Skip to main content

A question of which half

By 1494 Spain and Portugal had agreed to split the newly found world along a line running north to south through the Atlantic. The line had a hidden problem. On a globe, a line through the Atlantic continues over the poles and down the other side, and no one could measure longitude well enough to know where that other half of the line fell. The prize at stake was the Moluccas, the small islands in eastern Indonesia that were the world's only source of cloves. Portugal had reached them from the west. Magellan proposed to reach the Moluccas by sailing west and to show that they lay in Spain's half of the world.

The man and the fleet

Fernão de Magalhães, known in English as Ferdinand Magellan, was a Portuguese nobleman who had fought in India and Melaka. After a quarrel with King Manuel I, who refused him a raise in his pension and a new command, he offered his services to Spain. The young King Charles I, soon to be the emperor Charles V, backed him in 1518. Magellan's fleet of five ships and roughly 240 to 270 men left Spain in September 1519.

The voyage went badly almost from the start. The Spanish captains distrusted their Portuguese commander. While the fleet wintered at San Julián, in what is now Argentina, three of the ships rose in mutiny in 1520, and Magellan crushed it, executing one captain and marooning another. One ship was wrecked scouting the coast.

The strait and the great ocean

In late 1520 the fleet found a passage through the tip of South America, now called the Strait of Magellan. It took more than a month to thread the maze of channels. During the passage, the crew of the San Antonio deserted and sailed back to Spain, taking much of the fleet's food with them.

The three remaining ships came out into an ocean so calm that Magellan named it the Pacific, the peaceful sea. It was also far larger than anyone in Europe imagined. The crossing took over three months without fresh food. An Italian who sailed with the fleet, Antonio Pigafetta, kept a journal that is the main source for the voyage. He described men eating biscuit crawling with worms, sawdust and leather soaked in seawater, and many dying of scurvy, the disease caused by a lack of vitamin C.

Death in the Philippines

In March 1521 the fleet reached the islands later named the Philippines. On Cebu, Magellan made an alliance with a local ruler who accepted baptism, then joined in a quarrel with a rival on the neighboring island of Mactan. In April 1521 Magellan led a small force ashore there and was killed in the fighting. Soon afterward several officers were killed at a feast on Cebu. The survivors burned one ship they no longer had the men to sail.

The return

The two remaining ships reached the Moluccas and loaded cloves. One, the Trinidad, tried to return east across the Pacific and was captured by the Portuguese. The other, the Victoria, under the Basque navigator Juan Sebastián Elcano, sailed home west across the Indian Ocean and around Africa, avoiding Portuguese ports where it could. In September 1522 the Victoria limped into Spain with about eighteen of the original crew aboard. The cloves in its hold more than paid for the expedition.

The prize itself slipped away. In the Treaty of Zaragoza in 1529, Spain gave up its claim to the Moluccas in return for a large payment from Portugal. Spain later turned instead to the Philippines, and in 1565 the navigator Andrés de Urdaneta found a way back east across the northern Pacific, opening a regular link between Asia and Mexico.

Worked example: the missing day

When the Victoria stopped at the Cape Verde Islands in July 1522, the crew sent men ashore for supplies. Pigafetta recorded a puzzle. By the ship's careful log it was Wednesday. The people on shore insisted it was Thursday.

No one had miscounted. Sailing west around the world, the crew had followed the sun and so experienced one fewer sunrise than people who stayed home. Every day at sea was slightly longer than twenty-four hours, as the ship moved with the sun's westward path, and over three years those small extra amounts added up to a whole day.

The reasoning works in reverse too. A traveler going east around the world meets each sunrise a little early and gains a day. That is why the modern world needs an International Date Line, a line in the Pacific where travelers adjust the calendar by one day. Magellan's crew were the first people known to have run into the problem in practice, and Pigafetta's surprise is a small, vivid proof that the earth turns and that a voyage around it had truly been made.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Magellan hope to show about the Moluccas?
2. How large was Magellan's fleet when it left Spain in 1519?
3. What happened at San Julián in 1520?
4. What did the crew of the San Antonio do?
5. Who brought the Victoria home in 1522?
6. About how many of the original crew returned on the Victoria?
7. What did the Treaty of Zaragoza settle in 1529?
8. Why did the Victoria's log run one day behind the calendar on land?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia