Skip to main content

Visitors to the Dutch Republic were often astonished. In Amsterdam, Calvinists, Lutherans, Mennonites, Catholics and Jews lived side by side, and books banned elsewhere rolled off local presses. Yet Dutch toleration was a practical compromise, not a principle of equal rights, and it had firm limits.

Freedom of conscience, not of worship

The Union of Utrecht of 1579 laid the groundwork. Its thirteenth article stated that each person would remain free in religion and that no one would be persecuted or investigated for religion. This was freedom of conscience, the right to believe privately. It was not freedom of public worship.

Only one church held public status. The Dutch Reformed Church was the privileged public church: it used the old medieval church buildings, its ministers were paid from public funds, and in most places only its members could hold public office. Yet membership was voluntary, and many people never joined fully. The Republic had an established church without a fully confessional state.

Hidden churches

Catholics remained a large minority, perhaps a third of the population in the mid seventeenth century. Public Catholic services were banned, so Catholics often worshipped in hidden house churches built inside ordinary buildings. In Amsterdam a merchant's house on a canal still contains one in its attic, finished in the 1660s and now a museum. Authorities knew where these churches were. In many towns Catholic congregations paid recognition money to local officials to be left alone, an arrangement somewhere between tolerance and extortion.

Mennonites, Lutherans and Remonstrants also built churches that looked like houses or warehouses from the street. The rule was not that dissent must vanish but that it must not be loud.

Jews in Amsterdam

From the 1590s Portuguese Jews, many of them descendants of families forced to convert in Spain and Portugal, settled in Amsterdam and returned openly to Judaism. Later, poorer Ashkenazi Jews arrived from Germany and Poland. Amsterdam did not confine Jews to a ghetto or make them wear distinctive marks, though they were barred from most guilds and from public office. In 1675 the Portuguese community opened a great synagogue, one of the largest in Europe at the time.

Spinoza and the radicals

The limits of toleration show most clearly in the case of Baruch Spinoza, born in Amsterdam in 1632 to a Portuguese Jewish family. In 1656, for reasons the surviving record does not fully explain, Spinoza was excommunicated by his own Amsterdam Jewish congregation in unusually severe terms. He lived quietly afterward, grinding lenses and writing.

In 1670 he published the Theological-Political Treatise anonymously, with a false place of printing on the title page. It argued that the Bible should be read as a historical document and that a free state must allow freedom of thought and speech, because people cannot be made to think on command, and trying only breeds hypocrisy. Reformed synods condemned it, and the authorities of Holland banned it in 1674.

Others fared worse. The physician and lawyer Adriaan Koerbagh published a dictionary mocking religious doctrines in plain Dutch, for ordinary readers. He was sentenced to hard labor, and Koerbagh died in prison in 1669. Writing radical ideas in Latin for scholars was tolerated more readily than spreading them in the language of the street.

A refuge for writers

Still, the Republic was a haven. René Descartes lived there for about twenty years and published his Discourse on Method in Leiden in 1637. The French Protestant Pierre Bayle wrote in Rotterdam, and the Englishman John Locke drafted his letter on toleration while in exile in the Republic in the 1680s. Dutch printers produced books in many languages for buyers across Europe.

The same habits crossed the ocean. In 1657, when the director of New Netherland, Peter Stuyvesant, banned Quaker worship, residents of the village of Flushing on Long Island signed the Flushing Remonstrance, a protest against the ban on Quakers. They appealed to the law of love and the liberties of their homeland. Stuyvesant arrested several signers, but in 1663 the company directors in Amsterdam told him to allow quiet dissent.

Worked example: why tolerate?

Why did a Calvinist republic put up with dissent at all? Consider three motives.

The first was commercial. Amsterdam's merchants wanted trade with everyone, and expelling Catholics, Jews or Mennonites would have driven away customers, capital and skilled workers. The second was political. The revolt had been fought partly against religious persecution, and the provinces could not easily adopt the methods of Alba. The third was principled: thinkers from the humanist Dirck Coornhert to Spinoza argued that conscience cannot be forced and that persecution corrupts both persecutor and victim.

Now test the arrangement against a modern standard of equal rights. Catholics could believe but not hold office; Jews could worship but not join most guilds; radicals could think but not always publish. By that standard the Republic falls short. By the standard of its century, when religious war tore through much of Europe, it offered a rare and valuable space.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Article 13 of the Union of Utrecht promise?
2. Which church held a privileged public position in the Republic?
3. Where did Catholics in the Republic often worship?
4. What did many Catholic congregations pay to local officials?
5. Who excommunicated Spinoza in 1656?
6. What did Spinoza's Theological-Political Treatise argue?
7. What happened to Adriaan Koerbagh?
8. What was the Flushing Remonstrance of 1657?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia