Skip to main content

Statistics of output and prices can hide what the Depression felt like. Behind each percentage were families who lost homes, skipped meals, moved across a continent or watched a lifetime of savings vanish when a bank closed. The human cost varied enormously by country, class, race and sex, and it left marks that lasted long after the economy recovered.

Joblessness on a vast scale

At the depth of the slump, about one in four American workers and roughly six million registered workers in Germany had no job. In Britain, unemployment among insured workers passed 20 percent in 1931 and 1932, and in old industrial towns of northern England, Scotland and Wales it was far higher. Many who kept their jobs had their hours or pay cut. There was little to fall back on. The United States had no national unemployment insurance before 1935, and in Britain the benefit was paid only after a household "means test" that counted the earnings and savings of everyone in the home, so a working son's wages could cut his father's relief. Families bitterly resented the inspectors who came to inspect their homes and possessions.

Hunger, shanties and protest

In American cities, people built shacks of scrap wood and tin on empty land. They called these settlements "Hoovervilles," mocking the president they blamed. Breadlines and soup kitchens, many run by churches and charities, stretched around city blocks. Private charity and local relief, which had been expected to handle hard times, ran out of money within a year or two.

The jobless also organized. Unemployed councils, many led by Communists, staged hunger marches in the United States and Britain. In March 1932 police and company guards fired on marchers outside the Ford plant in Dearborn, Michigan, killing several. In 1936 two hundred men walked about 300 miles from the shipbuilding town of Jarrow to London to petition for work, after the closure of its shipyard left most of the town unemployed. Their march won sympathy but few jobs.

Uprooted people

On the southern Great Plains, years of drought and dust storms in the mid 1930s added ecological disaster to economic collapse. Many farm families, called "Okies" whatever their home state, drove west to California in search of work picking crops, and found low wages and hostility.

Some people were pushed out of their country altogether. During the early 1930s local and federal authorities in the United States pressed people of Mexican descent to leave, through raids, threats and offers of train fare. Estimates of the number who left for Mexico range from about 400,000 to over a million, and many were American citizens, often children born in the United States. In 2005 California formally apologized for its part.

Unequal burdens

Hardship fell unevenly. Black workers in American cities were often the first fired, and relief offices in the South paid Black families less. Married women faced a campaign to give jobs to men: in the United States a 1932 federal law required that when both spouses worked for the government, one had to leave, and it was overwhelmingly wives who lost their posts. In Japan, a collapse of silk prices ruined farm families in the northeast, and during a famine in 1934 some poor families sold daughters into brothels or factory labor.

One surprising finding complicates the picture. Overall death rates in the United States fell during the worst years of the Depression, according to a 2009 study, even as suicides rose. Researchers suggest people drove less, drank less and suffered fewer industrial accidents, since factories ran fewer shifts. The finding does not mean the Depression was harmless; it shows how hard it can be to measure suffering with one number.

Worked example: one photograph

In March 1936 the photographer Dorothea Lange, working for a federal farm agency, stopped at a pea pickers' camp in Nipomo, California. The crop had frozen and there was no work. She took several pictures of a woman sitting with her children, one of whom rested on her shoulder. The image, later called Migrant Mother, became the best known picture of the Depression.

For decades the woman was nameless. In the 1970s she was identified as Florence Owens Thompson, a woman of Cherokee descent from Oklahoma who had supported her children through years of farm and mill work after her first husband died. She later said she had never been paid for the photograph and had felt exploited, though the picture had helped bring government food to the camp.

The photograph shows how the Depression was understood: it put a single human face on a disaster of millions. It also shows a lasting question about documenting suffering. Lange's work moved public opinion and helped win support for relief, yet the person at its center had little say in how her image was used. Respecting dignity means seeing people in hard times as the authors of their own stories, not only as symbols.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. At the depth of the slump, how many registered workers in Germany had no job?
2. What did Britain's household means test count?
3. What were Hoovervilles?
4. Why did men march from Jarrow to London in 1936?
5. How many people of Mexican descent left the United States for Mexico in the early 1930s?
6. Under the 1932 US federal law on married couples in government jobs, who mostly lost their posts?
7. What did a 2009 study find about US death rates in the worst Depression years?
8. Who took the Migrant Mother photograph, and for whom?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia