Skip to main content

Visitors to Venice in the sixteenth century were less impressed by its palaces than by its politics. Here was a state that had kept its independence for centuries, had never been ruled by a tyrant or a foreign king, and had avoided the revolutions that tore through Florence, Milan and Genoa. Venetians called it the Serenissima, the Most Serene Republic. Understanding how it worked means looking at its councils, its doge and the people it left out.

The Great Council and its closing

The foundation of the system was the Great Council, the assembly of adult male nobles from which every other council and office was filled. In the thirteenth century its membership changed from year to year. In 1297 a reform known as the Serrata, the "closing", made membership permanent for men who had sat in the council in the previous four years, along with others approved by vote. Over the next decades entry was narrowed until the council became a hereditary body. From the early sixteenth century noble births and marriages were recorded in registers later called the Golden Book, so that no one could claim a seat without proof of descent. By then the council had well over two thousand members, many of them poor.

The doge: a prince in a cage

At the top sat the doge, elected for life, dressed in gold and ermine, and surrounded by ceremony. His real power was carefully limited. At his election each doge swore the promissione, an oath listing the limits on his power, which grew longer with each reign. He could not open letters from foreign rulers except in the presence of his councillors, could not leave Venice without permission, and his family could not hold certain offices. Six ducal councillors sat beside him at all times. The doge presided, persuaded and represented the state, but he could not rule alone.

Senate, Collegio and Ten

Real business ran through smaller bodies. The Senate, a few hundred senior nobles, handled foreign policy, war, trade and finance. The Collegio, a steering committee, prepared its agenda and received ambassadors. For security there was the Council of Ten. In June 1310 a group of nobles led by Bajamonte Tiepolo tried to seize power and was defeated in street fighting. The Council of Ten was created that year in response to the Tiepolo conspiracy, first as an emergency body. It was made permanent in the 1330s and grew into a powerful committee for state security, secret diplomacy and the policing of nobles themselves.

The system punished even the highest. In 1355 the doge Marino Faliero was beheaded for plotting to make himself lord of Venice. In the great hall of the Doge's Palace, where portraits of the doges run along the walls, his place is painted over with a black cloth bearing a note on his crimes.

Rules against ambition

Many Venetian rules aimed to stop any one man or family from dominating. Most offices lasted only months or a year or two, and a man often had to wait before holding the same office again. Open campaigning for office was forbidden, though nobles canvassed anyway in the arcades by the Doge's Palace. Voting was secret, with cloth-covered urns and small balls of linen, so that a noble could vote against a powerful neighbor without being seen.

Who was left out

The nobles were a small minority, perhaps four or five percent of the population. Below them sat the cittadini, a privileged class of citizens who staffed the state chancery and ran the great confraternities. Reserved posts, up to grand chancellor, gave them a stake in the system. Below them were the popolani, the artisans, boatmen, laborers and servants who made up most of the city, together with foreigners, Jews and slaves. They had no vote, though guilds and confraternities gave many of them a voice in their own affairs. Venice was a republic, but a republic of a few.

Worked example: how to elect a doge

From 1268 the Great Council chose a doge by a procedure designed to defeat factions. On the day of the election, the youngest member of the Signoria, the doge's council, went to pray in San Marco and then took the first boy he met in the square to draw the lots. Then came ten steps. The doge was chosen through ten alternating rounds of lot and election:

First, 30 members were picked by lot, and their number was cut by lot to 9. The 9 elected 40, each needing at least 7 votes. The 40 were cut by lot to 12, who elected 25. The 25 were cut by lot to 9, who elected 45. The 45 were cut by lot to 11, who elected 41. Finally the 41 elected the doge, who needed at least 25 of their votes.

Why so complicated? Lot made it almost impossible for a faction to know in advance who would be choosing, so bribes and promises were hard to target. The rounds of election let the council's judgment back in, so that a fool chosen by chance could be screened out. And the high thresholds of votes forced electors to compromise. The method did not stop all intrigue, and doges were often elderly men picked because they posed no threat. But for five centuries it produced rulers without civil war, an achievement few states of the age could claim.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was the Great Council?
2. What did the registers later called the Golden Book record?
3. What was the promissione?
4. Why was the Council of Ten first created in 1310?
5. Why was Marino Faliero beheaded in 1355?
6. Who were the cittadini?
7. How was the doge chosen from 1268?
8. How large a share of the population were the nobles?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia