Skip to main content

Dayton left one conflict untouched. In Kosovo, where Serbia had stripped away autonomy in 1989, more than four in five people were Albanians who had been pushed out of state jobs, schools and the media. Their response at first was remarkable. In the 1990s Ibrahim Rugova led a nonviolent campaign that built parallel Albanian institutions in Kosovo, including schools held in private homes, an unofficial parliament and a health service. When Dayton ignored Kosovo, many Albanians concluded that peaceful resistance earned nothing.

War in Kosovo

A guerrilla force, the Kosovo Liberation Army, began attacking Serbian police and officials, and sometimes Albanians it called collaborators. In 1998 Serbian forces struck back with a brutal offensive that burned villages and drove hundreds of thousands from their homes. In January 1999 the bodies of about 45 Albanians were found at the village of Račak. After talks at Rambouillet in France failed, NATO began bombing Yugoslavia in March 1999 without authorization from the UN Security Council. Serbian forces then expelled more than 800,000 Albanians across the borders. In June Belgrade agreed to withdraw, and a Security Council resolution placed Kosovo under UN administration. As Albanians returned, many Serbs and Roma fled reprisals.

Milošević's rule did not survive long. After he refused to accept defeat in the presidential election of 2000, mass protests forced him out in October. In 2001 the new Serbian government handed him over for trial. Kosovo declared independence from Serbia in February 2008. Serbia rejects it, and in 2010 the International Court of Justice gave an advisory opinion that the declaration did not violate international law.

Justice in The Hague

The wars produced a new experiment in international law. The UN Security Council created the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in 1993, while the fighting was still raging. It was the first international war crimes court since those at Nuremberg and Tokyo after the Second World War. Over its life it indicted 161 people from every side and closed its doors at the end of 2017.

Its rulings changed the law. In a 2001 case about Foča, judges convicted Bosnian Serb soldiers of rape and enslavement as crimes against humanity. The tribunal ruled that the Srebrenica killings were genocide, because they were aimed at destroying part of a protected group, the Bosniaks of eastern Bosnia. Karadžić was arrested in Belgrade in 2008, after years in disguise as an alternative healer, and Mladić was arrested in 2011. Both were convicted of genocide and sentenced to life in prison. Milošević died in his cell in 2006 before the tribunal reached a verdict.

In a separate case brought by Bosnia, the International Court of Justice ruled in 2007 that Serbia had failed to prevent the Srebrenica genocide, while finding that Serbia itself had not committed it. Critics on all sides attacked the tribunal. Many Serbs saw it as biased, since most of those convicted were Serbs. Many Bosniaks and Croats were angered by acquittals of men they held responsible. Supporters reply that the tribunal established a detailed record, tested in court, that no one can easily erase. Denial of the Srebrenica genocide remains common in Serbia and the Republika Srpska, and a 2024 UN General Assembly resolution naming 11 July a day of remembrance passed only over strong objections.

Successor states

Counting Kosovo, seven countries now stand on Yugoslav soil. Slovenia joined the European Union in 2004 and Croatia joined in 2013. Montenegro left its union with Serbia after a referendum in 2006, and Macedonia, after a long dispute with Greece over its name, became North Macedonia in 2019. Bosnia remains divided by Dayton's lines, and Serbia and Kosovo have not normalized relations. Across the region many older people speak warmly of Tito's country, a feeling known as Yugonostalgia, while younger people often leave for jobs abroad, as their grandparents did as guest workers.

Worked example: explaining the breakup

Why did Yugoslavia fall apart so violently? Four explanations compete. The first, popular with some journalists and politicians in the early 1990s, held that ancient ethnic hatreds had simply been frozen by communism and thawed when it ended. Most historians reject this. The peoples of Yugoslavia had lived together for long periods, intermarried and fought on many sides, and the worst violence of the twentieth century was recent, not ancient.

A second explanation blames elites. Leaders such as Milošević and Tuđman, facing the end of communism, used nationalism and controlled media to keep power, deliberately creating fear. A third stresses economics: the debt crisis and inflation turned republics against each other and destroyed faith in the federal state. A fourth points to outside powers, whose early recognitions, arms embargo and delays shaped the wars.

A good answer combines them. Memories of the Second World War gave fear something to feed on. Economic collapse weakened the state. Leaders chose to exploit fear rather than calm it, and outside powers hesitated. The lesson is uncomfortable but hopeful: violence on this scale was not destiny. It was the result of choices, and different choices were possible.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Ibrahim Rugova lead in the 1990s?
2. How did NATO's bombing of Yugoslavia in March 1999 begin?
3. When did Kosovo declare independence from Serbia?
4. Who created the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in 1993?
5. How did the tribunal classify the Srebrenica killings?
6. What happened to Milošević at The Hague?
7. What did the International Court of Justice rule in 2007?
8. Which successor states joined the European Union, and when?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia