Skip to main content

Nicolaus Copernicus (1473 to 1543) spent most of his adult life as a canon, one of the officials who ran the affairs of the cathedral chapter at Frombork in Royal Prussia, then part of the Kingdom of Poland. Copernicus earned his living as a canon who helped run a cathedral chapter. He managed estates and practised medicine; astronomy filled the margins of a busy life.

What Copernicus wanted

Around 1514 he circulated a short handwritten sketch, the Commentariolus, proposing that the Earth turns daily on its axis and travels yearly around the Sun. His motive was not a new observation. It was a sense that Ptolemy's system had betrayed its own principles. To make his predictions work, Ptolemy had used a device called the equant, a point around which a planet moved at an even rate, though it was not the center of the planet's circle. Copernicus objected above all to Ptolemy's equant, which broke the rule that heavenly motion should be uniform and circular. Putting the Sun near the center also brought order: the planets fell into a sequence by distance, and their strange backward loops became an effect of watching from a moving Earth.

Rheticus and the printed book

For decades Copernicus held back the full work. The push came from an unlikely visitor. In 1539 Georg Joachim Rheticus, a 25-year-old mathematics professor from Wittenberg, the heart of the Lutheran Reformation, arrived in Catholic Frombork and stayed about two years. Rheticus, a young Lutheran mathematician from Wittenberg, persuaded Copernicus to publish. In 1540 Rheticus printed the First Account, a summary of the theory, and he carried the manuscript to a printer in Nuremberg. The book appeared in 1543 with an unsigned preface by the Lutheran theologian Andreas Osiander, telling readers to treat it as a calculating device. Copernicus died that same year, by tradition just as a printed copy reached him.

Readers who took the math and left the motion

The first serious readers were mostly Lutheran professors. Erasmus Reinhold at Wittenberg admired Copernicus's geometry, used it to build new planetary tables, the Prussian Tables of 1551, and said little about whether the Earth really moved. The historian Robert Westman named this approach the "Wittenberg interpretation". The Wittenberg interpretation used Copernicus's mathematics while leaving the Earth at rest. For working astronomers the useful thing was better numbers, not a new cosmos.

Few went further. Westman counted only about ten thinkers who fully accepted the moving Earth between 1543 and 1600. The objections were weighty. The Earth felt still, and nobody could explain why falling stones and clouds were not left behind. Several Bible passages spoke of the Sun moving. And if the Earth circled the Sun, nearby stars should seem to shift during the year, yet none did. Copernicans answered that the stars must be unimaginably far away. The English astronomer Thomas Digges went bolder. In 1576 Thomas Digges pictured the stars scattered without end through infinite space, breaking the outermost sphere that had closed the cosmos.

Tycho and the changing sky

The heaviest blows against the old heavens came from a man who never accepted the moving Earth. In November 1572 a brilliant new star appeared in the constellation Cassiopeia. The Danish nobleman Tycho Brahe measured it night after night and found that it never shifted against the stars around it, as the nearby Moon would have done. Tycho showed that the new star of 1572 lay beyond the Moon, proving that the heavens could change. Tycho's measurements placed the great comet of 1577 far beyond the Moon too. The comet of 1577 seemed to pass straight through the solid spheres thought to carry the planets, and many astronomers began to doubt that such spheres existed at all.

Was the book read?

In 1959 the writer Arthur Koestler suggested that On the Revolutions was a book nobody had read. The Harvard astronomer Owen Gingerich set out to test the claim by examining surviving copies of the first two editions, of 1543 and 1566, in libraries around the world, about 600 in all. Gingerich found that working astronomers had carefully annotated many copies, correcting misprints and working through the technical chapters.

Worked example: what the margins reveal

Gingerich's census turned bookkeeping into evidence. Some copies carried nearly identical notes, which he traced back to Reinhold's own annotations, copied from student to student like a shared set of lecture notes.

The census also tracked the Catholic Church's response. In 1616 the authorities in Rome suspended the book, and in 1620 they issued a short list of changes: delete a few sentences that called the Earth's motion real, and soften others to sound hypothetical. In Italy, most copies Gingerich examined had been corrected by hand as ordered. Outside Italy, few had. The censorship was patchy and fairly light, aimed at claims of truth rather than at the calculations.

Notice the method. Instead of asking what famous people said about the book, Gingerich asked what ordinary owners did to it. Ink in margins, crossed-out lines and copied notes became a record of how ideas actually travelled. The finding cut both ways: astronomers read Copernicus closely, yet mostly as a technical manual. Accepting the moving Earth as physical truth took most of another century.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Copernicus earn his living?
2. What did Copernicus most dislike in Ptolemy's astronomy?
3. Who persuaded Copernicus to publish his full work?
4. What was the Wittenberg interpretation of Copernicus?
5. What did Thomas Digges propose in 1576?
6. What did Tycho show about the new star of 1572?
7. Why did the comet of 1577 trouble the old picture of the heavens?
8. What did Owen Gingerich's census of early copies find?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia