In April 1848 a Czech historian received an invitation to help prepare a parliament for all of Germany at Frankfurt. Many Germans assumed that Bohemia, long part of the Holy Roman Empire, would join a new German nation. František Palacký wrote back that he was a Czech of Slavic descent and could not take part. His letter became one of the founding statements of a question that would shape the Habsburg monarchy until its end: could one state hold many nations, and on what terms?
The national awakening
After 1815 Metternich's police tried to keep politics out of public life. But scholars, poets and teachers were building national cultures that would soon become political. Czech, Slovak, Croatian, Slovene, Ukrainian, Romanian and Hungarian writers compiled dictionaries, collected folk songs and wrote histories. Hungary's nobles began to replace Latin with Hungarian in their diet. None of this was yet a demand for independence, but it created communities of readers who saw themselves as nations.
Palacký's letter gave one answer to the problem. Palacký argued that Austria was needed to shield the small nations of Central Europe from absorption by Germany or Russia, provided it treated them equally. That idea, called Austro-Slavism, hoped for a federal monarchy rather than its breakup.
The revolutions of 1848
Revolution reached Vienna in March 1848. The government granted press freedom and promised a constitution, and an elected parliament met that summer. When fighting forced it out of Vienna, it moved to the Moravian town of Kremsier. There the Kremsier parliament drafted a constitution that balanced the nations, but the government dissolved it in March 1849. Its draft remained a lost alternative for later reformers.
Hungary went furthest. Its diet passed the April Laws, creating a government responsible to its own parliament. Croats, Serbs and Romanians inside Hungary, fearing Hungarian domination, often sided with Vienna, and the Croatian governor Josip Jelačić invaded Hungary in the emperor's name. War followed, and in April 1849 Hungary declared independence. Vienna could not win alone. A Russian army helped crush the Hungarian revolution in 1849. Reprisals followed, and on 6 October 1849 thirteen Hungarian generals were executed at Arad, a date Hungary still marks as a day of mourning.
A young emperor and a string of defeats
In December 1848 the feeble Emperor Ferdinand abdicated in favor of his nephew. Franz Joseph was eighteen years old when he took the throne, and he would reign for nearly 68 years. At first he ruled without any constitution, through a centralized system run by his interior minister Alexander Bach. Then came defeats abroad. France and Piedmont took Lombardy from Austria in 1859. In 1866 Prussia beat the Austrian army at Königgrätz in Bohemia, which ended Austria's role in German affairs. Venetia went to the new kingdom of Italy.
The Dual Monarchy
Weakened, Franz Joseph made a deal with the Hungarian moderates led by Ferenc Deák. The Compromise of 1867 created two states sharing one monarch, a common foreign policy, a common army and the finances to pay for them. Everything else, from schools to courts to most taxes, each half ran for itself. Franz Joseph was crowned king of Hungary in Buda that June. The empire was now Austria-Hungary.
The Austrian half gained a constitution in December 1867. Its Article 19 declared all nationalities equal, with a right to preserve their language in schools, offices and public life. In practice the Germans dominated Austria and the Hungarians dominated Hungary, and the Slavs and Romanians, who made up about half the population, gained no equal partnership. Critics called the deal a bargain between the two strongest nations at the expense of the rest; defenders said it was the only arrangement that could keep the monarchy together.
Worked example: running an empire with two parliaments
How could two states with separate parliaments pay for one army and one foreign ministry? The Compromise answered with a set of unusual institutions. Each parliament chose a delegation of sixty members. The two delegations met at the same time, alternating between Vienna and Budapest, but in separate rooms. They exchanged written messages and voted on the common budget, and only if they disagreed three times did they meet together, voting without debate.
The costs were divided by a quota. At first Austria paid about 70 percent and Hungary about 30 percent, reflecting their wealth. A customs union and a shared currency bound the economies together. But the economic terms, including the quota, had to be renegotiated every ten years. Each renewal became a crisis, as Hungarian politicians demanded more autonomy and Austrian ones complained about paying too much.
Consider what this structure did to decision making. On foreign policy and war, the common ministers answered mainly to the monarch, not to either parliament. On almost everything else, two governments had to agree, and a third group of nations had no seat at the table. The system gave the monarchy a further half century, but it also locked in its rivalries. When historians ask why Austria-Hungary found reform so hard, they often begin with these ten-year bargains.
