Skip to main content

In 1641 Catholics owned about three fifths of the land of Ireland. By 1703 they owned about a seventh. No other change in early modern Ireland mattered more for the next two centuries, because land meant wealth, votes, office and the power to shape a community's life. This level follows how that transfer happened and how a legal order was built to keep it in place.

Confederates and Cromwell

After 1641 Catholic Ireland organized itself. Gaelic Irish and Old English Catholics, the descendants of the medieval settlers, joined in the Confederation of Kilkenny, which from 1642 ran much of the country with its own assembly and armies while professing loyalty to King Charles I. While it argued, England's civil war ended with the king's execution in January 1649.

That August Oliver Cromwell landed near Dublin with a veteran army. In September he stormed Drogheda, whose garrison had refused to surrender, and his troops killed most of the defenders along with priests and an unknown number of civilians. Cromwell wrote to Parliament that he was persuaded "that this is a righteous judgment of God upon these barbarous wretches, who have imbrued their hands in so much innocent blood". He presented the killings as God's judgment for the massacres of 1641, though Drogheda's defenders had nothing to do with Ulster in 1641, and many were English royalists. Wexford suffered a similar sack in October.

The Cromwellian settlement

The Act for the Settlement of Ireland in 1652 treated most Catholic landowners as guilty. Those not executed or exiled were ordered to move to Connacht and County Clare, west of the Shannon, where they received smaller grants of poorer land. Their estates went to Parliament's soldiers in place of back pay and to investors who had lent money for the war. War, plague and famine between 1641 and 1653 killed a very large share of the population; estimates vary widely, and any precise figure should be treated with caution.

Derry, the Boyne and Limerick

Catholic hopes revived when Charles's Catholic brother became King James II in 1685. When James was overthrown in England in 1688 and replaced by his Protestant daughter Mary and her Dutch husband William of Orange, Ireland became a battleground. In December 1688 thirteen apprentice boys shut the gates of Derry against a Jacobite regiment, and in 1689 the city endured a siege of 105 days before relief ships broke through. On 1 July 1690 by the calendar then in use, William III defeated James II at the Boyne, and James fled to France. The war ended after the bloody Jacobite defeat at Aughrim in 1691.

The Treaty of Limerick, signed in October 1691, had two parts. Its military terms allowed Irish soldiers to leave and serve in France, and around fourteen thousand sailed, remembered as the Wild Geese. Its civil terms promised Catholics the religious privileges they had enjoyed under Charles II. Those promises would soon be hollowed out.

The Penal Laws

From 1695 the all-Protestant Irish parliament passed a series of measures known as the Penal Laws. Catholics were barred from parliament, the legal profession, the army and, from 1728, from voting. Bishops were banished in 1697. Under an act of 1704, Catholics could not buy land or take long leases, and a Catholic's estate had to be divided among all his sons unless the eldest converted, in which case he took everything. Presbyterians, too, were shut out of public office by a religious test from 1704.

Historians debate the laws' aim. Most now see them as protecting Protestant property and power more than forcing conversions. Enforcement was uneven: priests went on saying Mass, sometimes in the open air at sites later remembered as Mass rocks, and informal hedge schools taught children. But the laws did their main work. By 1703 Catholics owned about one seventh of the land, and the share kept falling. A small Anglican landed class, later called the Protestant Ascendancy, held the land, the parliament and the professions.

Protestant patriots

That Ascendancy did not see itself as English. A Declaratory Act of 1720 asserted that the British parliament could make laws for Ireland. During the American war, armed Protestant Volunteer companies formed to defend the island and then pressed for reform. Led in parliament by Henry Grattan, they won a settlement in 1782 that gave the Irish parliament the right to make its own laws. Yet it remained an assembly of Protestant landowners, and the executive was still appointed from London.

Worked example: a promise and its erosion

Compare two documents. The first is the civil article of the Treaty of Limerick promising Catholics such religious privileges as they had under Charles II. The second is the 1704 act forbidding Catholics to buy land. A historian sets them side by side and asks what happened in between. The answer is that the Irish parliament, which had not negotiated the treaty, delayed ratifying it until 1697 and then confirmed a narrowed version. Meanwhile it passed laws the treaty's makers had not foreseen. The lesson is general: a promise made by negotiators is only as strong as the body that must enforce it, and minorities whose rights rest on the goodwill of a majority's parliament hold them on fragile terms.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Cromwell describe the killings at Drogheda?
2. Under the 1652 settlement, where were Catholic landowners ordered to move?
3. How did the siege of Derry begin in 1688?
4. What happened at the Boyne in 1690?
5. What did the military terms of the Treaty of Limerick allow?
6. What did the 1704 act forbid Catholics to do?
7. What did the 1782 settlement win for the Irish parliament?
8. About what share of Irish land did Catholics own by 1703?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia