In September 1864, politicians from Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and Prince Edward Island met in Charlottetown to discuss uniting their three small colonies. A steamer arrived from the Province of Canada carrying eight uninvited guests, who asked to join the talks. The Canadians had come to propose something far larger, and over a week of speeches, dinners and, by several accounts, a good deal of champagne, the Maritimers were persuaded to listen.
Deadlock and pressure
The Province of Canada had stopped working. Its two halves, Canada West and Canada East, held equal seats, so neither could govern without allies from the other, and governments fell again and again. Canada West had grown larger, and its Reform leader George Brown demanded representation by population, which French Canadians feared would leave them outnumbered. The solution was unexpected. In 1864 the bitter rivals George Brown, John A. Macdonald and George-Étienne Cartier joined forces in the Great Coalition to seek a federal union, in which each community could run its own local affairs.
Outside pressures pushed the same way. The American Civil War had produced the largest army in North America, and some northern politicians spoke openly of taking British territory. In 1866 Irish American veterans calling themselves Fenians launched raids across the border. Britain, tired of paying for colonial defense, encouraged union. Businessmen wanted a railway linking the Maritimes to the St. Lawrence, and the United States had ended a free trade treaty, so the colonies needed markets in one another.
Designing a federation
The delegates met again at Quebec in October 1864 and drew up seventy-two resolutions, which became the basis of the British North America Act passed by the British Parliament. On 1 July 1867 the Dominion of Canada was born with four provinces: Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick.
Macdonald wanted a strong central government, having watched the American union break apart over states' rights. The act gave Ottawa the major powers, including trade, defense, criminal law and banking, and gave Parliament power to make laws for the "peace, order, and good government" of Canada in all matters not assigned to the provinces. The provinces received education, property and civil rights, hospitals and local works. That allowed Quebec to keep its civil law and Catholic schools. The House of Commons was elected by population, satisfying Brown, while the appointed Senate gave equal seats to three regions: Ontario, Quebec and the Maritimes, each with twenty-four. French and English could both be used in Parliament and federal courts and in the Quebec legislature.
The act also decided the future of people who were not at the table. Section 91(24) gave Ottawa authority over "Indians, and Lands reserved for the Indians." No Indigenous nation was consulted, yet that clause would govern their lives for generations.
Joining and refusing
Not everyone wanted in. Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland stayed out. In Nova Scotia, Premier Charles Tupper had steered the plan through the legislature without an election, and the popular Joseph Howe led a furious campaign against it. In the first federal election of 1867, anti-Confederation candidates won eighteen of Nova Scotia's nineteen seats. Howe went to London to seek repeal, was refused, and in 1869 accepted better financial terms and a seat in Macdonald's cabinet.
The new country grew quickly. In 1869 and 1870 it acquired Rupert's Land, the vast territory claimed by the Hudson's Bay Company, and Manitoba became a province in 1870. British Columbia joined in 1871 on generous terms. Canada promised British Columbia a railway to the Pacific within ten years. Prince Edward Island, deep in debt from building its own railway, joined in 1873.
Worked example: did Nova Scotians consent?
Was Nova Scotia's entry into Canada legitimate? Defenders of Confederation pointed out that the colony's elected legislature had voted to negotiate union, that the British Parliament had full legal authority to pass the act, and that representative government means legislators decide between elections. Tupper believed union was essential to the colony's security and prosperity, and that a long campaign would let fear and local interests defeat it.
Critics replied that no election had been fought on the question, and that when voters finally spoke, in 1867, they rejected Confederation almost unanimously. Howe called it a scheme imposed on a free people. Both sides had a point. The legal process was valid, but its democratic support was thin, and only negotiation, money and time turned acceptance into loyalty.
The case shows something unusual about Canada's founding. There was no revolution and no popular vote. Canada began as a bargain among politicians, approved by an imperial parliament. That made it peaceful, but it also left large questions open, about the place of Quebec, the rights of provinces, and the nations whose lands the new country now claimed. Those questions would shape the next century and a half.
