Skip to main content

In 1500 the English crown's real authority in Ireland reached about a day's ride from Dublin. By 1610 English law ran across the whole island, Gaelic lordship had collapsed, and settlers from Britain were laying out new towns in the far north. The century between saw the most decisive conquest in Irish history, and it was carried out less by one great battle than by law, land titles, war, famine and the redistribution of property.

From lordship to kingdom

For decades the crown ruled through the Fitzgerald earls of Kildare, who served as lords deputy and kept order with their own armies and alliances. An earlier act, Poynings' Law of 1494, required that laws for the Irish parliament be approved in advance by the king and his council in England, which kept that parliament on a short leash. In 1534 the young heir of Kildare, known as Silken Thomas, rose in rebellion after rumors that his father had been executed in London. The revolt was crushed, Thomas and five of his uncles were executed, and Henry VIII's government resolved to rule Ireland directly.

Henry had broken with Rome, and his reforms crossed to Ireland: monasteries were dissolved and their lands sold or granted. Then, in 1541, the Irish parliament declared Henry VIII King of Ireland, replacing the old lordship with a kingdom. Every inhabitant was now in theory a subject of the crown under English law. To make that real, the government offered Gaelic lords a deal known as surrender and regrant: a lord surrendered his lands to the crown and received them back as an English style title. The policy was meant to be peaceful, but it clashed with Gaelic custom, in which lordship passed to a chosen member of the kin group rather than to the eldest son, and it fueled succession disputes.

Plantation and war

Alongside persuasion came force and settlement. In the 1550s the crown confiscated lands in the midlands and created King's County and Queen's County, planted with English tenants. After the Desmond rebellions in Munster were crushed in the early 1580s, large confiscated estates were granted to English settlers, among them the poet Edmund Spenser.

The greatest challenge came from Ulster, the most Gaelic province, where Hugh O'Neill, earl of Tyrone, and Red Hugh O'Donnell fought the Nine Years' War from 1593, winning a major victory at the Yellow Ford in 1598. Spain, England's enemy, sent troops, but they landed at Kinsale on the south coast, far from O'Neill's base. When O'Neill marched south to join them, his army was routed in December 1601. Defeat at Kinsale broke the Gaelic alliance with Spain, and O'Neill submitted in 1603.

Life under new officials soon grew intolerable. In September 1607 O'Neill, Rory O'Donnell and about ninety followers sailed into exile on the continent, an event remembered as the Flight of the Earls. They never returned.

The Plantation of Ulster

The crown treated the earls' departure as treason and confiscated six counties. From 1609 the Plantation of Ulster granted the land in blocks to undertakers, who were required to bring in English and Scottish Protestant tenants, to servitors who had served the crown, and to a limited number of loyal Irish. The City of London's companies were given the county renamed Londonderry. In Antrim and Down, outside the official scheme, Scottish landowners brought over large numbers of Lowland Scots, mostly Presbyterians.

The plan called for the native Irish to be moved off the undertakers' lands, but it was never fully carried out, because the new landlords needed Irish tenants and laborers and settlers came in smaller numbers than hoped. The result was a patchwork in which settler and native lived close together, with the settlers holding the better land and the law on their side. That pattern of neighbors divided by religion, land and memory still shapes Ulster.

The rising of 1641

In October 1641, with England sliding toward civil war, Irish Catholic gentry in Ulster led by Sir Phelim O'Neill rose to recover land and protect their religion. The rising quickly turned to attacks on settlers. Many were stripped and driven from their homes in winter, and many were killed. Modern historians estimate that roughly four thousand were killed outright and perhaps several thousand more died of cold, hunger and disease, though exact figures are uncertain. Protestant pamphlets in England claimed over a hundred thousand dead, and those inflated numbers would justify terrible reprisals.

Worked example: weighing the 1641 Depositions

The main evidence for the rising is the 1641 Depositions, sworn statements by Protestant survivors, now kept at Trinity College Dublin. How should a historian use them? First, note the purpose: many were taken to record property losses, so witnesses had reasons to list everything they had lost. Second, separate what a witness saw from what a witness heard. A deponent who describes her own eviction is a strong source; one who reports a massacre in another county on the word of a neighbor is much weaker. Third, look for patterns across many statements, which are more reliable than any single dramatic story.

Read this way, the depositions confirm real atrocities, including the drowning of settlers at Portadown, while also showing that the wildest numbers were rumor.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Poynings' Law of 1494 require?
2. What did the Irish parliament declare in 1541?
3. What was surrender and regrant?
4. What was the result of the defeat at Kinsale in 1601?
5. What was the Flight of the Earls in 1607?
6. Who was given the county renamed Londonderry?
7. What are the 1641 Depositions?
8. Why did many native Irish remain on planted land in Ulster?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia