Skip to main content

Figures for troop levels and bomb tonnage can hide what the war was like for the people inside it. Millions of Vietnamese, Americans and others lived through it in very different ways, and each group's experience shaped how it understood the war afterward.

Villages in the crossfire

Most of the fighting took place in the South Vietnamese countryside, among the people both sides claimed to protect. Villagers faced demands from every direction. The guerrillas collected taxes, recruited sons and punished those suspected of working for Saigon, sometimes by assassination. Government and American forces searched homes, detained suspects and called in artillery and air strikes on villages thought to shelter the enemy. Large areas were declared free fire zones, where anyone moving could be treated as hostile. Millions of South Vietnamese were driven from their homes and became refugees, many crowding into slums around the cities.

Weapons from the air

The United States dropped more than twice the tonnage of bombs on Indochina that it had dropped in the Second World War. From 1962 to 1971 American aircraft sprayed herbicides such as Agent Orange over South Vietnam to strip the jungle cover that hid enemy movements and to destroy crops. Agent Orange was contaminated with dioxin, a toxic chemical that persists in soil and food. Neighboring Laos, through which the trail ran, became one of the most heavily bombed countries per person in history, and unexploded cluster bombs still kill and maim farmers there today.

The southern soldier

The Army of the Republic of Vietnam, the South's army, has often been dismissed in American accounts as weak. Its record was mixed. Some units were poorly led by officers chosen for political loyalty, and desertion was a constant problem. Others fought hard and well. Over the whole war, South Vietnam's army lost far more soldiers killed than the American military, with estimates of roughly two hundred thousand to a quarter of a million dead.

The northern soldier

For young men and women in the north, the war meant a journey south down the trail that could last months, through malaria, hunger and bombing. Many soldiers did not expect to come home until the war was won, and many never did. Northern women served in large numbers in youth volunteer brigades that repaired roads and bridges under bombing, defused bombs and carried supplies. Party propaganda was everywhere, but letters and diaries show that many soldiers were moved by real patriotism and a sense that their families and nation depended on them, along with fear, homesickness and grief.

The insurgents underground

Near Saigon, guerrillas dug networks of tunnels with hiding places, kitchens, storerooms and field hospitals. The Cu Chi tunnels northwest of Saigon stretched for well over a hundred kilometers. For the guerrillas, life underground meant darkness, foul air and disease, but it let them survive in areas their enemy claimed to control.

The American soldier

About 2.7 million Americans served in Vietnam. College deferments meant the draft fell more heavily on working class and poor young men, though a lottery introduced in 1969 reduced some of the unfairness. Unlike in earlier wars, soldiers served a tour of about one year and then went home as individuals, so units constantly lost experienced men and absorbed new ones. Morale fell sharply after 1969 as the war wound down without clear purpose, with drug use, racial tension and attacks on unpopular officers. Some soldiers committed atrocities, the worst known being the massacre of hundreds of villagers at My Lai in March 1968. Others risked their lives to prevent or report such crimes. Many veterans came home to a country that preferred not to think about the war, and some struggled for years with what would later be recognized as post-traumatic stress.

Worked example: weighing the legacy of Agent Orange

How should a historian assess the long-term harm of the herbicide campaign? Evidence comes from several directions. American veterans who handled or were exposed to the spray reported cancers and other illnesses, and after years of dispute the United States government accepted that a list of diseases could be presumed linked to exposure and paid compensation. Vietnamese authorities and the Vietnam Red Cross have said that millions of Vietnamese were exposed, and they attribute many birth defects to dioxin.

The historian must separate what is well established from what is still debated. That dioxin is highly toxic and lingered at former air bases such as Da Nang and Bien Hoa is well established, and the United States has funded cleanup at both. The number of Vietnamese harmed is much harder to fix, because wartime health records are poor, exposure is hard to measure decades later, and figures have been used for political purposes on all sides. A careful account would acknowledge real and serious harm while being honest about uncertainty in the numbers. It would also note an imbalance that troubled many observers: American veterans won compensation from their government, while a lawsuit brought by Vietnamese victims against American chemical makers was dismissed by American courts in 2005.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What happened to millions of South Vietnamese during the fighting?
2. What did American aircraft spray over South Vietnam from 1962 to 1971?
3. Which toxic chemical contaminated Agent Orange?
4. How did South Vietnamese army deaths compare with American military deaths?
5. What did many northern women do in youth volunteer brigades?
6. How far did the Cu Chi tunnels northwest of Saigon stretch?
7. Why did the draft fall more heavily on working class and poor young men?
8. How long was the standard tour for an American soldier in Vietnam?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia