When the RPF took power in July 1994, Rwanda was a country of the dead and the displaced. Hundreds of thousands of survivors were wounded, widowed or orphaned; perpetrators lived in camps across the border or on the next hill. How do you do justice when the guilty number in the tens of thousands and the courts have been destroyed? Rwanda tried three answers at once, and each taught the world something.
An international tribunal
On 8 November 1994 the UN Security Council created the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR). Rwanda, which then held a seat on the Council, voted against it. Its government objected that the tribunal would sit outside the country, could not impose the death penalty and covered only crimes committed in 1994. The tribunal was based in Arusha, Tanzania.
Its first judgment made history. On 2 September 1998 it convicted Jean-Paul Akayesu, the burgomaster of Taba commune, of genocide. It was the first time an international court had convicted anyone of genocide under the 1948 convention. The judgment also held, for the first time, that rape and sexual violence could be acts of genocide when committed with intent to destroy a group. The charges of sexual violence were added only after a witness spoke of rapes in court and the judges, including Navanethem Pillay, pressed prosecutors to investigate. That same year Jean Kambanda, the interim prime minister, pleaded guilty to genocide, the first head of government convicted of that crime.
The ICTR closed at the end of 2015 after indicting 93 people and convicting more than sixty, including Colonel Bagosora. Critics noted its slowness, its cost and its failure to try any RPF soldiers for crimes committed in 1994. Félicien Kabuga, the financier of RTLM, was arrested in France in 2020 after decades on the run, but judges later ruled him unfit for trial because of dementia.
Gacaca: justice on the grass
Rwanda's own courts held trials from 1996, and in 1998 twenty two people convicted of genocide were publicly executed. Rwanda abolished the death penalty in 2007. But with more than 100,000 suspects in overcrowded prisons, ordinary trials would have taken a century. The government turned to an old practice. Gacaca, from a Kinyarwanda word for the grass where elders met to settle disputes, became a national system of community courts. After a pilot phase, about twelve thousand gacaca courts worked across the country from 2005 until 2012. Their judges were elected local people of integrity, called inyangamugayo, and trials were held in the open with neighbors as witnesses.
Gacaca handled nearly two million cases. Defendants who confessed and apologized could receive reduced sentences, often partly served in community work. Supporters credit gacaca with revealing where bodies lay, letting survivors learn how relatives died, and returning many prisoners home. Critics, including human rights groups, pointed to the lack of defense lawyers, intimidation of witnesses, false accusations and the rule that kept crimes by RPF soldiers out of its reach.
Memory and unity
The new government removed ethnic labels from identity cards and promoted a single Rwandan identity. Laws against "divisionism" and "genocide ideology" made it a crime to stir up ethnic hatred, and critics say they have also been used to silence opponents. Each year from 7 April the country holds Kwibuka, meaning "remember," a national period of mourning. In 2018 the UN General Assembly adopted the name "genocide against the Tutsi" for its annual day of reflection, recognizing who was targeted while noting that others were killed too.
Rwanda since 1994
Paul Kagame led the country as vice president and minister of defense and has been president since 2000, winning elections with official results above 90 percent. Under his government Rwanda has rebuilt roads, cut child mortality and grown its economy quickly, and women hold an unusually large share of public offices. Critics point to jailed and exiled opponents, a tightly controlled press and Rwanda's armed interventions in neighboring Congo, where its forces pursued genocidaires in the refugee camps from 1996 and where UN investigators have documented grave abuses by Rwandan troops and allied rebels. Both the achievement and the repression are real, and Rwandans and outside observers weigh them differently.
Worked example: a hearing on the hill
Imagine a gacaca session in 2006 under a tree in a rural sector. Nine inyangamugayo sit on a bench; several hundred residents sit on the grass. A man in the pink uniform of a prisoner stands to confess that in April 1994 he joined a group that searched a banana grove and killed a woman and her two children. He names the others. The woman's surviving sister asks where the bodies were left, and he tells her. The judges reduce his sentence because he confessed, and order part of it served in community work.
Apply this level's ideas. The hearing delivers truths no distant tribunal could. Yet the man has no lawyer, the crowd may pressure witnesses, and no one here may raise killings by the soldiers of the new army. Gacaca offered a kind of justice built for numbers that would overwhelm any court. Whether it brought reconciliation, or only coexistence, is a question Rwandans still answer for themselves, family by family and hill by hill.
