Skip to main content

When the fighting ended, travelers in the Yangzi delta described empty towns, collapsed bridges and fields gone back to weeds. Some of the richest country in China had become a wasteland.

Counting the dead

Most estimates put the deaths at about 20 to 30 million, from battle, massacre, famine and disease. Some demographers, counting both deaths and births that never happened across the affected provinces, put the population loss much higher, as high as about 70 million. Either way, most of the dead were civilians. Many counties in Jiangsu, Zhejiang and Anhui lost half their people or more, and the region took decades to recover, partly by settling migrants from Hunan, Henan and elsewhere on abandoned land.

Not one rebellion but many

The Taiping were the largest of several uprisings. The Nian rebellion, from 1851 to 1868, was fought on the north China plain between the Huai and Yellow rivers. The Nian were mounted bands, rooted in fortified villages, who raided across several provinces. Their region suffered terribly when the Yellow River broke its banks in 1855 and shifted to a new course north of the Shandong peninsula. Li Hongzhang and Zeng Guofan finally wore them down by blockading their home districts. Senggelinqin, the Mongol prince who had destroyed the Taiping Northern Expedition, was killed fighting the Nian in 1865.

In the southwest, the Panthay rebellion was a Muslim uprising in Yunnan from 1856 to 1873, under Du Wenxiu, who ruled a state from the city of Dali. In the northwest, a Muslim rebellion in Shaanxi and Gansu began in 1862 and was crushed by Zuo Zongtang by 1873, followed by his reconquest of Xinjiang in 1877 and 1878. Miao peoples rose in Guizhou. Each of these wars killed people in the hundreds of thousands or millions.

A dynasty patched together

The Qing survived, which surprised many observers. In 1861 the Xianfeng emperor died, and a palace coup placed power in the hands of the Empress Dowager Cixi and Prince Gong, ruling for the boy Tongzhi emperor. The recovery that followed is called the Tongzhi Restoration. Officials rebuilt academies, resumed examinations in recaptured areas, cut taxes in the ruined delta and promoted Confucian moral teaching.

New institutions appeared too. The Zongli Yamen was a foreign affairs office set up in 1861, the first Qing body to deal with Western states as equals rather than as tributaries. The Imperial Maritime Customs, staffed partly by foreigners under the Irishman Robert Hart from 1863, collected duties efficiently and gave Beijing a steady income. Zeng Guofan and Li Hongzhang began building arsenals and shipyards.

Where power went

The historian Philip Kuhn argued that the war moved power toward the provinces and local gentry. Militias, regional armies and lijin revenue gave governors and local elites resources that Beijing could not easily reclaim, and some historians trace a long line from Zeng's army to the warlords of the early twentieth century. Others caution against drawing that line too straight. Zeng disbanded most of his army in 1864, and the court still appointed and moved governors at will. The fair conclusion is that the Qing survived by sharing power it never fully recovered.

Memory and its uses

Later revolutionaries claimed the Taiping. According to later accounts, the young Sun Yat-sen, who grew up in Guangdong hearing stories of the rebels, liked to call himself a second Hong Xiuquan. Chinese Communists praised the Taiping as a great peasant revolution, and the Monument to the People's Heroes in Beijing includes a relief of the Jintian uprising. Zeng Guofan was for decades condemned as an executioner who served foreign Manchu masters; since the 1980s he has been widely celebrated in China as a model of discipline and self-cultivation.

Recent historians have turned toward those whom both sides forgot. The historian Tobie Meyer-Fong studied the war's ordinary victims and how survivors mourned them, through funeral rites, charity and local memorials. Her work asks us to see the war not as a contest of heroes but as a catastrophe endured by millions who simply wanted to live.

Worked example: weighing a death toll

Suppose a county's records listed 600,000 people in the 1840s and 200,000 in the 1870s. A first reading says 400,000 died, two thirds of the population. Now look closer. Perhaps 60,000 people fled and settled elsewhere for good, so they left the county without dying. Perhaps record keeping collapsed after the war and the later count missed one person in ten, so the true figure was about 222,000. Then the population fell by about 378,000, and the number who left alive must be taken from that, leaving about 318,000 who died or were never born.

Each adjustment is reasonable, and each changes the total by tens of thousands. Repeat this across hundreds of counties and the national figure can swing by tens of millions. That is why careful historians give ranges, explain their methods and stay humble about precision. The range does not weaken the moral point. Whether the toll was twenty million or seventy, each number was a person.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What range do most estimates give for deaths in the Taiping war?
2. Where was the Nian rebellion fought?
3. What was the Panthay rebellion?
4. Who held power in Beijing after the coup of 1861?
5. What was the Zongli Yamen?
6. What did Philip Kuhn argue about the war's effects?
7. What does the Monument to the People's Heroes in Beijing include?
8. What did Tobie Meyer-Fong's work focus on?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia