The Depression tested whether democracies could protect their citizens in an emergency without giving up freedom. Some failed the test. Others, including the United States, Britain and Sweden, survived it, and in doing so they changed what citizens expected from their governments. Their answers differed, and each drew strong criticism at the time and since.
The New Deal begins
When Franklin Roosevelt took office on March 4, 1933, banks were closed or limiting withdrawals in most states. Two days later he declared a national bank holiday, closing every bank in the country. Congress quickly passed an Emergency Banking Act, and examiners reopened sound banks in stages. In the first of his radio "fireside chats," Roosevelt explained in plain terms why money would be safer in a reopened bank than under a mattress. When banks reopened, deposits flowed back in.
A burst of laws followed in the first hundred days. The Civilian Conservation Corps put young men to work in forests and parks. The Agricultural Adjustment Act paid farmers to grow less, to push prices up. The Tennessee Valley Authority, a public corporation, built dams to control floods and bring cheap electricity to one of the poorest regions of the country, where most farms had never had power. The National Industrial Recovery Act let industries set prices and wages through codes of fair competition. The Banking Act of 1933 created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which insured ordinary bank deposits, and separated commercial banking from investment banking. Bank runs, once routine, almost disappeared. Roosevelt also took the country off gold in 1933 and in 1934 raised the official price of gold from about 20.67 to 35 dollars an ounce, in effect devaluing the dollar.
The second wave
In 1935 the Supreme Court struck down the industrial codes, and the next year it struck down the first farm program. Roosevelt and Congress moved on to new measures. The Works Progress Administration employed millions on roads, schools and public art. The Wagner Act protected workers' right to join unions and bargain collectively. The Social Security Act of 1935 created old-age pensions and a system of unemployment insurance run with the states.
The new protections had limits. Social Security at first left out farm laborers and domestic servants, groups that included a large share of Black workers in the South. Historians debate whether this reflected deliberate pressure from Southern members of Congress or the practical difficulty of collecting taxes from such workers.
Recovery was real but incomplete. Output grew fast from 1933 to 1937, yet unemployment stayed high. In 1937, believing the worst was over, the government cut spending and the Federal Reserve tightened credit, and a sharp new recession in 1937 and 1938 sent unemployment back up.
Judging the New Deal
Supporters say the New Deal saved American democracy at a time when others were falling, restored faith in banks and built a lasting floor of security. Critics on the left say it did too little: spending was modest compared with the size of the collapse, and many of the poor were left out. Critics on the right argue that some programs slowed recovery. The economists Harold Cole and Lee Ohanian argued in 2004 that the industrial codes and union laws kept wages and prices too high, so firms hired fewer workers. Others question whether so much power should have flowed to Washington and to the president.
Britain and Sweden
Britain took a more cautious path. Its National Government cut spending and kept budgets close to balance, but after leaving gold it kept interest rates low from 1932, a policy known as "cheap money." Cheap mortgages helped fuel a housing boom in the south of England, and new industries such as cars and electrical goods grew around London and the Midlands. The old industrial regions of the north, Scotland and Wales stayed depressed.
Sweden offered a third model. The Social Democrats won power in 1932 under Per Albin Hansson, whose ideal of the folkhem, or "people's home," pictured society as a household where no one is a stepchild. In 1933 they made a deal with the Farmers' League: support for farm prices in exchange for backing public works and relief. Swedish economists of the Stockholm School argued for public spending in a slump, independently of Keynes. In 1938 unions and employers signed the Saltsjöbaden Agreement, setting rules for bargaining without state control.
Worked example: stopping a bank panic
Consider why the bank holiday worked. A bank run is driven by fear: each depositor withdraws because others might. Closing every bank at once stopped the race. While banks were shut, examiners sorted them into sound and unsound, and the government stood behind the ones it reopened. Roosevelt's radio talk told listeners that the reopened banks had been checked. People who believed others would leave their money in had no reason to rush. When banks opened on March 13, deposits exceeded withdrawals in many cities. Nothing about the banks' loans had changed in a week. What changed was confidence, backed by a credible promise. Deposit insurance later made that promise permanent.
