In 1532 Tawantinsuyu was at its greatest extent, and it was tearing itself apart. Within a few years its ruler was dead, its capital was in foreign hands and its armies were fighting one another and a small band of invaders. The speed of the collapse has fed myths for five hundred years. Recent historians have tried to replace those myths with a fuller and more Andean story.
A death in the north
The trouble began with a disease that traveled faster than the Spaniards. Huayna Capac most likely died in an epidemic that outran the Spaniards, around 1528, while campaigning in what is now Ecuador. The illness is usually thought to have been smallpox, brought to the Americas by Europeans and spreading south along trade routes, though some scholars question the diagnosis. The heir Huayna Capac had chosen is said to have died in the same outbreak.
The succession was left open. Huáscar, a son based in Cusco, claimed the throne. Atahualpa, another son, held the loyalty of the veteran armies in the north. Their war lasted several years and was brutal. In 1532 Atahualpa's generals defeated and captured Huáscar, and their troops took terrible revenge on his supporters in Cusco. Atahualpa himself was resting at the highland town of Cajamarca, on his way south to claim his capital, when he received news of strange visitors.
Cajamarca
Francisco Pizarro had landed on the north coast with a small force and marched inland. About 168 Spaniards were with Pizarro at Cajamarca on 16 November 1532, when Atahualpa entered the town square carried in a litter, surrounded by thousands of attendants who were mostly unarmed. A friar approached and offered Atahualpa a book, calling on him to accept Christianity and the Spanish king. Atahualpa, by most accounts, examined it and let it fall. The Spaniards, hidden in buildings around the square, opened fire, charged on horseback and killed thousands of people in a few hours. Atahualpa was taken prisoner.
To win his freedom Atahualpa promised to fill a large room once with gold and twice with silver, and his subjects brought treasure from across the empire for months. The Spaniards took the ransom, melted most of it into bars and then put him on trial. Sentenced to burn, Atahualpa was garroted rather than burned because he accepted baptism, in July 1533. From prison he had already ordered Huáscar killed.
Why so few won
Older accounts credited the conquest to Spanish courage, steel and horses, or to Andean awe at bearded strangers taken for gods. Steel swords and armor, horses and the tactics of men hardened by war in Europe and the Caribbean did matter, especially in open battle. But historians now stress other causes. Many historians now stress disease, civil war and native allies as the forces that made the conquest possible. The epidemic had killed a ruler and perhaps a huge number of his subjects. The civil war had split the empire. And many Andean peoples saw the Spaniards as a way to escape Inca rule.
The Cañari, Chachapoya and Huanca peoples became important Spanish allies, providing soldiers, porters and food. The Huanca of the Jauja valley later petitioned the Spanish crown for repayment, presenting khipu records of the goods and labor they had supplied. To them, the war was a chance to throw off a conqueror, not the defense of a homeland.
Rebellion and Vilcabamba
The Spaniards entered Cusco in late 1533 and crowned a young son of Huayna Capac, Manco Inca, as a puppet ruler. Humiliated and abused, he escaped. In 1536 Manco Inca besieged Spanish-held Cusco for months with a huge army, burning much of the city. The Spaniards held out, helped by native allies, and recaptured the great fortress of Sacsayhuamán above the city in fierce fighting. Manco then withdrew to the forested region of Vilcabamba, northwest of Cusco, where he and his sons kept an independent Inca state for more than thirty years.
One of those sons, Titu Cusi Yupanqui, dictated an account of the conquest in 1570 to a Spanish friar, telling it from his father's side as a story of broken promises. His brother succeeded him. Túpac Amaru, the last ruler of Vilcabamba, was executed in Cusco in 1572 on the orders of the viceroy Francisco de Toledo, after Spanish forces captured him in the forest. With him ended the line of independent Inca rulers.
Worked example: one afternoon, two stories
Set two accounts of Cajamarca side by side. Pizarro's secretary, writing soon afterward for readers in Spain, tells of a pagan king who scorned the holy book, and of a small band of Christians saved by God against impossible odds. Titu Cusi, nearly forty years later, tells of strangers welcomed with hospitality who answered it with treachery and greed. Both accounts agree on the basic events: the square, the book, the massacre, the capture. They differ on what those events meant. Neither is neutral. The Spanish version justified the conquest to a king and a church; the Andean version justified resistance and asked for respect. Reading them together, a historian can see not only what happened but how each side needed the story to be told.
