The wealth of the Golden Age was not made only by thrifty merchants and clever bankers. Much of it came from overseas companies that used armed force, seized land, and bought, sold and worked enslaved people. Any honest account of the Republic must hold both stories together.
The VOC in Asia
The East India Company was a trading firm and a military power at once. It built a network of forts and trading posts from the Cape of Good Hope to Japan, with its headquarters on Java. Its aim was to control the supply of fine spices, such as nutmeg, cloves and mace, along with pepper, textiles and later tea and coffee. Where local rulers resisted, the company used violence; its conquest of the Banda Islands in 1621 destroyed most of their population.
The VOC also fought the Portuguese for their Asian possessions. It took Malacca in 1641 and, between 1638 and 1658, drove the Portuguese from the coasts of Ceylon, today's Sri Lanka, where it controlled the cinnamon trade. Not every venture succeeded. The company held a colony on Taiwan, centered on Fort Zeelandia, until the VOC lost Taiwan in 1662 to Zheng Chenggong, a Ming loyalist commander known in Europe as Koxinga, after a siege of nine months.
Slavery was woven into the Asian empire too. The VOC bought and transported enslaved people around the Indian Ocean, from India, Madagascar, the Indonesian islands and East Africa, to work in its towns, households and plantations.
The West India Company and the Atlantic
The West India Company, founded in 1621, began as a war machine against Spain and Portugal. Its greatest coup came in 1628, when Piet Heyn captured a Spanish silver fleet off Cuba, a haul that paid the shareholders a huge dividend and funded the army at home. The company also seized northeastern Brazil from Portugal in 1630, holding it until 1654. Under its governor Johan Maurits of Nassau, Dutch Brazil drew artists and naturalists who painted and described its people, plants and animals, but its wealth still came from sugar.
In North America the company founded New Netherland along the Hudson River, with New Amsterdam on Manhattan as its port. England seized the colony in 1664. At the peace of Breda in 1667, England kept it while the Dutch kept Suriname, which a Zeeland fleet had just captured. New Amsterdam became New York.
Dutch traders and the slave trade
Brazil's sugar mills ran on enslaved African labor, and the Dutch entered the Atlantic slave trade to supply them. In 1637 the company took Elmina, on the Gold Coast, from the Portuguese, and the castle became the hub of its West African trade. The Caribbean island of Curaçao, taken in 1634, served as a depot from which captives were resold to Spanish colonies.
Historians estimate that Dutch ships carried more than half a million enslaved Africans across the Atlantic, roughly one in twenty of all people transported. The share was smaller than that of Portugal or Britain, but for a time in the seventeenth century the Dutch were among the leading carriers.
Suriname
Suriname became the center of Dutch plantation slavery. Enslaved people grew sugar, coffee and cotton under conditions notorious even among contemporaries for their brutality. Punishments were public and savage, and recaptured runaways could be mutilated or killed. Many fled into the rainforest, forming maroon communities that fought the colony to a standstill; in the 1760s the colonial government signed treaties recognizing the freedom of some of them.
The Netherlands was slow to abolish. Slavery in Suriname and the Dutch Caribbean was abolished in 1863, decades after Britain. Even then, freedom was delayed: freed people had to work ten more years under state supervision. And compensation was paid, but the slaveholders received compensation, not the enslaved, at about 300 guilders per person in Suriname.
Worked example: cutting the chain
Every year on 1 July, people in Suriname and the Netherlands mark Keti Koti, a Sranan Tongo phrase meaning that the chain is cut. For a long time the holiday was little noticed in the Netherlands. Its growth shows how a society can come to see an old story differently.
Consider three ways of telling the Golden Age. In the first, it is a tale of enterprise and freedom: a small republic outtrading empires. In the second, it is a tale of exploitation: wealth extracted from Asia, Africa and the Americas. A third view, which most historians now take, holds both together. The same society that defended freedom of conscience at home bought and sold human beings abroad, and many of its citizens saw no contradiction.
In December 2022 the Dutch prime minister apologized on behalf of the state for its role in slavery, and on 1 July 2023 King Willem-Alexander apologized at the national commemoration. Supporters saw the apologies as overdue recognition of human dignity denied. Critics asked what should follow: education, memorials, or reparations. The debate itself is part of the Golden Age's legacy. A society that prides itself on tolerance must also ask whom its tolerance once excluded.
