A war that lasted more than a century left marks that outlived everyone who fought in it. Some were institutions, some were languages and loyalties, and some were stories that later generations told for their own purposes.
Two different states
In France, the war left a stronger monarchy with permanent taxes and a standing army. Charles VII and his successors collected the taille regularly, kept paid troops ready, and relied less and less on the Estates-General, which met rarely in the centuries that followed. The crown that had nearly collapsed in 1420 emerged as one of the most powerful in Europe.
England took a different path. Because English kings had to ask Parliament for war taxes again and again, the Commons gained a lasting role in granting money and voicing grievances. Defeat, though, brought crisis. Soldiers and settlers came home from Normandy angry; ministers were blamed; in 1450 the Duke of Suffolk was murdered and Jack Cade's rebels occupied London. In August 1453, weeks after Castillon, Henry VI suffered a mental collapse. Within two years rival noble factions were fighting the Wars of the Roses. Defeat in France helped bring on the Wars of the Roses, a generation of civil war over the English crown.
Languages and loyalties
When the war began, the English nobility still spoke French and the law courts used it. That changed. The Statute of Pleading of 1362 required pleading in the law courts to be in English, though written records stayed in Latin. Henry V, despite conquering France, wrote many of his letters in English, and the royal government's clerks helped spread a more standard written English.
In France, war against the English helped people in different provinces imagine a common enemy and a common king. Joan of Arc spoke of the kingdom of France as a cause God himself wanted restored to its rightful king. Historians are careful here: most people's first loyalties remained to their lord, town and region, and many French nobles had served the English king. Even so, the long war did much to make "English" and "French" feel like opposed identities.
Rules for war
The war also prompted thinking about how wars should be fought. Around 1387 Honoré Bovet, a French monk, wrote a treatise called the Tree of Battles. He argued that peasants and others who did not fight should be left in peace, since they worked the land for everyone and had no part in the quarrels of kings. Around 1410 Christine de Pizan, an Italian-born writer at the French court, drew on Bovet in her own book on the deeds of arms and chivalry, written in French rather than Latin.
In practice, chivalric codes mainly protected noble captives who could pay ransoms. A knight who surrendered might be fed, housed and released for money. Common soldiers and peasants had no such value and were often killed. Still, the idea that noncombatants deserve protection, voiced by writers who saw the chevauchée up close, is one root of the later laws of war, which rest on the belief that a human being's worth does not depend on their usefulness to an army.
Stories and memory
The war produced great chroniclers, above all Jean Froissart, who wrote vividly of knightly deeds and paid much less attention to burned villages. Christine de Pizan wrote a poem celebrating Joan of Arc in 1429, while Joan was still alive and fighting; it is one of the very few works about her written in her lifetime. More than a century later, Shakespeare's history plays fixed a heroic picture of Henry V in English memory.
Even the name is a later invention. The phrase "Hundred Years' War" was coined by historians in the nineteenth century, first in France, as they tried to organize a long, messy period into a single national story.
Joan herself became a symbol for almost everyone. Monarchists, republicans, Catholics and anticlericals all claimed her in nineteenth century France. In the Second World War both the Vichy regime and the Resistance used her image, each presenting her as their own.
Worked example: one battle, three tellings
Take Agincourt and see how its meaning changes with the teller.
In Shakespeare's Henry V, first performed around 1599, the king rallies his men on Saint Crispin's Day, calling them "We few, we happy few, we band of brothers." The battle becomes a story of English unity across social ranks, with the king as one of his men. The play was written as England faced Spanish threats and war in Ireland, when such a message was useful.
French chroniclers of the fifteenth century told it differently. For them, Agincourt was a judgment on the pride and quarrels of the French nobility, who had rushed to claim the front line and ignored good advice. It was a moral lesson about division at home.
Modern historians, working from pay rolls, muster lists and studies of the terrain, ask other questions: how many men were really there, how much they ate, how deep the mud was. Their Agincourt is a story of logistics, weather and chance.
None of these tellings is simply false. Each answers the needs of its own time. A careful reader of history asks of any account: who is telling this, for whom, and what does the story leave out? For this war, the answer is often the villagers whose fields the armies crossed, the people who left the fewest records and paid the highest price.
