A lone genius in a study is the popular picture of science. The seventeenth century did produce brilliant individuals, but one of its biggest inventions was collective: new ways for people who studied nature to meet, share results, argue and keep records.
Bacon's dream
Francis Bacon (1561 to 1626), lawyer and Lord Chancellor of England, believed the old learning had stalled for want of organization. The title page of his Great Instauration (1620) shows a ship sailing out between the Pillars of Hercules, the ancient limit of the known world, a promise that knowledge too could pass old boundaries. In his unfinished fable New Atlantis, published in 1627 after his death, sailors land on an island guided by a learned order. Bacon's New Atlantis imagined Salomon's House, a research college supported by the state, with teams that gathered reports, ran experiments, built instruments and drew general rules from the results. Later founders of scientific societies cited it as their model.
Lynxes and letters
The first such society had already appeared. In 1603 a young Roman nobleman, Federico Cesi, founded the Accademia dei Lincei. The Lincei took their name from the lynx, famed for its sharp sight, and Galileo proudly signed himself a Lincean. The academy did not long survive Cesi's death in 1630.
Much exchange happened by post, in what contemporaries called the Republic of Letters. Its great hub in the 1630s and 1640s was a friar in Paris. Marin Mersenne, a Paris friar, linked scholars across Europe by passing their letters, questions and results to one another. He spread news of Torricelli's mercury experiment in France and kept Descartes in touch with the world from his Dutch retreat.
Florence, London, Paris
In Florence the Medici princes sponsored the Accademia del Cimento, the "academy of experiment", from 1657 to 1667, with the motto "by trying and trying again". When its findings were published in 1667, no individual was named. The Cimento published its findings as the work of the group, without naming individual authors.
In London a group began meeting in 1660 after a lecture at Gresham College and received a royal charter as the Royal Society in 1662. The king gave his name, but not money: fellows paid fees, often late. France took another path. In 1666 Louis XIV's minister Jean-Baptiste Colbert created the Royal Academy of Sciences. Unlike the Royal Society, the Paris Academy paid its members salaries from the crown, and it recruited foreign stars such as the Dutch physicist Christiaan Huygens and the Italian astronomer Giovanni Domenico Cassini.
Print and priority
Journals followed. The Journal des sçavans in Paris first appeared in January 1665, two months before London's Philosophical Transactions, which the Royal Society's secretary Henry Oldenburg ran as his own venture. In 1667, during a war with the Dutch, Oldenburg's many foreign letters made him suspect, and he spent about two months in the Tower of London. The Royal Society also prized a new kind of prose. Its first historian, Thomas Sprat, praised members in 1667 for preferring "a close, naked, natural way of speaking" to ornament.
Getting credit was a constant worry. A discovery announced too early might be stolen; one kept too long might be claimed by someone else. Scientists hid discoveries in anagrams to claim priority without revealing what they had found. Galileo sent a scrambled Latin sentence about Saturn in 1610. Huygens did the same for Saturn's ring in 1656. In 1676 Hooke published the letters "ceiiinosssttuv", unscrambled two years later as a Latin phrase meaning "as the extension, so the force", his law of springs.
Nor were the doors open to all. When Margaret Cavendish, Duchess of Newcastle, a prolific author of poetry, plays and natural philosophy, wrote about the new instruments in 1666, she took a skeptical line. Cavendish argued that microscopes can distort what they show, so reason must judge their images.
Worked example: a duchess at the Royal Society
On 30 May 1667 a crowd gathered to watch an unusual visitor. Cavendish had asked to attend a meeting of the Royal Society, and no woman had done so before. Boyle and Hooke put on demonstrations for her: weighing air, mixing liquids that changed color, and showing a magnet. Samuel Pepys, there that day, wrote more about her dress than about anything she said.
Cavendish was not a starstruck guest. A year earlier, in her Observations upon Experimental Philosophy, she had argued that a magnified flea is a picture shaped by glass and light, and that lenses can mislead as well as reveal. She came to the room where those instruments were most admired.
The episode tests the new science's ideals. Its institutions claimed that anyone could check a fact, regardless of rank. In practice the community was made of gentlemen, and the Royal Society did not elect a woman as a fellow until 1945. Cavendish's critique was answered with a show rather than a debate. Yet her point, that instruments shape what we see, later became a serious question in thinking about science. Openness on paper and openness in practice are different things, and both are worth measuring.
