Skip to main content

In May 1568 a defeated queen crossed the Solway Firth in a fishing boat and landed in England. Mary, Queen of Scots, had been forced to abdicate in favor of her infant son. She was also Elizabeth's cousin and, in the eyes of many Catholics, her rightful heir or even the rightful queen. Elizabeth could not let her go to France, could not restore her by force and could not safely set her free. She kept her. Mary was held captive in England for nearly nineteen years, and she became the center of almost every plot of the reign.

The Northern Rising

The first great challenge came in November 1569, when the earls of Northumberland and Westmorland led a Catholic rising in the north. The rebels heard mass in Durham Cathedral and marched south, hoping to free Mary. They found little support beyond their own tenants, and the rising collapsed within weeks. Hundreds of poor rebels were hanged in villages across the north.

Priests and penalties

English Catholicism might have faded slowly without priests. In 1568 the exiled scholar William Allen founded a college at Douai in the Spanish Netherlands to train English priests for a mission to their homeland. Hundreds crossed secretly to England over the following decades. Jesuits joined them in 1580, among them Edmund Campion, who was captured, racked and executed in 1581.

Parliament raised the stakes. From 1581 recusants, those who refused to attend Protestant services, could be fined twenty pounds a month, a sum that could ruin a gentry family within a few years. The government insisted it punished treason, not faith. Catholics replied that they were being killed for being priests.

The Bond of Association

After the Throckmorton Plot of 1583, which aimed at a French invasion, and the murder of the Dutch rebel leader William of Orange in 1584, Elizabeth's councillors feared she would be next. In 1584 thousands of gentlemen signed the Bond of Association, swearing to kill anyone in whose favor a plot against the queen was made, whether that person had known of it or not. In practice, that meant Mary.

The trap

The queen's secretary Sir Francis Walsingham ran a network of informers and codebreakers. In 1586 a young Catholic gentleman, Anthony Babington, plotted to murder Elizabeth and free Mary. Walsingham let the plot run. Mary's secret letters were carried hidden in the beer barrels delivered to her house, by a courier who worked for Walsingham, and his codebreaker Thomas Phelippes read every one. When Mary wrote approving the plan, the trap closed. Babington and his friends were executed, and Mary was tried and condemned.

Elizabeth hesitated for months before signing the death warrant. Mary was beheaded at Fotheringhay Castle on 8 February 1587. The queen then claimed the warrant had been sent without her consent, and she blamed her secretary William Davison, who was fined and imprisoned.

The Armada

Philip II of Spain was already at war with England, which had sent troops to help the Dutch rebels in 1585. In 1588 he launched the Armada, about 130 ships under the Duke of Medina Sidonia. The plan was for the fleet to escort the Duke of Parma's army across from the Netherlands to invade England.

The fleet sailed up the Channel in a tight crescent while English ships harried it from a distance. It anchored off Calais, but Parma's army was not ready. On the night of 7 to 8 August the English sent fireships into the anchorage, and the Spanish cut their cables and scattered. A fierce battle followed off Gravelines. Then the wind drove the Armada into the North Sea. To get home it sailed around Scotland and Ireland, where autumn storms wrecked many ships. Perhaps a third of the fleet never returned.

A puzzle for readers: English records date the fireships to the night of 28 to 29 July. England still used the old Julian calendar, ten days behind the Gregorian calendar adopted in Spain in 1582. Both sets of dates are correct.

Worked example: the speech at Tilbury

While the Armada was still at sea, Elizabeth visited her army at Tilbury on the Thames. The best known version of her speech has her say: "I know I have the body of a weak and feeble woman; but I have the heart and stomach of a king, and of a king of England too."

How do we know she said it? The text comes from a letter by Leonel Sharp, a chaplain who said he was present and was ordered to repeat the speech to the troops. His letter was written years later, and it was first printed in 1654. Other accounts from 1588 confirm that she rode among the soldiers and spoke, but they do not give these words.

So weigh it. For: Sharp was there, and the phrasing fits Elizabeth's known style, which often turned her sex into an argument. Against: the text appears long after the event, from a man with reasons to remember it well. Many historians accept that the speech is close to what she said, while admitting it cannot be proved. The case shows a common situation: the most famous words in a story are often the hardest to verify.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How long was Mary, Queen of Scots, held captive in England?
2. Who led the Northern Rising of 1569?
3. What did William Allen found at Douai in 1568?
4. What could recusants be fined from 1581?
5. What did signers of the Bond of Association swear?
6. How were Mary's secret letters carried in 1586?
7. What happened at Calais on the night of 7 to 8 August 1588?
8. Whom did Elizabeth blame for sending Mary's death warrant?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia