Skip to main content

James II became king in February 1685, aged fifty one, with surprisingly little opposition. Within months his nephew, the Duke of Monmouth, an illegitimate son of Charles II and a Protestant hero to many, landed in the West Country to claim the throne. His rebellion of farmers and artisans was crushed at Sedgemoor in July, and Monmouth was beheaded. In the trials that followed, known as the Bloody Assizes, Judge George Jeffreys sentenced hundreds of rebels to hanging or transportation to the colonies.

A Catholic king and a Protestant nation

James wanted freedom of worship and public office for his fellow Catholics, who made up perhaps one or two in a hundred of the English population. When Parliament refused to repeal the Test Act, he used his claimed power to dispense with laws in particular cases, appointing Catholic officers in an enlarged army and Catholic heads of Oxford colleges. In 1687 he issued a Declaration of Indulgence that suspended the penal laws against Catholics and Protestant Dissenters. Many more English people saw it as a king claiming to set aside acts of Parliament by his own will, the same issue that had divided the nation in 1640.

In 1688 James reissued the Declaration and ordered it read in every church. Seven bishops, led by the Archbishop of Canterbury, William Sancroft, petitioned against the order and were tried for seditious libel. On 30 June 1688 a jury acquitted the Seven Bishops, and crowds in London lit bonfires. A few weeks earlier the queen had given birth to a son. Until then James's heirs were his Protestant daughters, Mary and Anne, and many had been willing to wait. Now a Catholic dynasty seemed likely, and rumors spread that the baby had been smuggled into the queen's bed in a warming pan.

Invasion and flight

On the night of the acquittal seven leading men, Whigs and Tories together, wrote to William of Orange, Mary's husband and the leader of the Dutch Republic, inviting him to come with an army. William landed at Torbay in Devon on 5 November 1688. James's army began to melt away as officers, including John Churchill, the future Duke of Marlborough, went over to William. In December James tried to flee. He is said to have dropped the Great Seal into the Thames. He was caught, then allowed to escape, and reached France.

A Convention met in January 1689. They settled on a formula: James had broken the original contract between king and people, had abdicated the government, and the throne was therefore vacant. In February the Convention offered the crown jointly to William and Mary, after reading them a Declaration of Right, later enacted as the Bill of Rights.

Glorious for whom?

Protestant England remembered 1688 as a bloodless revolution. Beyond England it was not bloodless: Scotland faced a Jacobite rising and Ireland a full war. In Scotland a Convention issued its own Claim of Right and abolished bishops in the Kirk, while the Jacobites, named after the Latin for James, took up arms for the exiled king. In Ireland the war ended in 1691 with a settlement that left Catholics excluded from power. The Toleration Act of 1689 gave freedom of worship to Protestant Dissenters who took certain oaths, but not to Catholics or to those who denied the Trinity, and Dissenters still could not hold office legally.

How historians have read the century

Nineteenth century writers such as Thomas Babington Macaulay told the story as the steady growth of English liberty. In 1931 Herbert Butterfield criticized this Whig interpretation for judging the past by whether it led to the present. Marxist historians, led by Christopher Hill, saw a revolution in which a rising class of gentry and merchants broke feudal limits, and Hill drew attention to the radicals from below. From the 1970s revisionists such as Conrad Russell and John Morrill argued that the war had no long term inevitability. Russell stressed the problem of ruling three kingdoms with an empty treasury; Morrill argued that the conflict was driven above all by religion, more akin to Europe's wars of religion than to later revolutions. More recently Steve Pincus has argued that 1688 itself was a genuine and violent revolution, a contest between rival plans for a modern state.

Worked example: reading the Bill of Rights

Much of the Bill of Rights of 1689 is a list of James's misdeeds. It declared that the pretended power of suspending laws without the consent of Parliament is illegal, which answered James's Indulgence. Levying money without Parliament's grant was illegal, which answered Ship Money. Keeping a standing army in peacetime without Parliament's consent was illegal, which answered the Major Generals. Elections were to be free, speech in Parliament could not be questioned in any court, and cruel and unusual punishments were banned. Protestants could have arms for their defense as allowed by law, and no Catholic could wear the crown.

Now notice its limits. It was a settlement among propertied Protestants, not a declaration of universal rights. It said nothing about the vote, which the Putney agitators had demanded. It entrenched exclusion by religion. Yet its central idea, that power must answer to law made by an elected assembly, was precisely what Hampden had argued over twenty shillings, and it became a model for others, including the framers of the American Bill of Rights a century later.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What were the Bloody Assizes of 1685?
2. What did James II's Declaration of Indulgence of 1687 do?
3. What was the outcome of the trial of the Seven Bishops in June 1688?
4. What is James II said to have thrown into the Thames as he fled?
5. How did the Convention of 1689 describe what James had done?
6. Who received freedom of worship under the Toleration Act of 1689?
7. What did Butterfield criticize in the Whig interpretation of history?
8. Why is the label bloodless misleading for the revolution of 1688?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia