Skip to main content

By 1914 the partition was nearly complete, and the outbreak of war in Europe soon turned colonies into battlefields. Historians have argued ever since about what the Scramble meant and what it left behind. Those arguments are not only academic: they shape how people think about borders, development and responsibility today.

The map in 1914

France and Britain held the largest shares, France across the west and north, Britain from Egypt to the Cape and along the west coast. Germany held four African colonies in 1914: Togo, Kamerun, South West Africa and German East Africa. Belgium had taken over the Congo, Portugal held Angola and Mozambique, and Spain kept small territories. The last gaps closed shortly before the war. Italy seized Libya from the Ottoman Empire in 1911 and 1912, and France made most of Morocco a protectorate in 1912 after a crisis with Germany, with Spain taking a northern zone.

When war came in August 1914, the colonies were drawn in at once. Togo fell to British and French forces within weeks, and Africans were recruited as soldiers and carriers in their hundreds of thousands, fighting in a quarrel that was not their own.

Did colonialism develop or underdevelop Africa?

The Guyanese historian Walter Rodney gave a forceful answer in How Europe Underdeveloped Africa (1972). He argued that colonialism drained Africa's wealth and blocked its development, turning economies toward raw exports, extracting labor and profits, and starving education and industry. His book shaped a generation of African scholarship and activism.

At the other pole, the historians Lewis Gann and Peter Duignan argued in the 1960s that colonial rule was on balance an engine of modernization, bringing railways, ports, medicine, schools and the rule of law. Their critics answer that Africans paid for most of this through taxes and forced labor, that the benefits went mainly to settlers, firms and a small elite, and that similar or greater gains might have come without conquest. Most historians now avoid a single balance sheet and ask instead who gained, who lost, and when.

Measuring legacies

Economists have tried to test some claims with data. Stelios Michalopoulos and Elias Papaioannou, studying ethnic homelands split by colonial borders, found that partitioned ethnic homelands have seen more political violence since independence than homelands left whole. The political scientist Jeffrey Herbst made a different point: colonial states rarely extended firm control far beyond capitals and key economic zones, leaving independent governments with weak reach over large, thinly populated territories. Such studies give evidence for particular mechanisms, though critics warn that numbers can hide the variety of colonial experience.

Public memory has moved too. Germany has returned human remains taken from Namibia, and in 2020 Belgium's king wrote to Congo's president expressing deep regret for the violence and cruelty of the colonial period, though he stopped short of a formal apology. Such gestures show that the Scramble is still argued over not only by scholars but by governments, descendants and citizens who ask what is owed for wrongs committed more than a century ago.

The borders themselves remain disputed ground. Defenders note that many precolonial states had shifting, overlapping frontiers, and that some colonial lines followed rivers, watersheds or the limits of existing kingdoms. Critics answer that even such lines were chosen for European convenience, and that much of the harm came from what the lines became: hard, guarded boundaries that cut across trade routes, grazing lands and families that had once moved freely.

African agency

Since the 1960s historians have stressed African agency: the idea that Africans' own choices and strategies shaped how conquest and colonial rule unfolded. This corrects older stories in which Europeans acted and Africans were acted upon. It also carries a risk. Celebrating clever kings and successful cocoa farmers can obscure how narrow the choices were, and how much power lay with those who held the guns and wrote the laws. A fair history keeps both truths in view.

Why it matters

The Scramble rested on the idea that some peoples could be governed without their consent because they were held to be lesser. The treaties, the forced labor, the camps and the courts that punished without trial all followed from that premise. Recognizing it helps explain why the struggle against colonial rule was, at its root, a claim to equal human worth.

Worked example: the mountain and the myth

The border between Kenya and Tanzania runs as a straight line from the Indian Ocean toward Lake Victoria, except for a bend near Mount Kilimanjaro that places the mountain in Tanzania. Visitors are often told why: Queen Victoria supposedly gave the mountain to her grandson, the German Kaiser Wilhelm II, as a birthday present.

The evidence does not support the story. The line was set in an Anglo-German agreement of 1886, negotiated by officials, when Wilhelm was not yet emperor. Germany's claim to the Kilimanjaro area rested on treaties its agents had made with Chagga rulers there, while Britain secured its interests around Mombasa. No document records a royal gift. Testing the myth teaches two lessons. First, popular stories often turn hard bargaining into royal whimsy. Second, even the true story leaves out the people who lived on the mountain, who were not asked which empire they wished to belong to.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How many African colonies did Germany hold in 1914?
2. What did Italy do in 1911 and 1912?
3. What did France do in Morocco in 1912?
4. What did Walter Rodney argue in 1972?
5. What did Gann and Duignan argue about colonial rule?
6. What did Michalopoulos and Papaioannou find about partitioned homelands?
7. What did Jeffrey Herbst argue about colonial states?
8. What does the idea of "African agency" emphasize?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia