisoners, most of them Protestants, and government forces killed surrendered and wounded rebels in large numbers. Estimates of the dead range from about ten thousand to thirty thousand, a wide spread that reflects poor records. Tone was captured on a French ship and died in prison in November 1798.
The Act of Union
The British prime minister, William Pitt, concluded that the Irish parliament could not keep order. He pressed for union, and after one defeat the Irish parliament voted itself out of existence in 1800, persuaded in part by a lavish distribution of peerages, offices and compensation. From 1 January 1801 the Act of Union created the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. The Irish parliament was abolished, and Ireland instead sent one hundred members to the House of Commons at Westminster.
Pitt had intended union to come with full rights for Catholics. But King George III refused to accept Catholic emancipation, and Pitt resigned.
O'Connell and emancipation
The next challenge came by a different road. Daniel O'Connell, a Catholic barrister from Kerry, believed that no political change was worth the shedding of blood. In 1823 he founded the Catholic Association. Its masterstroke was the Catholic rent, a subscription of a penny a month that ordinary tenants could afford, collected with the help of parish priests. It turned a lobby of gentlemen into a movement of hundreds of thousands.
In 1828 O'Connell stood for parliament in a County Clare by-election and won, even though as a Catholic he could not take his seat. The prime minister, the duke of Wellington, and his home secretary, Robert Peel, feared that refusing would lead to rebellion. In 1829 Parliament passed Catholic emancipation, letting Catholics sit in parliament and hold most high offices. There was a price: the small freeholders who had voted for O'Connell lost the vote, when the property qualification was raised from forty shillings to ten pounds. O'Connell went on to campaign against slavery in the British Empire and the United States, and later for repeal of the Union with huge outdoor meetings in 1843, but he called off a final meeting at Clontarf when the government banned it, rather than risk bloodshed.
Worked example: two roads to change
Set 1798 beside 1829. Both sought rights for Irish Catholics. The United Irishmen chose secret organization, armed revolt and foreign help; O'Connell chose open organization, small regular contributions, elections and the threat of ungovernability without violence. The first ended in defeat, sectarian killing and the loss of the Irish parliament. The second won its central demand within six years. The comparison does not prove that peaceful methods always work: O'Connell's success depended on a parliament that could be pressured, and his later repeal campaign failed. But it shows how much the choice of method shapes not only whether a movement wins, but what kind of society it leaves behind.
