Joseph II once disguised himself as a simple count to travel through his own lands, and he opened Vienna's royal hunting park, the Prater, to the public with a sign said to welcome everyone. He worked at his desk for hours on end and issued thousands of decrees. He also left a monarchy close to revolt. His reign is a lesson in what happens when a ruler is sure he knows what his subjects need better than they do.
Reform in a hurry
Joseph became sole ruler after his mother died in 1780. He believed the state existed to serve the common good and that every institution must justify itself by its usefulness. Within months he issued a stream of laws. Besides granting toleration to Protestants and Orthodox Christians, his Serfdom Patent of 1781 abolished personal serfdom in Bohemia and soon in other lands. Peasants could now marry, move and learn a trade without their lord's permission, though they still owed labor dues.
The church felt his hand most heavily. Joseph considered monks who only prayed to be useless. He dissolved contemplative orders and used their wealth to fund parishes, schools and hospitals. Around 700 monasteries and convents were closed. Bishops had to accept state control over seminaries, and even the number of candles on altars was regulated. The pope traveled to Vienna in 1782 to plead with him, with little result.
One language, one law
Joseph wanted his lands to work as a single state, with uniform rules from the Netherlands to Transylvania. In 1784 he made German the language of administration across the monarchy, including Hungary, where Latin had long served that purpose. He meant it as a practical step. Many Hungarian nobles saw it as an attack on their nation and their privileges.
He also refused the oath that bound Hungary's kings to respect the kingdom's laws. Joseph was never crowned king of Hungary, so his critics called him "the king in a hat". He had the Holy Crown of Saint Stephen taken to Vienna and stored as a museum piece. New tax and land surveys threatened noble exemptions. When war with the Ottomans went badly after 1788, Hungary edged toward open revolt, and the Austrian Netherlands rose in rebellion in 1789.
His law codes reflected Enlightenment ideas. Joseph's penal code of 1787 abolished the death penalty in ordinary courts, though it replaced execution with harsh punishments such as hauling barges on the Danube in chains. Dying in early 1790, Joseph withdrew most of his reforms for Hungary, keeping only toleration and the serf reforms. The Holy Crown returned to Buda to cheering crowds.
Revolution and the end of an empire
His brother Leopold II, who had reformed Tuscany for 25 years, calmed the provinces by bargaining with the estates. He died in 1792, and his son Francis faced the French Revolution. France declared war that spring and, under Napoleon, defeated Austria repeatedly. When Napoleon declared himself emperor of the French, Francis responded in 1804 by proclaiming a hereditary Austrian Empire. Two years later, with much of Germany organized under French protection, Francis dissolved the Holy Roman Empire in August 1806, ending an institution about a thousand years old.
Defeat forced bitter compromises. In 1810 Francis gave his daughter Marie Louise in marriage to Napoleon, the man who had twice occupied Vienna. Yet the Habsburgs survived and joined the coalition that defeated Napoleon. After 1815 Francis and his minister Metternich built a system of censorship and police surveillance designed to stop revolution at home and abroad. The reforming spirit of Joseph had turned into fear of change.
Worked example: the reusable coffin
Few of Joseph's measures show his method more clearly than a burial decree of 1784. Vienna's churchyards were crowded and, in the view of the authorities, unhealthy, so new cemeteries were opened outside the city walls. Joseph went further. To save wood and money, the decree ordered that bodies be sewn into linen sacks, carried to the grave in a reusable coffin with a hinged bottom, and dropped into the pit, then covered with lime.
From the government's point of view, the logic was sound. Funerals were expensive, poor families went into debt for them, and the forests were being cut down. But Viennese families saw the decree as an insult to their dead. Burial customs carried religious meaning, family honor and grief, and the state had brushed all of that aside as mere waste. Protests were so strong that Joseph withdrew the rule within months, writing with irritation that people could bury their dead however they liked.
The coffin decree shows the strengths and limits of enlightened absolutism. Joseph thought in terms of efficiency, public health and the welfare of the poor, which are serious goals. Yet he made no effort to persuade those affected or to ask what mattered to them. The same pattern, sensible aims imposed without consent, appeared in his language law and his church reforms. A reform that ignores the dignity people attach to their own customs can fail even when its reasons are good.
